首页
外语
计算机
考研
公务员
职业资格
财经
工程
司法
医学
专升本
自考
实用职业技能
登录
外语
Americans are still chuckling about the "pants suit". A man—a judge, no less—sued his dry cleaners for $ 54m for allegedly losin
Americans are still chuckling about the "pants suit". A man—a judge, no less—sued his dry cleaners for $ 54m for allegedly losin
admin
2015-10-21
32
问题
Americans are still chuckling about the "pants suit". A man—a judge, no less—sued his dry cleaners for $ 54m for allegedly losing his trousers. A sign at the shop promised " Satisfaction Guaranteed". The plaintiff was not satisfied, so he cried fraud. He then used his highly trained legal brain to calculate the damages he was owed. He started with $1,500, a reasonable fine for consumer fraud. He multiplied it by 12, for the number of his complaints. Then by 1,200, for the number of days he was deprived of his trousers. And then by three, for the three owners of the dry-cleaning shop. After adding a bit more for mental anguish, the total came to $67m, but he kindly reduced it to $54m.
When the case was dismissed in 2007, many felt justice had prevailed. But the defendants had been put through purgatory and saddled with $100,000 in legal costs. They closed the shop and considered moving back to South Korea. The case illustrates " an important truth about human nature—that angry people can go nuts," observes Philip Howard, a campaigner for legal reform. What was most shocking about the pants suit was not the idiotic claim, he says, "but that the case was allowed to go on for more than two years. " Some judges think even the nuttiest plaintiffs deserve their day in court. As the judge who let a woman sue McDonald’s for serving her the coffee with which she scalded herself put it: "Who am I to judge?"
The rule of law is a wonderful thing, as anyone who has visited countries ruled by the whims of the powerful can attest. But you can have too much of a wonderful thing. And America has far too much law, argues Mr. Howard in a new book, Life without Lawyers. For nearly every problem, lawmakers and bureaucrats imagine that more detailed rules are the answer. But people need to exercise their common sense, too. Alas, the proliferation of rules is making that harder.
At a school in Florida, for example, a five-year-old girl decided to throw everyone’s books and pencils on the floor. Sent to the head teacher’s office, she continued to wreak havoc. Her teachers dared not restrain her physically. Instead, they summoned the police, who led her away in handcuffs, howling. The teachers acted as they did for fear of being sued. A teacher at a different school was sued for $20m for putting a hand on a rowdy child’s back to guide him out of the classroom. The school ended up settling for $90,000. Understandably, many schools ban teachers from touching pupils under any circumstances. In New York City, where more than 60 bureaucratic steps are required to suspend a pupil for more than five days, teachers are so frightened of violating pupils’ rights that they cannot keep order.
The relentless piling of law upon law—the federal register has 70,000 ever-changing pages-does not make for a more just society. When even the most trivial daily interactions are subject to detailed rules, individual judgment is stifled. When rule-makers seek to eliminate small risks, perverse consequences proliferate. Bureaucrats rip up climbing frames for fear that children may fall off and break a leg. So children stay indoors and get fat.
The direct costs of lawsuits are only one of the drawbacks of an over-legalistic society. Too many rules squeeze the joy out of life. Doctors who inflict dozens of unnecessary tests on patients to fend off lawsuits take less pride in their work. And although the legal system is supposed to be neutral, the scales are tilted in favour of whoever is in the wrong. Because the process is so expensive and juries are so unpredictable, blameless people often settle baseless claims to make them go away. The law is supposed to protect individuals from the state, but it often allows selfish individuals to harness the state’s power to settle private scores.
Will any of this change under Barack Obama? At first glance, the odds are poor. The new President is a lawyer from a party dominated by lawyers. His vice-president publicly thanked God last year that lawyers are such a problem for corporate America. When Mr. Obama was in the Senate, he once voted for a mild curb on jurisdiction-shopping by class-action lawyers, but otherwise tended to vote against tort reform. And Democrats in the new Congress are itching to reward the lawyers who donated so generously to their election campaigns, for example by revoking the(admittedly short)statute of limitations on pay-discrimination claims, allowing lawyers to mine decades-old grievances.
The word "rowdy" in the fourth paragraph probably means______.
选项
A、boisterous
B、self-centered
C、restrained
D、spoiled
答案
A
解析
语义题第四段开头首先讲述了一个5岁的女孩任意扔书和铅笔,教师束手无策,而不得不叫警察的故事,紧接着又举了另外一名教师把一个学生撵出教室而被起诉索赔2000万美元的故事,两个例子都是在说明类似的情况,由此可以推断出后一个事例中那个小孩也是一个吵闹、不听话的孩子,即[A]正确。[B]“以自我为中心的”,[C]“克制的”,[D]“溺爱的”,均与上下文意思不符,故排除。
转载请注明原文地址:https://kaotiyun.com/show/9WKO777K
0
专业英语八级
相关试题推荐
TheAmericanWay:FreedomTheheartoftheAmericancalendarisJuly【4】Americanshavecelebratedthisdateas"Independence
A、lifeisinfluencedbypeople’sfeelingofhappinessB、people’sfeelingofhappinessusuallydipsafternewseventsC、thehappi
Evenasthenumberoffemalesprocessedthroughjuvenilecourtsclimbssteadily,animplicitconsensusremainsamongscholarsi
WhichofthefollowingstatementsisTRUEaboutMissGreen’suniversitydays?
The1920sbroughtthefollowingtoAmericansEXCEPT
MoststudentsintheUKleaveschoolor【N1】______collegeattheageof18andgotostudyforthreeyearsinaUniversity,but
FilmloversarelookingtoLondonforthenexttwoweeks,todiscoverthebestinUKcinemaatthe51stBritishFilmInstituteL
WhichofthefollowingisNOTthebackgroundinformationofapossibleattackonIran?
Cigarettesleaveyouwithmorethanasmokyscentonyourclothesandfingernails.Anewstudyhasfoundevidencetobacco【M1】__
Cigarettesleaveyouwithmorethanasmokyscentonyourclothesandfingernails.Anewstudyhasfoundevidencetobacco【M1】__
随机试题
滑动轴承根据结构类型可分为( )。
按照网络安全漏洞的可利用方式来划分,漏洞探测技术可以分为信息型漏洞探测和___________两种。
胫骨中下1/3交界处最易发生骨折的原因主要是
患儿,女,3岁。颈部肿物约1cm,稍高起于皮肤,圆形,边界不清,皮表正常。肿块呈青蓝色,质软,有压缩性,压迫时消失,去压后即复原。最可能的诊断为
空腹痛常见于
大肠的主要生理功能是
以下属于项目生命周期和阶段划分特点的有()。
某乡总面积179平方公里,其中林地面积113平方公里,总人口13866人,辖8个村民委,84个自然屯,119个村民小组,居住着苗、瑶、侗、壮、汉、仫佬、水等民族,其中苗族占总人口的46.3%,少数民族占总人口的80%。该乡有丰富的竹木资源,当地群众依地取材
境内某上市公司,2012年10月18日股票价格10元/股,当日授权员工王某,工作满3年时,可以4元/股价格购买本公司股票100000股。2015年10月18日王某行权时,该股票市价每股12元,假设该股票期权不可公开交易,计算王某股票期权行权所得应纳的个人所
党的十五大报告指出:“中华民族面对的两大历史任务:一个是求得民族独立和民族解放;一个是实现国家繁荣富强和人民共同富裕。”这实际上指出了中国新民主主义革命和社会主义革命与建设的共同主题是()。
最新回复
(
0
)