首页
外语
计算机
考研
公务员
职业资格
财经
工程
司法
医学
专升本
自考
实用职业技能
登录
外语
Raising the Minimum Wage Reduces Poverty A) One funny part of watching journalists cover the minimum wage debate is that the
Raising the Minimum Wage Reduces Poverty A) One funny part of watching journalists cover the minimum wage debate is that the
admin
2022-07-28
59
问题
Raising the Minimum Wage Reduces Poverty
A) One funny part of watching journalists cover the minimum wage debate is that they often have to try and referee cutting-edge econometric (计量经济学) debates. Some studies, notably those lead by UMass Amherst economist Arin Dube, argue that there are no adverse employment effects from small increases in the minimum wage. Other studies, notably those lead by University of California Irvine economist David Neumark, argue there is an adverse effect. Whatever can we conclude?
B) But instead of diving into that controversy, let’s take a look at where these economists, and all the other researchers investigating the minimum wage, do agree: They all tend to think that raising the minimum wage would reduce poverty. That’s the conclusion of a major new paper by Dube, titled "Minimum Wages and the Distribution of Family Incomes."
C) Let’s first highlight the major results. Dube uses the latest in minimum-wage statistics and finds a negative relationship between the minimum wage and poverty. Specifically, raising the minimum wage 10 percent (say from $7.25 to near $8) would reduce the number of people living in poverty 2.4 percent. (For those who thrive on jargon, the minimum wage has an "elasticity" of -0.24 when it comes to poverty reduction.)
D) Using this as an estimate, raising the minimum wage to $10.10 an hour, as many Democrats are proposing in 2014, would reduce the number of people living in poverty by 4.6 million. It would also boost the incomes of those at the 10th percentile (百分位) by $1,700. That’s a significant increase in the quality of life for our worst off that doesn’t require the government to tax and spend a single additional dollar.
E) And, given that this policy is self-enforcing with virtually no administrative costs while challenging the employer’s market power, it is a powerful complement to the rest of the policies the government uses to boost the living standards of the worst off, including the Earned Income Tax Credit, food stamps, Medicaid, etc.
F) Now, this is normally the part where we’d have to go through the counterarguments, using different data and techniques from different economists, to argue that the minimum wage wouldn’t do this. But this is the fun part: Dube’s paper finds a remarkable consistency across studies here. For instance, in a 2011 paper by minimum-wage opponent David Neumark, raising the minimum wage 10 percent would reduce poverty 2.9 percent (an elasticity of-0.29) for 21-44-year-old family heads or individuals. That’s very similar to what Dube finds. Neumark doesn’t mention this directly in the paper however; Dube is able to back out this conclusion using other variables that are listed.
G) Indeed, Dube digs out the effects of the minimum wage on poverty from 12 different studies in the new wave of literature on the topic that started in the 1990s with David Card and Alan Krueger field-creating research. Of the 54 elasticities that Dube is able to observe in these 12 papers, 48 of them are negative. Only one study has a sizable positive one, a 2005 one by David Neumark, a study that stands out for odd methodology (方法论) (it lacks state and yearly fixed effects, it assumes quantiles (分位数) are moving in certain directions) that isn’t standard in the field or in his subsequent work. (Indeed, it is nothing like Neumark’s standard 2011 study, mentioned above, which finds that the minimum wage reduces poverty.) Including that study, there’s an average elasticity of-0.15 across all the studies; tossing it, there’s one of-0.20 across the 11 studies, similar to what Dube finds.
H) However, these previous studies also have issues which Dube’s new study examines. This paper uses data up through 2012, so there are much more substantial variations to examine between states’ minimum wages compared to earlier studies from the 1990s. Meanwhile there are additional controls added, including those that deal with the business cycle as well as regional effects. The range of controls provide 8 different results, all of which are highlighted.
I) Now, as a general rule with these numbers, you should never observe too far away from the mean—that is, you shouldn’t take the effects of small changes to see what would happen if we, say, increased the minimum wage 500 percent, or to levels that don’t actually exist right now. But the results are promising.
J) Indeed, they are promising on three different measures of poverty. There’s the normal definition of poverty established in the 1960s as a result of how much food costs takes up in your family budget.
K) However, the relationship is both relevant and even stronger for the poverty gap, which is how far people are away from the poverty line, and the squared poverty gap, which is a focus on those with very low incomes. The elasticities here are -0.32 and -0.96 respectively, with the second having an almost one-to-one relationship because the minimum wage reduces the proportions of those with less than one-half the poverty line.
L) What should people take away from this? The first is that there are significant benefits, whatever the costs. If you look at the economist James Tobin in 1996, for instance, he argues that the "minimum wage always had to be recognized as having good income consequences…I thought in this instance those advantages outweighed the small loss of jobs." Since then there’s been substantially more work done arguing that the loss of jobs is smaller or nonexistent, and now we know that the advantages are even better, especially when it comes to boosting incomes of the poorest and reducing extreme poverty.
