首页
外语
计算机
考研
公务员
职业资格
财经
工程
司法
医学
专升本
自考
实用职业技能
登录
外语
Is Higher Education a Bubble? My colleague at Democracy in America draws attention to an ongoing debate over the nature of h
Is Higher Education a Bubble? My colleague at Democracy in America draws attention to an ongoing debate over the nature of h
admin
2012-08-10
49
问题
Is Higher Education a Bubble?
My colleague at Democracy in America draws attention to an ongoing debate over the nature of higher education, and, in particular, steady increases in the cost of getting one. The question of the hour is: is higher education a bubble?
Consider: If you can only afford to go to a state university, don’t be too annoyed. Except this: Kevin Drum went to a state university that does not exist anymore. When he graduated from Cal State Long Beach in 1981, he paid $ 160 in fees. If he graduated from the same institution today, the tuition he would have paid for this year would be $ 4,335. They officially call it "tuition" now, because it’s not meant to be a nominal (名义上的) "fee" anymore. It’s simply the price you pay for your education, as a customer, and next year it will be higher, a lot higher. Unless the direction of things changes soon, it will be $6,450. And the year after that? It will be even higher. Fees/Tuition in the California State system have risen significantly every year since when Kevin Drum went there, and they have risen by around 400% since 2002. Given the complete intransigence (不妥协) of California republicans, tuition will most likely rise by another 32% next year.
A diploma is a kind of investment. It is a guarantor of higher lifetime earnings: The " college wage premium" for highly educated workers is in the tens of thousands of dollars per year. It is also an insurance policy against unemployment, a signaling device to employers and peers, a prestige line for your resume or New York Times wedding announcement, and a place to make friends and connections. Most importantly, it is a way to learn new skills and information.
It could be that college students are overpaying for their educations. But it seems more likely that some college students attending certain types of schools are overpaying. If you want to be an aerospace engineer and have the chops to get into Caltech, the quality of the education, contacts, and fellow students on offer might really be worth $ 200, 000 to you. A diploma from the school practically guarantees a good salary.
It’s much harder to talk about a bubble in education than it was one in housing. In housing, there was a clear metric: prices, in absolute terms and as a ratio of just about everything, were soaring. And there was a clear debate: are these increases justified by some real economic shift or are they a bubble associated with new mortgage products and loose credit. In higher education, the questions are much more difficult.
For one thing, it’s hard to agree on what price should be the focus. Advertised topline tuition? Few people pay that. Average tuition paid? Average student loan debt? Is the bubble in higher education present at all universities, or just top universities, or just for-profit universities? And how is whatever rising price that is the focus connected to changes in the benefits of a higher education? Indeed, what are those benefits?
The ultimate benefit seems to be a substantial wage premium, and comparisons of that premium to average levels of tuition or incurred debt make college look like an incredibly good deal. The tricky thing is that there may well be an identification problem: it could simply be the case that students who go to college earn more, because the types of students that go to college are the types that have characteristics (intelligence, discipline) that translate into higher earnings. University degrees could simply be expensive signaling mechanisms at best, in this world, and massively wasteful cultural institutions at worst.
Because we can’t select high school seniors at random, send some to universities and some into the workforce, and see what happens, we’re going to be limited in what we can say about the extent to which this is true. But let me tell you how I think about this.
I think the gains from higher education are mostly, though not at all entirely, about actual learning, though I should say that a healthy portion of these learning gains aren’t academic in nature, but have to do with things like social capital. Given the cost of higher education, it seems unlikely that signaling can be the main value of a college degree. There are so many other available means to accomplish the same thing. Why wouldn’t an employer be as happy with a set of scores on the SAT and GRE and a letter of acceptance from Harvard? The potential market for a cheaper means to signal worth and to network seems so large that its absence is just very difficult to explain.
There are highly successful firms that do opt to recruit large numbers of skilled young people away from universities and toward an early professional career: America’s professional sports teams. Why haven’t other companies followed suit? If college doesn’t teach anything, how can we explain this enormous market failure?
One potential explanation is that there are multiple balances and at present we are stuck in a bad one. So long as the vast majority of talented youths get traditional college educations, it is too risky and costly for young people to defect from the higher-education strategy. Defection could, indeed, signal a lack of professional fitness. But this is a very vulnerable equilibrium (平衡). If even a small number of those students accepted to top universities opt instead to strike out on their own, the bad record of missing out on college could quickly erode. One can even imagine a young student leaving to pursue an entrepreneurial vision directly targeted at potential college dropouts—setting up support networks, alternative signaling mechanisms, and so on.
