首页
外语
计算机
考研
公务员
职业资格
财经
工程
司法
医学
专升本
自考
实用职业技能
登录
外语
Measuring Organisational Performance There is clear-cut evidence that, for a period of at least one year, supervision which incr
Measuring Organisational Performance There is clear-cut evidence that, for a period of at least one year, supervision which incr
admin
2014-05-25
109
问题
Measuring Organisational Performance
There is clear-cut evidence that, for a period of at least one year, supervision which increases the direct pressure for productivity can achieve significant increases in production. However, such short-term increases are obtained only at a substantial and serious cost to the organisation.
To what extent can a manager make an impressive earnings record over a short period of one to three years by exploiting the company’s investment in the human organisation in his plant or division? To what extent will the quality of his organisation suffer if he does so? The following is a description of an important study conducted by the Institute for Social Research designed to answer these questions.
The study covered 500 clerical employees in four parallel divisions. Each division was organised in exactly the same way, used the same technology, did exactly the same kind of work, and had employees of comparable aptitudes.
Productivity in all four of the divisions depended on the number of clerks involved. The work entailed the processing of accounts and generating of invoices. Although the volume of work was considerable, the nature of the business was such that it could only be processed as it came along. Consequently, the only way in which productivity could be increased was to change the size of the work group.
The four divisions were assigned to two experimental programmes on a random basis. Each programme was assigned at random a division that had been historically high in productivity and a division that had been below average in productivity. No attempt was made to place a division in the programme that would best fit its habitual methods of supervision used by the manager, assistant managers, supervisors and assistant supervisors.
The experiment at the clerical level lasted for one year. Beforehand, several months were devoted to planning, and there was also a training period of approximately six months. Productivity was measured continuously and computed weekly throughout the year. The attitudes of employees and supervisory staff towards their work were measured just before and after the period.
Turning now to the heart of the study, in two divisions an attempt was made to change the supervision so that the decision levels were pushed down and detailed supervision of the workers reduced. More general supervision of the clerks and their supervisors was introduced. In addition, the managers, assistant managers, supervisors and assistant supervisors of these two divisions were trained in group methods of leadership, which they endeavoured to use as much as their skill would permit during the experimental year. For easy reference, the experimental changes in these two divisions will be labelled the ’participative programme’.
In the other two divisions, by contrast, the programme called for modifying the supervision so as to increase the closeness of supervision and move the decision levels upwards. This will be labelled the ’hierarchically controlled programme’. These changes were accomplished by a further extension of the scientific management approach. For example, one of the major changes made was to have the jobs timed and to have standard times computed. This showed that these divisions were overstaffed by about 30%. The general manager then ordered the managers of these two divisions to cut staff by 25%. This was done by transfers without replacing the persons who left; no one was to be dismissed.
Results of the Experiment
Changes in Productivity
Figure 1 shows the changes in salary costs per unit of work, which reflect the change in productivity that occurred in the divisions. As will be observed, the hierarchically controlled programmes increased productivity by about 25%. This was a result of the direct orders from the general manager to reduce staff by that amount. Direct pressure produced a substantial increase in production.
A significant increase in productivity of 20% was also achieved in the participative programme, but this was not as great an increase as in the hierarchically controlled programme. To bring about this improvement, the clerks themselves participated in the decision to reduce the size of the work group.(They were aware of course that productivity increases were sought by management in conducting these experiments.)Obviously, deciding to reduce the size of a work group by eliminating some of its members is probably one of the most difficult decisions for a work group to make. Yet the clerks made it. In fact, one division in the participative programme increased its productivity by about the same amount as each of the two divisions in the hierarchically controlled programme. The other participative division, which historically had been the poorest of all the divisions, did not do so well and increased productivity by only 15%.
Changes in Attitudes
Although both programmes had similar effects on productivity, they had significantly different results in other respects. The productivity increases in the hierarchically controlled programme were accompanied by shifts in an adverse direction in such factors as loyalty, attitudes, interest, and involvement in the work. But just the opposite was true in the participative programme.
