首页
外语
计算机
考研
公务员
职业资格
财经
工程
司法
医学
专升本
自考
实用职业技能
登录
外语
The academics, at Miami University of Ohio, fill in questionnaires anonymously, evaluating their bosses’ effectiveness, with roo
The academics, at Miami University of Ohio, fill in questionnaires anonymously, evaluating their bosses’ effectiveness, with roo
admin
2017-02-13
89
问题
The academics, at Miami University of Ohio, fill in questionnaires anonymously, evaluating their bosses’ effectiveness, with room to add more detailed remarks at the end. These comments are summarised and returned to all academic staff in the department, who agree whether the summary is fair, and the evaluation is then used not only to inform individual chairs about what sort of job they are doing, but also whether a pay rise or promotion should be in the offing.
This kind of evaluation is relatively common in American universities. But U. K. universities have always been much warier about the idea.
Now union members at the University of Sussex want this to change, proposing that all academic staff should be given the chance to appraise their heads of school. They argue that with students increasingly asked to assess the effectiveness of the teaching they receive, academics should also be able to comment on the effectiveness of university management.
A proposal to introduce upward appraisal was put to the university last term, but was rejected by managers. The union then conducted its own survey of academic and academic-related staff, but managers said this was unauthorized, flawed and represented a breach of trust and mutual confidence on the part of the union. The 300 responses had to be torn up.
Upward appraisal is not entirely unknown in U. K. universities. In 1996, Gillian Evans and Kevin Moloney produced a report on the practice for the Council for Academic Freedom and Standards, which found that eight of the 41 U. K. institutions who replied to a survey used it in some form, although usually informally. The report urged more institutions to adopt it, arguing that staff were increasingly subject to appraisal from above and that equitable treatment of staff is important and can only result in efficiency gains.
Little has changed since the report was published, with upward appraisal in U. K. universities remaining rare, although some institutions do use 360-degree feedback—feedback by selected peers, subordinates and seniors—as a management development tool. This is done at Warwick University, which strongly insists that it is "feedback", not "appraisal", and is voluntary, confidential and "not linked to appraisal or remuneration in any way".
Daniel Kane, a teacher in English and American literature at Sussex says: "We’re expected to act on what students say. And we do. We are simply asking for the same rights and same respect that our students have. But we aren’t being given the basic dignity of being able to say what works and what doesn’t. What are they afraid of?"
Evans says academics feel increasingly powerless—exposed both to what students think of them, through Facebook and other sites, and to the pressures on managers to reduce staff costs. "Appraisal has moved from being equal-to-equal to top-down," she says. "It has moved from being a friendly discussion about what one wants to do with one’s career to obligations to do something. There has also been a shift from relative job security to more short-term contracts. "
Nick Holley, head of the human resources centre at Henley Business School, University of Reading, says it can be useful for managers to see how others see them, but warns that this kind of feedback has to be conducted carefully. Scoring managers for different qualities is not only inexact, as some people mark more highly than others, but could tempt people to see management capability in terms of numbers rather than taking account of its complexity.
What issue does the author mainly discuss in the passage?
选项
A、The academics in America can evaluate their bosses’ effectiveness.
B、Academics feel increasingly powerless.
C、Whether upward appraisal in universities should be done as the U. S. does.
D、Scoring managers for different qualities will lead to, false judgement of management capability.
答案
C
解析
概括大意题。根据题干,需要抓住作者主要讨论的问题,是英国是否需要像美国一样实行上行评价,因此选项C正确。A选项是事实,而非讨论的问题。选项B和D只是对文中具体细节问题的说明。
转载请注明原文地址:https://kaotiyun.com/show/SPi7777K
0
大学英语四级
相关试题推荐
Onlyhalfofwomenactuallyenjoybeingpraisedandmanyothersmisinterpretwell-meantwords,asoffensive,accordingtoanew
A、Getsomeavailableinformationaboutthepost.B、Haveabetterunderstandingofhisopponents.C、Showhisinterestandconfide
A、Copysomeinformationfromhisclassmates.B、LookforsomeinformationontheInternet.C、Tryhisluckinanotherlibrary.D、B
It’sverypopulartoseecollegeanduniversitystudentsspendingtheirvacationpartyinginawarmbarwithnoparentsaroundi
It’sverypopulartoseecollegeanduniversitystudentsspendingtheirvacationpartyinginawarmbarwithnoparentsaroundi
Thewidespreaduseofsearchenginesandonlinedatabaseshasaffectedthewaypeoplerememberinformation,researchersarerepo
Thewidespreaduseofsearchenginesandonlinedatabaseshasaffectedthewaypeoplerememberinformation,researchersarerepo
Thewidespreaduseofsearchenginesandonlinedatabaseshasaffectedthewaypeoplerememberinformation,researchersarerepo
We’renowwitnessingtheemergenceofanadvancedeconomybasedoninformationandknowledge.Physicallabor,rawmaterials,ami
We’renowwitnessingtheemergenceofanadvancedeconomybasedoninformationandknowledge.Physicallabor,rawmaterials,ami
随机试题
癫证多由痰气郁结所致,久则耗伤
《中华人民共和国企业破产法》规定,在重整期间,()。
环境条件和工程内容均较简单的工程项目,其招标程序中常常不采用的步骤是()。
多年来,市区某路口交通拥堵严重,机动车占用非机动车车道的现象十分普遍,社会工作者曾俊发现此问题后,调研发现造成拥堵的真正原因是该路段行人不遵守交通规则,于是曾俊决定在该路段宣传遵守交通规则的重要性,维持交通的正常运行,从而使该路段的拥堵得到有效改变。曾俊的
下列著作和教育家匹配正确的有()。
尽管从中央政府到地方政府都十分重视农民工问题,但问题办起来总显得慢半拍甚至慢几拍,农民工问题涉及数量大,执行起来有难度,这是人所共知的,但不少政策在一些地方三五年都仍停留在讨论阶段,还总是“需要研究”,这就让人想不明白。该语段下面可能要表达的主要意
Comparisonsweredrawnbetweenthedevelopmentoftelevisioninthe20thcenturyandthediffusionofprintinginthe15thand1
张某为文物收藏家,李某为。附庸风雅之富商。张某谎称已得到晋朝大书法家王羲之《兰亭序》正本,李某欲据为己有,便与张某达成买卖王羲之《兰亭序》正本的合同。合同约定,该《兰亭序》正本以100万元成交,在交付并经专家鉴定之前,李某预付20万元,余下80万元待经专家
设单位质点在水平面内作直线运动,初速度ν|t=0=ν0,已知阻力与速度成正比(比例系数为1),问t为多少时此质点的速度为?并求到此时刻该质点所经过的路程.
在MOV WORD PTR [0072],55AAH指令的机器代码中,最后一个字节是______。
最新回复
(
0
)