首页
外语
计算机
考研
公务员
职业资格
财经
工程
司法
医学
专升本
自考
实用职业技能
登录
外语
Why does the professor talk about a community center?
Why does the professor talk about a community center?
admin
2018-08-16
20
问题
Why does the professor talk about a community center?
Listen to part of a lecture in a political science class.
Professor: In previous classes, we explored how local governments create an annual spending plan, a budget, for the tax money they collect each year. And as I’ve said, budgeting is, in essence, a clear expression of priorities. In other words, it’s easy for politicians to say that they value things, things like education, but unless they allocate enough money, let’s say to hire more teachers, then you’ve got to wonder if they really do value education.
Student: As the old saying goes, you’ve got to put your money where your mouth is.
Professor: Exactly, Anyhow, with this in mind, let’s talk about participatory budgeting. Participatory budgeting, PB for short, is one alternative process that some town and city governments around the world have opted to put into place. Here in the
United States, we’re used to thinking of budgeting as happening behind closed doors, It’s generally believed that government officials alone will decide where to spend tax dollars, and that local citizens don’t really have access to that process. Well, PB turns that assumption on its head. First, PB seeks to get citizens involved through discussions, negotiations, and meetings. Citizens present their expectations and priorities to elected officials in terms of resource allocations, Also, the inner workings of the process become visible and clear to attendees. Citizens don’t have to guess what’s going on behind the scenes. They get insight into what’s happening and why. And lastly, the PB process helps to align government priorities with citizen priorities. It puts the politicians and the citizens they represent on the same page, since it gives the politicians a better understanding of local needs. So there are advantages to PB, but there are difficulties, too. First, it’s hard to implement. Why do you think that is? Richard?
Student: Probably because budgeting’s complicated. Maybe residents need a training workshop. You’d have to really understand how using funds for one thing means you don’t use funds for something else.
Professor: Well, while budgeting might get complicated at times, training isn’t a requirement. No. Actually, more than anything else, citizens need time to attend a bunch of meetings to advocate for what they want. It’s not enough to show up at one city council or school board meeting, ask for something, then disappear. Apart from that, citizens must also recognize that..., ok, say a group of citizens persuaded the city council to allocate $8 million to build a new community center, but tax revenues were lower than expected for that year, and so the bureaucrats didn’t have the funds to actually buy the land and materials and hire a construction team. In the end, the community center doesn’t get built.
Student: But why would a city council budget money it didn’t have?
Professor: Budgets are crafted months in advance. Tax revenues are projected based on past revenues, and funds can dry up or not materialize for lots of reasons, like an unexpected downturn in the economy could reduce consumer spending, which in turn reduces what business’ pay in gross receipt taxes to local governments. Now, I should point out that for us academics, it’s hard to talk conclusively about the efficacy of PB. You see, most of the recent literature is just individual case studies, descriptions of only a single city’s implementation of participatory budgeting. I’m not saying they were poorly designed. It’s just hard to draw any general conclusions from them. The only meaningful study I’ve seen to date is an analysis that used rigorous statistical controls, a comparative analysis of a whole number of cities in Brazil. A political scientist from Yale University looked at all the case studies that were published between 1996 and 2008, and he found that sort of on a macro level, that implementing PB did not really affect how public funds were allocated.
Student: Wait. If PB doesn’t change what budgets look like, why bother?
Professor: Good question, one I’d also ask if I hadn’t read one other finding of that Yale study that PB significantly increased the chance of the mayor’s political party getting reelected and remaining in power. At the risk of sounding too cynical, it seems that PB can generate good public relations. The use of PB, regardless of any tangible benefits to the public, apparently helps local residents trust their political leaders. Whether that’s enough to justify the process, I don’t know. Obviously more research is warranted.
选项
A、To give an example of a facility where PB meetings typically take place
B、To indicate that the budgeting process takes longer for some projects than it does for others
C、To point out that budgeting for a project does not guarantee that it will be carried out
D、To describe a project that she believes most politicians would support
答案
C
解析
组织结构题。线索词为教授所说:ok,say a group of citizens persuaded the city council to allocate $8 million to build a new community center,…In the end,the community center doesn’t get built.教授举社区中心的例子是为了论证参与式预算存在的一个问题,即预算不一定会被执行。A选项与原文相悖,社区中心不是参与式预算制定者开会的地点。B选项属比较逻辑关系未提及。D选项错误,因为文中未提及该项目是否能够得到大多数政治家的支持。
转载请注明原文地址:https://kaotiyun.com/show/4jfO777K
0
托福(TOEFL)
相关试题推荐
Completethesentencesbelow.WriteNOMORETHANTHREEWORDSforeachanswer.Computersinsome______cannotbelinkedtothene
ChooseTHREEletters,A-G.WhichTHREEfactorsshouldthestudentconsiderwhileselectingcourses?AclasstimeBcoursetopic
ChooseTHREEletters,A-G.WhichTHREEfactorsshouldthestudentconsiderwhileselectingcourses?AclasstimeBcoursetopic
Whatisthemainopinionofeachofthefollowingpeople?ChooseFIVEanswersfromtheboxandwritethecorrectletter,A-G,ne
Whatisthemainopinionofeachofthefollowingpeople?ChooseFIVEanswersfromtheboxandwritethecorrectletter,A-G,ne
Whatisthewoman’sattitudetowardeachofthefollowingactivitiesofstudy?ChooseFOURanswersfromtheboxandwritetheco
Completethenotesbelow.WriteNOMORETHANTWOWORDSAND/ORANUMBERforeachanswerENVIRONMENTALCHANGEDISCUSSIONInSouthe
Completethesentencesbelow.WriteNOMORETHANTWOWORDSAND/ORANUMBERforeachanswer.Researcherswanttostudymoreabou
Whichadvantageismentionedforeachofthefollowingrestaurants?ChooseSIXanswersfromtheboxandwritethecorrectletter
Choosethecorrectletter,A,BorC.Whatkindofresearchmethoddoestheprofessorrecommend?
随机试题
暑淫证的性质特点
医疗机构的医务人员违反献血法规定,将不符合国家规定标准的血液用于患者的,可能承担以下法律责任,除了
下列不属于继发性肺结核临床病理特征的是
施工成本分析就是对成本形成过程和影响成本升降的因素进行分析,以寻求进一步降低成本的途径,进行成本分析需要的第一手资料有()。
旅游需求的时间指向性是指旅游需求具有()。
石川馨认为,全面质量管理(TQC)在日本就是全公司范围内的质量管理,其具体内容包括()。
下列属于内部学习动机的是()。
下列选项中,体现人民警察秉公执法的有()
如图所示,某条河流一侧有A、B两家工厂,与河岸的距离分别为4km和5km,且A与B的直线距离为11km,为了处理这两家工厂的污水,需要在距离河岸1km处建造一个污水处理厂,分别铺设排污管道连接A、B两家工厂。假定河岸是一条直线,则排污管道的总长最短为(
某公司2012年1—4季度的营业收入总额分别为135、300、233、110百万元。该公司由东部、中部、西部三大地区分公司组成。2013年在三大分公司的累积营业收入(指当年至各季度止累积)和全年利润总额的数据如下图所示(单位:百万元)。根据材料,下列
最新回复
(
0
)