首页
外语
计算机
考研
公务员
职业资格
财经
工程
司法
医学
专升本
自考
实用职业技能
登录
外语
Some things are best kept secret. It is hard, for instance, to argue that public interest dictates publishing the blueprints for
Some things are best kept secret. It is hard, for instance, to argue that public interest dictates publishing the blueprints for
admin
2014-09-09
75
问题
Some things are best kept secret. It is hard, for instance, to argue that public interest dictates publishing the blueprints for an atom bomb. The matter is less clear-cut, however, when scientific information that has the potential to wreak havoc might also stop that havoc happening. Take bird flu. It has killed more than 330 people since 2003. That may not sound many, but it amounts to 60% of the 570 known cases of the disease. The only reason the death toll is not higher is that those who succumbed caught the virus directly from a bird. Fortunately for everyone else, it does not pass easily from person to person.
But it might. That is the burden of research carried out last year by two teams of scientists, one in America and one in the Netherlands. They tweaked the bird-flu virus’s genes to produce a version which can travel through the air from ferret to ferret. And ferrets are, in this context, good proxies for people. The researchers’ motives were pure. The mutations they combined to produce their ferret-killing flu virus are all out there in the wild already. There is every chance those mutations could get together naturally and unleash a pandemic. By anticipating that recombination the two teams highlighted the risk, gave vaccine researchers a head start in thinking about how to counter it and, by fingering the mutations, spurred surveillance efforts, which have often been half-hearted. Or, rather, they would have done had they been allowed to publish their results. They weren’t. Both the American and the Dutch governments saw not a sensible anticipation of a threat, but a threat in its own right. Their fear was that bad guys somewhere might repeat the experiment and weaponise the result. So in December they banned publication of the papers revealing the technical details of what the teams had done.
The threat from influenza is real. So-called Spanish flu, which infected 500m people in 1918-19, claimed the lives of one in five of those who caught it. Subsequent flu epidemics, though not as bad, have still cut swathes through humanity whenever they have arisen. But terrorism is real, too. Though there is no known case of biological warfare in the past 100 years, many countries have experimented with the idea; and there is concern that some terrorist groups, motivated not by specific political grievances but by a general hatred of the West, might unleash the uncontrollable mayhem of a viral epidemic purely out of spite. So who is right—the researchers who want to publish their findings, or the governments that want to stop them? In this particular case, probably the researchers. And, to their credit, the authorities seem to have recognised that. After months of fraught deliberation involving the world’s leading virologists, journal editors, security experts, ethicists and policymakers, the Americans reversed their stance on April 20th. The Dutch were reconsidering theirs as The Economist went to press.
The reason is that, as bioterrorists go, humans pale in comparison with nature. Even America’ s security services, which might be expected to err on the side of caution, seem to agree that the odds of a bioterror attack are long. Biological weapons require skilled scientists working in state-of-the-art facilities. Even then, they are unpredictable—and therefore difficult to control. Aum Shinrikyo, a sect with sophisticated scientific capability, toyed with anthrax in 1993. But for its most brazen attack, when it killed 13 people in the Tokyo metro two years later, it preferred nerve gas. In September 2001 al-Qaeda plumped for aeroplanes. Nature, by contrast, has form in this area. From the Black Death via Spanish flu to AIDS, bacteria and viruses have killed on a scale that terrorists and dictators can only dream of. The more you gag scientists or hide data, the harder it is for them to look for cures; you also probably drive bright young researchers away towards less fraught, blander areas.
At the moment, then, the natural threat seems greater than the artificial one. And it is brave of America’s authorities to recognize that. If a terrorist outrage does happen, they will surely get the blame. By contrast, "acts of nature" are more easily shrugged off as, as it were, acts of God. This case does, however, highlight a problem that is only going to grow. The atom bomb is a child of physics. Nerve gas is a child of chemistry. These are both old, mature sciences. Biotechnology is new. Its potential and limits are obscure. This time America has made the right decision. It is to be hoped that the Dutch will soon follow suit. But it behooves everyone—politicians and scientists alike—to keep a close eye on a fast-changing technology and on any shift in the balance of risks.
