首页
外语
计算机
考研
公务员
职业资格
财经
工程
司法
医学
专升本
自考
实用职业技能
登录
外语
How to Reinvent College Rankings: Show the Data Students Need Most A)All rankings are misleading and biased(有偏见的). But they’re a
How to Reinvent College Rankings: Show the Data Students Need Most A)All rankings are misleading and biased(有偏见的). But they’re a
admin
2014-08-29
33
问题
How to Reinvent College Rankings: Show the Data Students Need Most
A)All rankings are misleading and biased(有偏见的). But they’re also the only way to pick a school. I’ve heard those exact words dozens of times and inferred their sentiment hundreds more. They undoubtedly were a major contributing factor in the 250,000 applications to the top colleges this past year. With only 14,000 chances available, there will be a lot of disappointed families when decisions are announced in a few days. For 30 years, I’ve co-authored bestselling books and provocative articles about how to improve one’s chances of being accepted at a "top" college.
B)The first edition of our book Getting In! revealed what went on behind the admission committees’ closed doors, and introduced the concepts of packaging and positioning to the college-application vocabulary. The newest edition adapts the same principles to the digital age. But the core message remains: good colleges are not looking for the well-rounded kid—they’re looking to put together the well-rounded class.
C)What were revelations in 1983 are common knowledge today—at least among college-bound students, parents, and counselors. They also don’t have to be told that the odds of getting into a "highly selective" school are ridiculously low. Brown and Dartmouth will each accept about 9 percent of applicants; Cornell, Northwestern, and Georgetown about 16 percent. And Harvard, Yale, and Stanford? Forget about it: less than 7 percent!
D)Wanting to attend a "name" school isn’t illogical. And there is nothing illogical in parents wanting a better return on their investment. A college’s brand value—whether that school’s name will be recognized and open employers’ door.
E)Colleges, counselors, and parents talk a lot about finding the right "fit" between a school and a student. In reality, the process is dominated by reputation. The problem is that college reputations have been controlled by rankings. Far too many "highly ranked" colleges are gaming the rankings and trying to attract more and more applicants—when the particular college is actually a poor "fit" for many of the kids applying. Colleges want to attract and reject more kids because that "selectivity" improves the institution’s ranking. College presidents publicly complain there are too many college rankings. Privately, they admit they have to provide the data that feed that maw(大胃口). They can’t afford to be left off a rankings list. The real losers in this system are students and their parents. A bad fit is costly, not just in dollars, but in time, energy, and psychological well-being.
F)The emphasis should be on finding the right fit. But finding the right fit is not easy. Subjective guidebooks like Edward Fiske’s—originally titled The New York Times Selective Guide to Colleges— are very useful and consciously do not include rankings. Ted changed his three-category rating system to make it more difficult to simply add "stars" and rank-list colleges. Even families who can afford to visit lots of colleges and endure the backward-walking tours find that campus personalities soon blur in their memory.
G)Thus it is not surprising that anxious, busy parents turn to rankings for shorthand comfort. Unfortunately, the data that U. S. News and other media companies are collecting are largely irrelevant. As a result, the rankings they generate are not meaningless, just misleading. Some examples: U. S. News places a good deal of emphasis on the percentage of faculty who hold a "terminal degree"—typically a Ph. D. Unfortunately, a terminal degree does not correlate(相关的)in any way with whether that professor is a good teacher. It also doesn’t improve that professor’s accessibility to students. In fact, there is usually such a correlation; the more senior the professor, the less time they have for undergraduates.
H)U.S. News’ second most heavily weighted factor—after a college’s six-year graduation rate—is a peer assessment of colleges by college presidents and admissions deans. You read that right; administrators are asked to evaluate colleges that are competitive with their own school. If not an complete conflict of interest, this measure is highly suspect.
I)Even some seemingly reasonable "inputs" are often meaningless. U. S. News heavily weights the number of classes with fewer than 20 students. But small classes are like comfort food: it is what high-school kids are familiar with. They have never sat in a large lecture hall with a very interesting speaker. So it is not something they could look forward or value.
J)While most rankings suffer from major problems in criteria(标准)and inputs, the biggest problem is simpler; all the ranking systems use weightings that reflect the editors’ personal biases. Very simply, some editors’ priorities are undoubtedly going be different from what is important to me. Assuredly, my preferences are different from my kids’. And both will differ markedly from our neighbors’ objectives.
K)Colleges say they truly want to attract kids for whom the school will be a good fit. To make good on that promise, colleges need to provide families with insight, not just information; and they need to focus on outputs, not just inputs. Collecting and sharing four sets of very different data would be a good start: Better insight into the quality of education a student will get on that campus. Colleges need to share the exam scores for all students applying to medical school, law school, business school, and graduate programs. These tests reflect not just the ability of the kids who’ve gone to that college, but what they’ve learned in the three-plus years they’ve attended. Colleges need to assess a campus’ "happiness" coefficient(系数). A happy campus is a more productive learning environment; and one that has a lower incidence of alcohol and drug abuse. The full debt that families incur(招致); not just student debt. The salaries of graduates one, five, and 10 years after graduation.
