首页
外语
计算机
考研
公务员
职业资格
财经
工程
司法
医学
专升本
自考
实用职业技能
登录
外语
According to reports in major news outlets, a study published last week included a startling discovery: the nation’s Jewish popu
According to reports in major news outlets, a study published last week included a startling discovery: the nation’s Jewish popu
admin
2013-11-29
70
问题
According to reports in major news outlets, a study published last week included a startling discovery: the nation’s Jewish population is in shrinking. The study, the National Jewish Population Survey, found 5.2 million Jews living in the United States in 2000, a drop of 5 percent, or 300,000 people, since a similar study in 1990.What’s truly startling is that the reported decline is not true. Worse still, the sponsor of the $6 million study, United Jewish Communities, knows it.
Both it and the authors have openly admitted their doubts. They have acknowledged in interviews that the population totals for 2000 and 1990 were reached by different methods and are not directly comparable. The survey itself also cautions readers, in a dauntingly technical appendix, that judgment calls by the researchers may have led to an undercount. When the research director and project director were asked whether the data should be construed to indicate a declining Jewish population, they flatly answered no. In addition, other survey researchers interviewed pointed to other studies with population estimates as high as 6.7 million.
Despite all this, the two figures—5.2 million now, 5.5 million then—are listed by side in the survey, leaving the impression that the population has shrunk. The result, predictably, has been a rash of headlines trumpeting the illusionary decline, in turn touching off jeremiads by rabbis and. moralists condemning the religious laxity behind it. Whether out of ideology, ego, incompetence or a combination of all three, the respected charity has invented a crisis.
United Jewish Communities is the coordinating body for a national network of Jewish philanthropies with combined budgets of $2 billion. Its population surveys carry huge weight in shaping community policy. This is not the first time the survey has set off a false alarm. The last one, conducted by a predecessor organization, found that 52 percent of American Jews who married between 1985 and 1990 did so outside the faith. That number was a fabrication produced by including marriages in which neither party was Jewish by anyone’s definition, including the researchers.
Its publication created a huge stir, inspiring anguished sermons, books and conferences. It put liberals on the defensive, emboldened conservatives who reject full integration into society and alienated ordinary folks by the increasingly xenophobic tone of Jewish communal culture. The new survey, to its credit, retracts that figure and offers the latest survey has spawned a panic created by the last one.
So why did the organization flawed figures once again? Some scholars who have studied the survey believe the motivation then came partly out of a desire to shock straying Jews into greater observance. It’s too early to tell if that’s the case this time around. What is clear is the researchers did their job with little regard to how their data could be misconstrued. They used statistical models and question formats that, while internally sound, made the new survey incompatible with the previous one. For example, this time the researchers divided the population of 5.2 million into two groups—"highly involved" Jews and "people of Jewish background" — and posed most questions only to the first group. As a result, most findings about belief and observance refer only to a subgroup of American Jews, making comparisons to the past impossible.
We can’t afford to wait a decade before these figures are revised. The false population decline must be corrected before it further sours communal discourse. The United Jewish Communities owes it to itself and its public to step forward and state plainly what it knows to be true: American Jews are not disappearing.
How does the population survey get it wrong in 2000?
选项
A、The population total in 2000 was reached by different method from that in 1990.
B、There might be some problems with the judgment calls by the researchers.
C、United Jewish Communities offered not enough financial support to the survey.
D、It is the result of the rash of headlines leaving the impression that the population has declined.
答案
B
解析
答案在第二段:judgment calls by the researchers may have led to an undercount.
转载请注明原文地址:https://kaotiyun.com/show/2yZO777K
0
专业英语八级
相关试题推荐
ThebiggestproblemfacingChileasitpromotesitselfasatouristdestinationisthatitisattheendoftheearth.Itisto
AccordingtoOxfordEnglishDictionary,bookis"awrittenorprintedtreatiseorseriesoftreatises,occupyingseveralsheets
Studentswhopasstheexamcalled"the11-plus"inBritaincangoto
DumbandDumber,oneofthemodernclassicsofAmericancomedy,tellsthestoryofanaffableidiot,LloydChristmas,whofalls
Bynow,itshouldcomeasnosurprisewhenscientistsdiscoveryetanothercaseofexperiencechangingthebrain.Fromthesenso
Mostpeoplecomplainingaboutsleepingproblemsare
Itiscommonforstudentsinhighschooltowonderifcollegeeducationisreallyimportant.Manyhighschoolstudentsdon’ten
Specialistscallthefeelingswhichpeopleexperiencewhentheycometoanewenvironmentcultureshock.Therearethreestages
Specialistscallthefeelingswhichpeopleexperiencewhentheycometoanewenvironmentcultureshock.Therearethreestages
Specialistscallthefeelingswhichpeopleexperiencewhentheycometoanewenvironmentcultureshock.Therearethreestages
随机试题
甲出具一张本票给乙,乙将该本票背书转让给丙,丁作为乙的保证人在票据上签章。丙又将该本票背书转让给戊,戊作为持票人未按规定期限向出票人提示本票。根据票据法律制度的规定,下列选项中,戊不得行使追索权的有()。(2006年)
操作金属切削机床的危险大致存在两类。第一类是故障、能量中断、机械零件破损及其他功能紊乱造成的危险;第二类是安全措施错误、安全装置缺陷或定位不当造成的危险。下列金属切削机床作业的危险中,属于第二类危险的是()。
城市经济学成为一门独立的学科是在20世纪的()。
关于我国贷款管理制度的说法中,以下错误的有()
在金本位制下,1美元含金量为23.22格令,1英镑含金量为113.0016格令(格令是重量单位),当时在英美两国之间运送1英镑黄金的各项费用(运输、包装、保险)要花费3美分。在采用直接标价的前提下,如果需要比原来更少的本币就能兑换一定数量的外国货币,这
材料一:近日早晨,上海电台《音乐早餐》节目正在直播,与往常一样,主持人晓君和小畅在播音乐间隙用上海话聊天逗笑观众。有一名听众给他们发短信:“求你们不要说上海话了,我讨厌你们上海人!”之后,晓君语调认真地对这名观众说:“请你以团成一个团的姿势,然后慢慢地以比
在其他环境条件基本相似的情况下,行政管理幅度与管理层次的关系为()。
从所给的四个选项中,选择最合适的一个填入问号处,使之呈现一定的规律性:
Howbesttosolvethepollutionproblemsofacitysunksodeepwithinsulfurouscloudsthatitwasdescribedashellonearth?
一国两制
最新回复
(
0
)