The American and the Dutch governments banned publication of the papers revealing the technical details of what the two teams had done because they think______.
选项
A、their research results will only bring disasters to human community
B、pandemics and epidemics will never be overcome with such research
C、the technical details can never be used for curing such diseases
D、some villains might make use of the research and turn it into weapons
答案
D
解析
转载请注明原文地址:https://kaotiyun.com/show/4XSO777K
本试题收录于:
NAETI高级口译笔试题库外语翻译证书(NAETI)分类
0
NAETI高级口译笔试
外语翻译证书(NAETI)
相关试题推荐
Bush’sMBATwenty-sixof42presidents,includingBillClinton,werelawyers.Sevenweregenerals.GeorgeW.Bushbecomesth
Thetechnicianis________toalmostallthetasks,whomayevenfallsasleeponthejob.
OurGlobalVillageScienceandtechnologyhasturnedourworldintoaglobalvillage.Theterm—globalvillage—wascoinedby
Theoceanbottom—aregionnearly2.5timesgreaterthanthetotallandareaoftheEarth—isavastfrontierthateventodayis
Thoughtactlessinhisyouth,BenjaminFranklinbecamesodiplomatic,so________athandlingpeoplethathewasmadeAmericanAmb
UncleVernon,quiteunlikeHarryPotterwholookednothingliketherestofthefamily,waslarge,veryfat,and________,witha
Modernindustrialsocietygrantslittlestatustooldpeople.Infact,suchasocietyhasasystemofbuilt-inobsolescence.The
Inthepopularmind,theInternetistherealizationoftheglobalvillage,wheretheflowofinformationandideasisunimpeded
SirMartinSorrell,thechiefexecutiveoftheadvertisingconglomerateWPP,wasatKensingtonWade,Britain’sfirstprimarysch
Ingeneral,oursocietyisbecomingoneofgiantenterprisesdirectedbyabureaucraticmanagementinwhichmanbecomesasmall,
随机试题
对数据库“稿件管理”中的表“投稿”使用表单向导建立一个简单的表单,文件名为“bd1”,要求显示表中的全部字段,表单样式为“凹陷式”,按钮类型为“文本按钮”,按“投稿日期”升序排序,表单标题为“稿件投稿情况表”。
在社会学的功能中,建立规范这一作用体现了社会学的()
阅读舒婷《神女峰》一诗:在向你挥舞的各色花帕中是谁的手突然收回紧紧捂住了自己的眼睛当人们四散离去,谁还站在船尾衣裙漫飞,如翻涌不息的云江涛高一声低一声美丽的梦留下美丽的忧伤人间天上,代代相传但是,心真能变成石头吗为眺望远天的杳鹤
A.听区B.第Ⅰ躯体感觉区C.第Ⅰ躯体运动区D.运动性语言中枢E.视区位于颞横回的是()
下列哪项不是洋地黄中毒的临床表现?
每年对所有在用的起重机械至少进行()全面检查。停用1年以上、遇()以上地震或发生重大设备事故、露天作业的起重机械经受()以上的风力后的起重机使用前都应做全面检查。
一Excuseme.Couldyoutellme________?一Yes.Thereisavideoshopnexttothetallbuilding.
人体的方位术语有上和下,前和后,内和外,内侧和外侧,近侧和远侧,尺侧和桡侧,胫侧和腓侧,深和浅。()
在环保知识竞赛中,男选手的平均得分为80分,女选手的平均得分为65分,全部选手的平均得分为72分,已知全部选手人数在35到50之间,则全部选手人数为()。
2015年6月29日,《亚洲基础设施投资银行协定》签署仪式在北京人民大会堂举行。《亚洲基础设施投资银行协定》的签署,标志着
最新回复
(
0
)