首页
外语
计算机
考研
公务员
职业资格
财经
工程
司法
医学
专升本
自考
实用职业技能
登录
外语
In the name of "zero tolerance," our schools are treating innocent children like criminals. "Zero Tolerance" In High Schools
In the name of "zero tolerance," our schools are treating innocent children like criminals. "Zero Tolerance" In High Schools
admin
2010-04-30
70
问题
In the name of "zero tolerance," our schools are treating innocent children like criminals.
"Zero Tolerance" In High Schools
On a chilly December morning in Houston, Eddie Evans’s 12-year-old son hurried out the door in shirt sleeves on his way to the bus stop. Feeling the cold, he ducked back into his house to quickly grab a jacket. It wasn’t until he’d gotten inside the school building that he remembered his three-inch pocketknife was still in his coat. Why would a sixth-grader carry a knife? Because he was a Boy Scout and he’d brought it to his last Scout meeting.
After asking a friend what he should do, the boy decided to keep quiet and hide the knife in his locker until the end of the day. But his friend mentioned the knife to a teacher, and school officials called the police. That afternoon, cops arrested the Evans child and took him to a juvenile detention center. "From that point on, my family’s life was flipped on its head," the boy’s father says.
The boy was suspended from school for 45 days and enrolled in an alternative school for juvenile offenders. Evans says the place was like a boot camp, where his son —a good student, a youth leader in his church and a First Class Boy Scout —was so miserable he talked about suicide.
This is yet another chapter in the ongoing madness that is America’s "zero tolerance’ craze. Schools nowadays are wildly overreacting to any behavior with a whiff of danger or controversy. Some of these policies were a response to rising teen drug use and high-profile school shootings (such as the massacre at Columbine High School in 1999), which led to a wave of tough federal, state and local laws dealing with drugs and guns.
But they’ve been applied to everything from typical rowdy (粗野的) behavior to innocent missteps. According to a report issued by the Justice Policy Institute in Washington, D. C.:
- A 17-year-old in Richmond, Illinois, shot a paper clip with a rubber band, missing his target but hitting a cafeteria worker instead. He was expelled.
- A 12-year-old in Ponchatoula, Louisiana, diagnosed with a hyperactivity disorder, told others in a lunch line not to eat all the potatoes, or "I’m going to get you."
Turned in by the lunch monitor, he was referred by the principal to the police, who charged the boy with making "terroristic threats." The kid spent several weeks in a juvenile detention (拘留) center.
- A 13-year-old in Denton County, Texas, was assigned in class to write a "scary" Halloween story. He concocted (编造) one that involved shooting up a school, which got him a visit from police —and six days in jail before the courts confirmed that no crime had been committed.
"Zero tolerance has been implemented mindlessly," says education professor Cecil Reynolds of Texas A&M University. "Anytime you take something as complex as the way children behave and apply something simplistic to it, you can’t be doing a good job."
Schools Are Overreacting
Take a recent case of "sexual harassment" in a Hagerstown, Maryland, elementary school. Now, Sexual harassment is serious business. But what if I told you the suspect in this case was still trying to master the alphabet? Last December a five-year-old boy pinched the behind of a girl in his kindergarten class and was cited for harassment. As the boy’s father told a local newspaper, "He knows nothing about sex."
But school officials said that the pinch fell under the Maryland Department of Education’s definition of sexual harassment and that a tough response would be a learning experience for the child. The incident will stay in the young boy’s file for as long as he remains at the school. And he’s not even the flint to be treated this way: According to Maryland state data, 15 kindergartners were suspended for sexual harassment in the 2005-2006 school year.
Cases like these might be one reason the American Psychological Association says zero tolerance policies are having a harmful effect on our kids. When the APA studied such policies last year, it found that kids actually feel less safe and have lower academic performance in schools with high suspension or expulsion rates ( and that’s even if you take other factors, like local income levels, into account). The APA also found that suspending students under zero tolerance rules makes it more likely they’ll be disrnptive in the future.
"Educators should have zero tolerance for the behavior but not zero common sense for the consequences," says Tom Hutton, an attorney for the National School Boards Association.
And one consequence, a Virginia attorney told the American Bar Association’s journal, is that "kids are not going to respect teachers and administrators who cannot appreciate the difference between a plastic knife and a switchblade."
