首页
外语
计算机
考研
公务员
职业资格
财经
工程
司法
医学
专升本
自考
实用职业技能
登录
外语
Is science infinite? Can it keep giving us profound insights into the world forever? Or is it already bumping into limits? In hi
Is science infinite? Can it keep giving us profound insights into the world forever? Or is it already bumping into limits? In hi
admin
2021-12-15
27
问题
Is science infinite? Can it keep giving us profound insights into the world forever? Or is it already bumping into limits? In his 2011 book The Beginning of Infinity physicist David Deutsch made the case for boundlessness. When I asked him about consciousness, he replied; "I think nothing worth understanding will always remain a mystery. And consciousness seems apparently worth understanding. "
At a meeting I just attended in Switzerland, " The Mystery of Human Consciousness," another famous British physicist, Martin Rees, challenged Deutsch’s optimism. In that essay Rees calls The Beginning of Infinity "provocative and excellent" but disputes Deutsch’s central claim that science is boundless. Science "will hit the buffers (缓冲区) at some point," Rees warns.
There are two reasons why this might happen. The optimistic one is that we clean up and understand certain areas (such as atomic physics) to the point that there’s no more to say. A second, more worrying possibility is that we’ll reach the limits of what our brains can grasp. There might be concepts, crucial to a full understanding of physical reality. Efforts to understand very complex systems, such as our own brains, might well be the first to hit such limits. Perhaps complex collectives of atoms, whether brains or electronic machines, can never know all there is to know about themselves.
The riddle of consciousness is a synecdoche for the riddle of humanity. What are we, really? For most of our history, religion has given us the answer. We are immortal souls, children of a loving god, striving to reach heaven. Most modern scientists reject these religious explanations, but they cannot agree on an alternative. They have proposed a bewildering variety of answers to the question of what we really are.
Science will never resolve these disagreements and converge on a single, true theory of what we are, for two reasons. One is that we will never have a "consciousness meter," an objective means of measuring consciousness in non-human things. The other is that we are too varying, too creative, to be captured by single theory. Science itself keeps transforming us, with technologies as diverse as brain implants, genetic therapy and ideas as diverse as queer theory and integrated information theory. To be human means to be a work in progress.
Deutsch’s claim that science is infinite also has a contradiction at its core. He wants science to solve the deepest mysteries, like consciousness, and yet to have more mysteries to solve, forever. That is a radical assertion about the structure of nature, which to my mind reflects wishful thinking rather than hard-headed realism.
Deutsch is both wrong and right. He is wrong that science can solve every mystery, and especially consciousness. We will never understand, once and for all, who we are. But Deutsch is right that science is potentially infinite, if infinite means never-ending. It is precisely because we can never achieve total self-knowledge that we will keep seeking it forever.
Which of the following statements may David Deutsch agree with?
选项
A、The case study of physics should be unlimited.
B、The scientific mysteries are worth understanding.
C、The puzzle of consciousness will be worked out.
D、Science will finally hit a bottleneck somewhere.
答案
C
解析
由题干中的人名关键词DaVid Deutsch定位到原文第一段。推理判断题。本题考查对戴维.多伊奇的观点的理解。由定位段可知,戴维.多伊奇认为科学是无极限的,更详细的解释在第一段最后两句对他原话的引用。他的原话可以理解为,所有值得理解的事情都终将会被弄清楚,而意识就是这样值得弄清楚的谜题,可见他认为意识这一谜题是会被弄清楚的,故C)为答案。A)“物理学的个案研究是没有止境的”在原文没有提及,故排除;B)“科学谜题是值得理解的”是对文章引用的戴维.多伊奇的原话的误解,多伊奇的意思是说只要值得理解的事情都会被科学弄清楚,故排除;D)“科学最终会在某处遭遇瓶颈”与戴维.多伊奇的观点恰好相反,故排除。
转载请注明原文地址:https://kaotiyun.com/show/IPx7777K
0
大学英语六级
相关试题推荐
CompaniesAreWorkingwithConsumerstoReduceWasteA)Asconsumers,weareverywasteful.Annually,theworldgenerates1.
EffectiveFriday,ScreenActorsGuild-AmericanFederationofTelevisionandRadioArtists(SAG-AFTRA)hasdeclaredastrikeagai
Whatistheplaceofartinacultureofinattention?RecentvisitorstotheLouvrereportthattouristscannowspendonlyami
A、Itmarksabreakthroughinbehavioralscience.B、Itadoptsaconventionalapproachtoresearch.C、Itsupportsapieceofconve
SurfingtheInternetduringclassdoesn’tjuststealfocusfromtheeducator:italsohurtsstudentswho’realreadystruggling
Theroboticsrevolutionissettobringhumansfacetofacewithanoldfear—man-madecreationsassmartandcapableasweareb
A、Theirappreciationofhelpfromtheoutsiders.B、Theirsenseofsharingandcaring.C、Theirreadinesstoadapttotechnology.
Itmaycomeasasurprisetomanyanexhaustedmotherorfather—butthinkingaboutyourchildrencouldimproveyourmemory,ast
A、Helearnsproblemsshouldbesolvedwithviolence.B、Heknowsthepainisnature’swayofteachingchildren.C、Heunderstands
WhytheMonaLisaStandsOutA)Haveyoueverfallenforanovelandbeenamazednottofinditonlistsofgreatbooks?Orwal
随机试题
违反刑法、危害社会的是( )犯罪自然人具有刑事责任能力的是( )
收入增加会使所有者权益增加,费用减少也会使所有者权益增加。()
男性,74岁。反复咳嗽、咳痰40年,再发加重伴气短2天。查体:口唇发绀,桶状胸,双肺叩诊呈过清音,左上肺呼吸音消失,双下肺散在干湿哕音,心率124次/分,心律不齐。目前除COPD急性加重外,最可能存在的诊断是
以工业产权、非专利技术作价出资的比例不得超过投资项目资本金总额的( ),国家对采用高新技术成果有特别规定的除外。
中倍数泡沫灭火系统中,()主要适用于四周不完全封闭的A类火灾场所、限定位置的流散B类火灾场所和固定位置面积不大于100m2的流淌B类火灾场所。
在Word编辑状态下,格式刷可以复制()。
百思买模式的“买断经营”“现款现货”是最有利的商业模式。百思买模式通过现金买断的方式取得卖场的主导权,购买家电厂商的商品,并承担商品的折旧损失,门店促销由百思买员工承担,通过规模采购和购销差价赚取利润。根据上述定义,下列属于百思买模式范畴的是:
设总体X的概率密度为X1,X2,…,Xn是取自总体X的简单随机样本.求D()
CAMPINGAlthoughsomegroupsofpeoplehavealwayslivedoutdoorsintents,campingasweknowittodayonlybegantobe
经过二十多年的快速发展,西部地区已奠定了一定的物资技术基础,社会保持稳定,市场经济体制正在逐步完善之中。这些都为西部经济持续快速增长创造了有利的市场环境。同时,中国政府一直坚持把扩大内需与调整经济结构、推动科技进步、促进对外开放结合起来。随着西部
最新回复
(
0
)