L)A fifth useful metric is what employers—both nationally and regionally—think of graduates from particular colleges. Hiring preferences are a useful proxy(代表)for reputation.
M)The last piece in enabling families to find a better fit will come from entrepreneurs. Some smart "kid" will develop an online tool that will allow students and parents to take this new college-reported data and assign weighting factors to the characteristics that are important to them. The tool would then generate a customized ranking of colleges that reflects the family’s priorities—not some editor’s.
N)Colleges may complain about the rankings, but they are complicit(串通一气的)in keeping them. It is reminiscent(怀旧的)of the classic Claude Raines line in Casablanca; "I’m shocked, shocked to find that gambling is going on in here!" If colleges really want kids for whom their college is a good fit, they will collect and publish the types of honest data that will give families a better basis for smart decisions.
There is no doubt that the rankings of colleges is the major factor for most of the applicants to choose the top colleges.
选项
答案
A
解析
根据定位句可知,它们(大学排名)无疑是25万顶级大学申请者的主要参考因素。题干中的thereis no doubt that与定位句中的undoubtedly属于同义转述,定位句中的they就是指the rankings of colleges,故答案为A)。
转载请注明原文地址:https://kaotiyun.com/show/5Jv7777K
0
大学英语四级
相关试题推荐
A、Thetwopeoplecanlearnabouteachother’slikesanddislikes.B、Thetwopeoplecanhavetimetodecideiftheyareagoodma
中国各地的古典园林,风景优美,建筑奇特,是中外游人向往的游览胜地。中国古典园林的最大特点是讲究自然天成。古代的园林设计家在建园时,巧妙地把大自然的美景融合在人造的园林中,使人能从中欣赏到大自然的奇峰、异石、流水、湖面、名花、芳草,感觉就像在画中游览。中国古
Paststudieshavesuggestedtheamygdale(扁桃体)isimportantin(26)______responses.Peoplewhoareshown(27)______pictures,forexa
A、Healwaysbringsanotebookwithhimself.B、Hetreatshislistenersasstudents.C、Hecanexpresscomplexideasdirectlyandn
I’mnotaconspiracy(阴谋)theoristoranything,butImustadmitthatthose(26)______ofthemoonlandingmakemedoubtful.Imean
A、Heenjoysdancingverymuch.B、Heisfondofraisinganimals.C、Helikesgatheringstampsbest.D、Collectingcoinsishisfavo
ExercisetoProtectAgingBodies—andBrainsA)Weallknowthatexerciseisgoodforyou.Stayingphysicallyactivehelpskeep
中国人喜欢喝茶,也常常用茶来招待朋友和客人。茶叶是中国人生活中的必需品。茶树原产于中国。中国古人发现茶树后,起初是把茶叶作为药用,后来才当作饮料。花茶(scentedtea)是中国独有的一个茶类,是在茶叶中加入香花熏制而成的。最有名的花茶是福建产的茉莉花
HowtoIncreaseYourWorkingExperienceintheUniversity?1.大学期间,大学生有必要获得一些工作经验2.获得工作经验的途径3.我的观点
Anewstudyshowsthatstudentslearnmuchbetterthroughanactive,iterative(反复的)processthatinvolvesworkingthroughtheirm
随机试题
关于道德权利,下列说法正确的是
下列工作步骤中属于定额单价法,但不属于实物量法的是()。
背景资料:某公司承建一项天然气管线工程,全长1380m,公称外径dn110mm,采用聚乙烯燃气管道(SDR11PE100),直埋敷设,热熔连接。工程实施过程中发生了如下事件:事件一:开工前,项目部对现场焊工的执业资格进行检
衡量商业银行信用风险变化的程度,表示资产质量从前期到本期变化的比率指标有()。
DNA螺旋结构的发现被称为是20世纪生物学最伟大的发现,是______诞生的标志()
根据法律规定,以下属于行政裁决的是()。
(2010下项管)在大项目管理中,往往要在项目各阶段进行项目范围确认。有关范围确认的叙述,正确的是______。
A、Givingupsmoking.B、Keepingfit.C、Doingexercises.D、Eatingsweets.A
Althoughtherehadbeenvarioussmallcamerasdeveloped,itwasnotuntilGeorgeEastmanintroducedtheKodakin1888thatt
Somesayitisevidentthatcomputerscandamageaperson’seyesight.Sincethepopularityofcomputersbegantoskyrocket,ther
最新回复
(
0
)