M) The second is that this isn’t a thing that people proposing an inequality agenda just happened to throw on the table. A higher minimum wage is a substantial response to the challenges of inequality. Opponents of a higher minimum wage focus on the idea that it largely won’t benefit the worst off.
N) A higher minimum wage will lead to a significant boost in incomes for the worst off in the bottom 30th percent of income, while having no impact on the median household.
O) As many economists have argued, the minimum wage "substantially ’held up’ the lower tail of the U.S. earnings distribution" through the late 1970s, but this effect stopped as the real value of the minimum wage fell in subsequent decades. This gives us an empirical (以经验为根据的) handle on how the minimum wage would help deal with both insufficient low-end wages and inequality, and the results are striking.
P) Charles Darwin once wrote, "If the misery of the poor be caused not by the laws of nature, but by our institutions, great is our sin." One of the key institutions of the modern economy, the minimum wage, could dramatically reduce the misery of the poor. What would it say if we didn’t take advantage of it?
All the researchers investing the minimum wage agree that raising the minimum wage will reduce poverty.
选项
答案
B
解析
题干意为,所有调查最低工资的研究人员一致认为提高最低工资将会减少贫困。根据题干中的关键词All the researchers和agree可以定位到B段。该段首句中指出,先不要一头扎进争议中,我们来看看这些经济学家和其他调查最低工资的研究者一致赞同的地方:他们都倾向于认为提高最低工资能减少贫困。由此可知,题干是对原文的同义转述,故选B。
转载请注明原文地址:https://kaotiyun.com/show/7ix7777K
0
大学英语六级
相关试题推荐
从公元前4000年开始,中国传统绘画已经持续发展了6000多年。它的发展不可避免地反映出时代和社会状况的变化。在它的早期发展阶段,中国绘画与其他工艺密切相关,从陶瓷(potteries)到青铜器(bronzes)和玉雕(carvedjades)的装饰。中
A、Withintwodays.B、Rightnow.C、Afterthewomanhavegottheneededinformation.D、Afterthemanhavegothismanager’sapprov
A、Thefamousbrands.B、Thecereals.C、Books.D、Meat.B列举中直接提到了cereals。A的干扰性较大,女士建议“你经常使用的品牌产品可以上网选购”,并没有说这些产品是“名牌产品”。
A、Participationinsportsisrelevanttopositiveeffects.B、Participationinsportsincreasesfemalecollegeattendance.C、Part
A、Participationinsportsisrelevanttopositiveeffects.B、Participationinsportsincreasesfemalecollegeattendance.C、Part
A、Delegationisatickettoforeigntrade.B、Managersshouldn’tmerelybea"doer".C、Leadershipisabornability.D、Delegation
A、Theymainlyliveontheground.B、Theyaresensitivetodangers.C、Thefemalesdonothaveacall.D、Themalesaremorediffic
A、Youraudienceandwhattheyareinterestedin.B、Whatyouraudienceexpectyoutotalkabout.C、Youraudienceandwhatkindof
A、Tosatisfyhisrequirements.B、Toshowhowthesoftwareworks.C、Toaskhimtobuyotherproducts.D、Tolethimcompareprices
随机试题
A.反常呼吸B.胸膜损伤后,空气进入胸膜腔,异常通道自动闭合C.肺裂伤破裂处形成活瓣,气体只能进胸膜腔而不能排出D.胸壁伤口与胸膜腔相逗E.肺组织损伤,血液积聚于胸膜腔闭合性气胸
龋病期间不形成或形成很少修复性牙本质的是
甲公司和乙公司就双方签订的买卖合同达成仲裁协议,约定如果因为合同履行发生的任何纠纷,提交当地仲裁委员会裁决。后合同履行发生纠纷,甲公司将乙公司诉至法院。乙公司在首次开庭前向法院提交仲裁协议。在何种情形下,法院可以继续审理?()
下列选项中,可能导致撤销直接责任人员任职资格或者证券从业资格的情形有( )。
班级授课制的特点可以用“班”“课”“时”三个字来概括。()
中国历史上第一个全国性的专职警察机构是1898年在长沙成立的“湖南保卫局”。( )
绿色壁垒是指在国际贸易领域,一些发达国家及其政府凭借其科技优势,以保护环境和人类健康为目的,通过立法,制定繁杂的环保公约、法律、法规和标准、标志等形式对国外商品进行的准入限制。根据上述定义,下列不涉及绿色壁垒的是:
尽管家长、老师都大力宣扬体育运动能有效改善孩子的健康情况,但是他们还是会把运动和学业对立起来,认为孩子应该把更多的时间放在学业上,以提高学习成绩。而有专家表示,运动时间越多的孩子,学习成绩越高,建议家长、老师给孩子更多的时间去运动。以下哪个选项如
大众传媒最基本的功能就是获取信息和传递信息,人们借助它们,突破了时间和空间的限制,将信息迅速传递到目标地点。信息社会的一个标志性的信息传播手段是()。
A、Theywillpaymoreattentiontothequalityoftheirproducts.B、Theywerenotpreparedtocommentonthecigarettestudy.C、T
最新回复
(
0
)