首页
外语
计算机
考研
公务员
职业资格
财经
工程
司法
医学
专升本
自考
实用职业技能
登录
外语
You should spend about 20 minutes on Questions 27-40, which are based on Reading Passage 3 below. Lang
You should spend about 20 minutes on Questions 27-40, which are based on Reading Passage 3 below. Lang
admin
2015-01-05
32
问题
You should spend about 20 minutes on Questions 27-40, which are based on Reading Passage 3 below.
Language diversity
One of the most influential ideas in the study of languages is thatof universal grammar(UG). Put forward by Noam Chomsky in the 1960s, it is widely interpreted as meaning that all languages are basically the same, and that the human brain is born language-ready, with an in-built programme that is able to interpret the common rules underlying any mother tongue. For five decades this idea prevailed, and influenced work in linguistics, psychology and cognitive science. To understand language, it implied, you must sweep aside the huge diversity of languages, and find their common human core.
Since the theory of UG was proposed, linguists have identified many universal language rules. However, there are almost always exceptions. It was once believed, for example, that if a language had syllables* that begin with a vowel and end with a consonant(VC), it would also have syllables that begin with a consonant and end with a vowel(CV). This universal lasted until 1999, when linguists showed that Arrernte, spoken by Indigenous Australians from the area around Alice Springs in the Northern Territory, has VC syllables but no CV syllables.
Other non-universal universals describe the basic rules of putting words together. Take the rule that every language contains four basic word classes: nouns, verbs, adjectives and adverbs. Work in the past two decades has shown that several languages lack an open adverb class, which means that new adverbs cannot be readily formed, unlike in English where you can turn any adjective into an adverb, for example ’soft’ into ’softly’. Others, such as Lao, spoken in Laos, have no adjectives at all. More controversially, some linguists argue that a few languages, such as Straits Salish, spoken by indigenous people from north-western regions of North America, do not even have distinct nouns or verbs. Instead, they have a single class of words to include events, objects and qualities.
Even apparently indisputable universals have been found lacking. This includes recursion, or the ability to infinitely place one grammatical unit inside a similar unit, such as ’Jack thinks that Mary thinks that... the bus will be on time’. It is widely considered to be the most essential characteristic of human language, one that sets it apart from the communications of all other animals. Yet Dan Everett at Illinois State University recently published controversial work showing that Amazonian Piraha does not have this quality.
But what if the very diversity of languages is the key to understanding human communication? Linguists Nicholas Evans of the Australian National University in Canberra, and Stephen Levinson of the Max Planck Institute for Psycholinguistics in Nijmegen, the Netherlands, believe that languages do not share a common set of rules. Instead, they say, their sheer variety is a defining feature of human communication -something not seen in other animals. While there is no doubt that human thinking influences the form that language takes, if Evans and Levinson are correct, language in turn shapes our brains. This suggests that humans are more diverse than we thought, with our brains having differences depending on the language environment in which we grew up. And that leads to a disturbing conclusion: every time a language becomes extinct, humanity loses an important piece of diversity.
If languages do not obey a single set of shared rules, then how are they created? ’Instead of universals, you get standard engineering solutions that languages adopt again and again, and then you get outliers,’ says Evans. He and Levinson argue that this is because any given language is a complex system shaped by many factors, including culture, genetics and history. There are no absolutely universal traits of language, they say, only tendencies. And it is a mix of strong and weak tendencies that characterises the ’bio-cultural’ mix that we call language.
According to the two linguists, the strong tendencies explain why many languages display common patterns. A variety of factors tend to push language in a similar direction, such as the structure of the brain, the biology of speech, and the efficiencies of communication. Widely shared linguistic elements may also be ones that build on a particularly human kind of reasoning. For example, the fact that before we learn to speak we perceive the world as a place full of things causing actions(agents)and things having actions done to them(patients)explains why most languages deploy these grammatical categories.
Weak tendencies, in contrast, are explained by the idiosyncrasies of different languages. Evans and Levinson argue that many aspects of the particular natural history of a population may affect its language. For instance, Andy Butcher at Flinders University in Adelaide, South Australia, has observed that indigenous Australian children have by far the highest incidence of chronic middle-ear infection of any population on the planet, and that most indigenous Australian languages lack many sounds that are common in other languages, but which are hard to hear with a middle-ear infection. Whether this condition has shaped the sound systems of these languages is unknown, says Evans, but it is important to consider the idea.