For example, Figure 2 shows that when more general supervision and increased participation were provided, the employees’ feeling of responsibility to see that the work got done increased. Again, when the supervisor was away, they kept on working. In the hierarchically controlled programme, however, the feeling of responsibility decreased, and when the supervisor was absent, work tended to stop.
As Figure 3 shows, the employees in the participative programme at the end of the year felt that their manager and assistant manager were ’closer to them’ than at the beginning of the year. The opposite was true in the hierarchical programme. Moreover, as Figure 4 shows, employees in the participative programme felt that their supervisors were more likely to ’pull’ for them, or for the company and them, and not be solely interested in the company, while in the hierarchically controlled programme, the opposite trend occurred.
The experiment was designed to
选项
A、establish whether increased productivity should be sought at any cost.
B、show that four divisions could use the same technology.
C、perfect a system for processing accounts.
D、exploit the human organisation of a company in order to increase profits.
答案
A // establish whether increased productivity should be sought at any cost
解析
转载请注明原文地址:https://kaotiyun.com/show/JUNO777K
本试题收录于:
雅思阅读题库雅思(IELTS)分类
0
雅思阅读
雅思(IELTS)
相关试题推荐
Solveeachofthefollowingequationsforx.(a)5x-7=28(b)12-5x=x+30(c)5(x+2)=l-3x(d)(x+6)(2x-l)=0(e)x2+5x-14=
Usetherulesofexponentstosimplifythefollowing.(a)(n5)(n-3)(b)(s7)(t7)(e)(w5)-3(f)(50)(d3)
Ellenhasreceivedthefollowingscoreson3exams:82,74,and90.WhatscorewillEllenneedtoreceiveonthenextexamsoth
AtMegalomaniaIndustries,factoryworkerswerepaid$20perhourin1990and$10perhourin2000.TheCEOofMegalomaniaIndus
A、summarizethemainpointoftherefutationtotheargumentdiscussedinthepassageB、explainwhythehypothesisundercritici
A、agradualmovementfromtheideaofgenderlesswritingtoawritingthatoriginatesinthewoman’sbodyB、ashiftbetweenadve
Themostcompellingevidenceoftherisksofcarcinogeniceffectsofenvironmentalpollutantscomesfromanimaldata,suc
McClary’sposition,concerningtheprocessbywhichmusicisgenderedasmasculineorfeminine,isthatsocially-grounded
Indescribingthewayaseafloordisturbancesuchasmovementalongafaultreshapestheseasurfaceintoatsunami,mode
Ithasbeenchallengingformosttwentieth-centuryAmericanpolicy-makerstorecapturethememoryoftheearlyUnitedSta
随机试题
堵车现象并不是只存在于个别国家,但不同的国家有不同的对策:德国消除“高峰”时段;以色列让自行车取代汽车;西班牙大力发展公共交通;等等。这种现象说明()。①辩证的否定是联系的环节②要坚持一切从实际出发,实事求是③矛盾的普遍性与特殊性相统
按用途可将数据访问页分为三种类型,分别是()
脑膜中动脉穿()
JapanbombedPearlHarborin1941.TheUnitedStateswasmadattheJapanesesotheymademanyJapanese-Americansleavetheirho
“索赔金额=某项工作调整后的实际总费用-该项工作的报价费用”是( )的计算公式。
石膏制品的物理性能有()。
在互联网金融领域,个体网络借贷机构的性质是()。
年昕得在12万元以上的个人自行申报纳税时,应当填写《个人所的纳税申报表》,填写该表时应对各项所得计算年所得,下列关于年所得计算表述中正确的是()
根据美国心理学家卡特尔的智力分类,下面不属于晶体智力的是()。
Whatisthereasonforteenstodothesameastheirpeers?
最新回复
(
0
)