But why hasn’t this already happened? My guess is that most people, including parents, students, and employers, consider a university education to be a good value. The full set of returns to the investment—signaling and networking, yes, but also the actual investments in intellectual and social capital—justifies the sticker price, and certainly the $20,000 or so in average student loan debt.
What would we look for in a higher education bubble? College educations have long been incredibly cheap given the (apparent) long-run benefit to the degree-holder. Students today are now paying for a larger share of the benefit they receive. And in some cases, universities appear to be getting better at gaining some of the surplus created by degree completion.
Is this problematic? There is a positive societal effect to higher education, and so students (many of them anyway) should continue to receive some subsidy. And it is in society’s interest to ensure that deserving poor students have the same opportunities as richer ones. But broadly speaking, I don’t know if we can say that higher education has gotten too expensive or has become a bubble.
What does the author say about the bubble in education?
选项
A、There is a clear metric to show the prices are soaring.
B、The tuition increases are justified by higher salary.
C、It relates to new mortgage products and loose credit.
D、It involves more difficult questions than one in housing.
答案
D
解析
定位段主要阐述为什么谈论教育泡沫比房地产泡沫更难,原因包括房地产泡沫有明确的标准和清晰的辩论观点,而有关高等教育泡沫的问题更为复杂和困难等。D)符合文意,故为答案。
转载请注明原文地址:https://kaotiyun.com/show/Af57777K
0
大学英语四级
相关试题推荐
IncommunitiesnorthofDenver,residentsarepitchingintohelpteachersandadministratorsastheVrainSchoolDistricttries
WithfifteenyearsBritainandothernationsshouldbewellonwiththebuildingofhugeindustrialcomplexesforthe【B1】______o
A、Action.B、WorldNews.C、Enterprise.D、FacesandPlaces.A四个选项看起来毫不相关,考查的是文中的信息配对,而事实是题目询问运动员很可能会购买哪种杂志。关键听到“Action是为运动迷们准备的”,可
A、Literature.B、USCulture.C、TOEFL.D、BusinessEnglish.D细节题。四个选项都是表示课程的名词,注意听到课程时,要记录相关信息。女士在介绍课程时,提到了computerliteracy,interc
A、Picturetaking.B、Memory.C、Languagelearning.D、Poemwriting.B主旨题。本文介绍记忆力。通过浏览选项可知,本题考的可能是事实判断题或者推理题,这就要求考生在听录音的时候,特别关注选项所示的
A、90.B、108.C、180.D、668D细节题。本文介绍一位足球运动员。从选项可以看出该题考查数字。本文中数据很多,听的时候应该一一记录与不同数字相关的信息。听到90时写下captain;听到108时写下gamesforEngland;听
A、EnglishLiterature.B、Management.C、French.D、PublicAdministration.C对话中女士问男士的教育背景,男士回答说他在诺丁汉大学取得了法语的学士学位,由此可知,男士大学期间所学的专业是法语
Theyaregoingto______(紧急情况时调动军队).
A、Shehasgotmorethanonereasonforquitting.B、Shehasbeenfeelingpressureforalongtime.C、Shehasmanycomplaintsagai
A、Allcoldsarelinkedtosomepressure.B、Emotionalstresscancausecolds.C、Heavysmokingincreasestheriskofacold.D、Man
随机试题
婴儿一般在几个月可以爬行
判断有机磷农药中毒最可靠的化验检查指标是
若当事人对行政机关的行政复议决定不服,可以若当事人对复议的决定不服而申请行政诉讼的,应该是在接到复议决定书后的多长时间内依法申请
常温下,皮肤的物理散热速度主要决定于给高热患者用冰帽降温是通过增加
新生儿室的室温应保持在
背景资料:北京地区某公共建筑工程,地上10层,地下2层,建筑面积25780m2。采暖通风空调及生活热水供应系统、照明系统的全年能耗比上年度降低40%,且静态投资回收期已到5年。使用单位决定严格按照国家有关节能改造工程规定改造,节能改造前使用单位组织进行了
霍去病墓前石刻保存至今的有______件,其中______是石刻群的主像。
民警收集物证、书证不符合法定程序的,该物证、书证一律予以排除,不得使用。()
在区间[0,1]内随机取出两个数,则这两个数的平方和也在区间[0,1]内的概率是()。
在近代历史上,辛亥革命是中国人民为救亡图存、振兴中华而奋起革命的一个里程碑,但是以失败而告终。辛亥革命的失败,从根本上说是因为
最新回复
(
0
)