Levinson and Evans are not the first to question the theory of universal grammar, but no one has summarised these ideas quite as persuasively, and given them as much reach. As a result, their arguments have generated widespread enthusiasm, particularly among those linguists who are tired of trying to squeeze their findings into the straitjacket of ’absolute universals’. To some, it is the final nail in UG’s coffin. Michael Tomasello, co-director of the Max Planck Institute for Evolutionary Anthropology in Leipzig, Germany, has been a long-standing critic of the idea that all languages conform to a set of rules. ’Universal grammar is dead,’ he says.
* a unit of sound
Questions 27-32
Do the following statements agree with the views of the writer in Reading Passage 3?
Write
YES if the statement agrees with the claims of the writer
NO if the statement contradicts the claims of the writer
NOT GIVEN if it is impossible to say what the writer thinks about this
There is disagreement amongst linguists about an aspect of Straits Salish grammar.
选项
答案
Y
解析
PARAGRAPH 3 confirms that some linguists are controversial in arguing that languages, such as Straits Salish do not even have distinct nouns orverbs.
转载请注明原文地址:https://kaotiyun.com/show/iVNO777K
本试题收录于:
雅思阅读题库雅思(IELTS)分类
0
雅思阅读
雅思(IELTS)
相关试题推荐
Like______,ArcticscientistssequesteredonthePolemustaccustomthemselvestolongperiodsofsensory______,andregardall
Feministcriticshavelongdebatedtheextenttowhichgenderplaysaroleinthecreationandinterpretationoftexts.
Feministcriticshavelongdebatedtheextenttowhichgenderplaysaroleinthecreationandinterpretationoftexts.
African-Americanfilmmakersshouldbeinanenviableposition,forsincetheearly1990stherehasbeenasteadywaveof
Darwinproposedthetheoryofsexualselectiontoexplaintheoriginofostentatiousplumageincertainbirdspecies,mai
Akeyfeatureofquantuminformationscienceistheunderstandingthatgroupsoftwoormorequantumobjectscanhavesta
IfWilliamshadafault,itwasanalmostcomplete(i)______others,aproclivityborderingon(ii)______.
Truevertigoisnotmeredizzinessbut______motion:aninvoluntary,erroneousperceptionthatoneismoving.
Thespottedbowerbirdhasa(i)______foramassingthebrightshinyobjectsitneedsfordecoratingitsbower:itwillenterhou
随机试题
核医学的定义是
城市排水体制的选择主要表现在()。①环境保护方面比较;②排水管、渠系统规划布局方面的比较;③工程投资方面比较;④近远期关系方面比较;⑤施工管理方面比较
根据《水利水电工程合理使用年限及耐久性设计规范》SL654--2014,下列环境条件中,水工建筑物所处的侵蚀环境类别为二类的是()。
竣工验收阶段建设监理工作的主要任务包括()。
自然保护区核心区外围可以划定一定面积的缓冲区。该区可以进入从事()活动。
李某欲设立一家公司,但无奈资金不足,为此便向好友冯某借款50万元,为期两年。双方签订了书面借款合同,约定了借款用途、数额、期限和还款方式等内容,但并未对利息支付作出约定。****冯某要求李某为此借款合同提供担保,李某便请求另外两位好友王某和张某分别提供了
东方航空公司实行对教师机票六五折优惠,这实际上是吸引乘客的一种经营策略,该航空公司并没有实际让利,因为当某天航班的满员率超过90%时,就停售当天优惠价机票,而即使在高峰期,航班的满员率也很少超过90%。有座位空着,何不以优惠价促销它呢?以下哪项如果为真,将
某信息系统集成公司,根据市场需要从2013年初开始进入信息系统运营服务领域。公司为了加强管理,提高运营服务能力,企业通过了GB/T24405.1-2009idtISO20000-1:2005认证。2013年12月该公司与政府部门就某智能交通管理信
在汇编语言程序设计中,若调用不在本模块中的过程,则对该过程必须用伪操作命令 ( )说明。
私の作った餃子を食べてみて()。
最新回复
(
0
)