首页
外语
计算机
考研
公务员
职业资格
财经
工程
司法
医学
专升本
自考
实用职业技能
登录
考研
On a five to three vote, the Supreme Court knocked out much of Arizona’ s immigration law Monday— a modest policy victory for th
On a five to three vote, the Supreme Court knocked out much of Arizona’ s immigration law Monday— a modest policy victory for th
admin
2016-01-05
45
问题
On a five to three vote, the Supreme Court knocked out much of Arizona’ s immigration law Monday— a modest policy victory for the Obama Administration. But on the more important matter of the Constitution, the decision was an 8-0 defeat for the Administration’s effort to upset the balance of power between the federal government and the states.
In Arizona v. United States, the majority overturned three of the four contested provisions of Arizona’ s’ controversial plan to have state and local police enforce federal immigration law. The Constitutional principles that Washington alone has the power to "establish a uniform Rule of Naturalization" and that federal laws precede state laws are noncontroversial. Arizona had attempted to fashion state policies that ran parallel to the existing federal ones.
Justice Anthony Kennedy Joined by Chief Justice John Roberts and the Court’s liberals, ruled that the state flew too close to the federal sun. On the overturned provisions the majority held the congress had deliberately "occupied the field" and Arizona had thus intruded on the federal’s privileged powers.
However, the Justices said that Arizona police would be allowed to verity the legal status of people who come in contact with law enforcement. That’s because Congress has always envisioned joint federal-state immigration enforcement and explicitly encourages state officers to share information and cooperate with federal colleagues.
Two of the three objecting Justice—Samuel Alito and Clarence Thomas—agreed with this Constitutional logic but disagreed about which Arizona rules conflicted with the federal statute. The only major objection came from Justice Antonin Scalia, who offered an even more robust defense of state privileges going back to the Alien and Sedition Acts.
The 8-0 objection to President Obama turns on what Justice Samuel Alito describes in his objection as "a shocking assertion of federal executive power". The White House argued that Arizona’s laws conflicted with its enforcement priorities, even if state laws complied with federal statutes to the letter. In effect, the White House claimed that it could invalidate any otherwise legitimate state law that it disagrees with.
Some powers do belong exclusively to the federal government, and control of citizenship and the borders is among them. But if Congress wanted to prevent states from using their own resources to check immigration status, it could. It never did so. The administration was in essence asserting that because it didn’t want to carry out Congress’s immigration wishes, no state should be allowed to do so either. Every Justice rightly rejected this remarkable claim.
Three provisions of Arizona’s plan were overturned because they
选项
A、deprived the federal police of Constitutional powers.
B、disturbed the power balance between different states.
C、overstepped the authority of federal immigration law.
D、contradicted both the federal and state policies.
答案
C
解析
细节题。根据关键词Three provisions,overturned定位于第二段。结合第一段内容以及第二段最后一句话可知.亚利桑那州四分之三有争议的计划条款被推翻是因为其挑战联邦移民法的权威,也即C项表述正确。overstep意为“逾越”。A项原文未提及。B项与原文表述不符。D项太宽泛,不如C项具体。
转载请注明原文地址:https://kaotiyun.com/show/OtsZ777K
0
考研英语一
相关试题推荐
Thedevil,astheoldsayinggoes,isinthedetails.Or,inthecaseofthenewEstonianlawsettingupanationalgeneticdata
ThelowerhouseofAustralia’sParliamentpassedsweepingchangesinimmigrationpolicyonWednesdaythataremeanttodiscourag
TheObamaadministrationwonavictorytodayintheircampaigntostrikedownvoterIDlaws.OnlydaysaftertheUnitedStatesD
Illegalimmigration,whichhassparkedpoliticalandsocialdisorderincommunitiesacrossthenation,isonthewane,according
AttheendofhisworkdayinsteamymidtownManhattan,JoelTerrycravesrelaxingoutdoors.Butthesedays,insteadofstarting
AttheendofhisworkdayinsteamymidtownManhattan,JoelTerrycravesrelaxingoutdoors.Butthesedays,insteadofstarting
Customhasnotcommonlybeenregardedasasubjectofanygreatmoment.Theinnerworkingsofourbrainswefeeltobeuniquely
Mothersinterferewiththeirchildren’slivesevenmorethanmostoffspringrealize.Thattheynagabouteatinghabitsiswellk
Mothersinterferewiththeirchildren’slivesevenmorethanmostoffspringrealize.Thattheynagabouteatinghabitsiswellk
随机试题
在Access2010中,有关设置字段属性的叙述错误的是_____。
猪向牛抱怨它不受人们的欢迎:“人们经常提及你的善良和你那仁慈的目光。确实,你给予了人们牛奶和奶油,但我给予人类的更多,我奉献人类熏肉和火腿,但是,人们还是不喜欢我,为什么?”牛想了想说:“也许是因为我是在生前奉献的。”牛的回答很巧妙,生前奉献是针对猪的评论
使用下列哪种药物时应测心率
钱迷为新世纪化肥厂的采购员,其受该化肥厂的委托持空白合同书和空白支票前往河边编织袋厂采购50万条编织袋。钱迷发现该编织袋厂的编织袋存在严重的质量问题,编织袋厂亦观察到钱迷不想购买该厂的编织袋,但又不愿意放弃这一大单生意,于是,对钱迷许以高额回扣,每条编织袋
( )有助于确定一个特定企业或特定的建设工程可能遭受哪些损失以及在何种情况下遭受这种损失。
项目监理机构的组织形式应根据()选择。
新进入某市场的银行最适合采取的定位策略是()
下列说法中正确的有( )。
设二次型f(x1,x2,x3)=ax12+ax22+(a1)x32+2x1x3-2x2x3.求二次型f的矩阵的所有特征值;
若实体A和B是一对多的联系,实体B和C是一对一的联系,则实体A和C的联系是
最新回复
(
0
)