The good news is that some parents have been fighting back. Eddie Evans, for one, didn’t take what happened to his son lying down. He contacted everyone from the governor to his state legislators. He organized a parents’ group, complete with its own website, called Texas Zero Tolerance.
Soon he was testifying at the state capitol to reform Texas’s inflexible zero tolerance laws. In 2005 Gov. Rick Perry signed a law that would give special consideration to whether students with weapons had any intent to cause harm or were acting in self-defense. Present at the ceremony: Eddie Evans and his son.
"Get involved in the political process," Evans now urges other parents, "because if you remain silent, the system will not change." His family had the courage and tenacity to say, Enough! Now, how about the rest of us?
Which of the following statements is NOT true?
选项
A、The five-year-old boy in the sexual harassment case was innocent.
B、The school punished the five-year-old boy for sexual harassment so that he would receive a serious lesson.
C、The zero tolerance policies are necessary in guiding teenage behaviors.
D、Although suspending students are under zero tolerance roles they might as well end up in committing crimes.
答案
C
解析
文章中"Anytime you take something as complex as the way children behave and apply something simplistic to it,you can’t be doing a good job" 从侧面反映了这项规定的不合理。因此选C。
转载请注明原文地址:https://kaotiyun.com/show/5FOK777K
0
大学英语六级
相关试题推荐
A、Apublicspeech.B、Atestatschool.C、Apersuasivespeech.D、Aconversationtoastranger.CWhatisanemploymentinterviewl
Theoldestandsimplestmethod,then,ofdescribingdifferencesinpersonalitywasto(36)______peopleaccordingto(37)______
Theoldestandsimplestmethod,then,ofdescribingdifferencesinpersonalitywasto(36)______peopleaccordingto(37)______
A、Choosingjournalismasacareer.B、People’sreactionstoaschoolplay.C、Howtotakegoodphotographs.D、Theexperiencesoft
MercedesestatecarsandFiatrunarounds(轻便小汽车)arebeingusedtotestupto22differentmonitorsdesignedtodetectifadrive
A、Theyfoughtwiththeothermice.B、Theystayedclosetotheirmothers.C、Theyranbackandforthconstantly.D、Theyremainedc
Opinionpollsarenowbeginningtoshowthathighunemploymentisthemostcommoncomplaint.Thismeansweshallhavetofindwa
WhatcanpeopleknowfromthecrownofanancienttreefoundinNewYork?Whywasitpossiblefortheseancienttreesletmore
MildweatherhasbroughtJapan’smuch-lovedcherrytreesinto(36)______twoweeksearlythisyear,butnoteveryoneis(37)____
Infaceoftheevolvingglobaleconomy,theauthorsuggeststhattheemphasisincareereducationbeshiftedto______.Thecha
随机试题
有些炎症,西药中药都能治。不但中药能与一般抗菌素媲美,而且副作用小,成本也较低。
下列哪个决策原则被称为乐观主义原则?()
某化工厂一苯胺管道阀门处发生苯胺泄漏,一检修工在无任何防护条件下抢修近4小时,头晕、乏力、恶心、频繁呕吐而入院。查体:意识清,口唇、耳廓、颜面明显发绀。发生上述临床征象的最主要原因是
心肺复苏的关键是:心肺复苏的重点是:
通风与空调系统综合效能试验测定与调整的项目,应依据()确定。
可以记入账户借方的情况有()。
下列父于柔性防水和刚性防水的说法正确的有()。
《房地产开发企业资质管理规定》将房地产开发企业划分为4个资质等级,其中属于一级资质的必备条件有()。
咬文嚼字有时是一个坏习惯,___________这个成语的含义通常不很好。但是在文学,无论阅读或写作,我们_________有一字不肯放松的谨严。文学借文字___________思想情感:文字上面有含糊,就显得思想还没有_________,情感还没有凝练。
任何不能回答病人的问题的人都不能算是一个合格的医生。这正是我对自己的医生充满信心的原因,因为无论问题多么烦恼,她总是细心地回答我的每一个问题。上述论证中的推理错误也类似地出现在以下哪一项中?
最新回复
(
0
)