首页
外语
计算机
考研
公务员
职业资格
财经
工程
司法
医学
专升本
自考
实用职业技能
登录
考研
Ah, the naivety of the older generation. Nearly 500 eminent astronomers, biologists, chemists, physicists and earth scientists h
Ah, the naivety of the older generation. Nearly 500 eminent astronomers, biologists, chemists, physicists and earth scientists h
admin
2017-02-28
29
问题
Ah, the naivety of the older generation. Nearly 500 eminent astronomers, biologists, chemists, physicists and earth scientists have been surveyed to identify the "core traits of exemplary scientists". Their answer? Honesty is critical, second only to curiosity, and we ought to do more to instil it in those considering science careers.
Ironically, they are deceiving themselves. Researchers have never been whiter than white. Here are a couple of revealing numbers. About 2 per cent of scientists admit to at least one act of research misconduct. But as a whole, researchers say that around 14 per cent of their colleagues are involved in such behaviour. Someone’s not being straight.
Those figures come from a 2009 meta-analysis (far more scientifically reliable than a single sample of " honoured" academics) , that also found one-third of scientists confessed to "questionable research practices" such as cooking data, mining it for a significant result that is then presented as the original target of the study, selective publication or concealing conflicts of interest.
We may never know for sure how widespread such behaviour is. According to another meta-analysis published in October, scientists are becoming less likely to admit to fabrication, falsification or plagiarism. That study also found that researchers see plagiarism as more heinous than making results up. They are more likely to report a colleague they catch in an act of plagiarism than one fabricating or falsifying data.
How can this be so, when honesty is supposedly such an essential attribute? Because it gets the job done. Raymond De Vries at the University of Michigan and colleagues have argued that data manipulation based on intuition of what a result should look like is "normal misbehaviour." They see such common misbehaviours as having "a useful and irreplaceable role" in science. Why? Because of "the ambiguities and everyday demands of scientific research."
In other words, data isn’t often as clean as you would like. According to Frederick Grinnell, an ethicist at the University of Texas, intuition is " an important, and perhaps in the end a researcher’ s best, guide to distinguishing between data and noise." Sometimes you just know that data point was an anomaly to be ignored.
Should we do something to make science more virtuous? Probably not. Those eminent academics questioned for the survey by Michigan State University, which was released today at the annual meeting of the American Association for the Advancement of Science, are hopelessly optimistic when it comes to improving ethical standards: 94 per cent of them said students can learn scientific values and virtues from "exemplary scientists."
According to Frederick Grinnell, intuition can serve as
选项
A、a judge.
B、a critic.
C、a guide.
D、a challenger.
答案
C
解析
(1)根据题干关键词Frederick Grinnell定位至第6段。其实,第5、6段都在分析“研究者对捏造或编造数据持有宽容态度的原因”。(2)根据文章,Frederick Grinnell认为“直觉是重要的,也许最终是最佳向导”(第6段:guide)。其实,有关直觉的作用在第5段就已经提到了(第5段:intuition,normal misbehavious)。故答案为选项[C]。
转载请注明原文地址:https://kaotiyun.com/show/SsbZ777K
0
考研英语一
相关试题推荐
Itusedtobesostraightforward.Ateamofresearchersworkingtogetherinthelaboratorywouldsubmittheresultsoftheirres
Ofallthecomponentsofagoodnight’ssleep,dreamsseemtobeleastwithinourcontrol.Indreams,awindowopensintoaworl
[A]Somearchaeologicalsiteshavealwaysbeeneasilyobservable—forexample,theParthenoninAthens,Greece;thepyramidsofGi
Doyourememberallthoseyearswhenscientistsarguedthatsmokingwouldkillusbutthedoubtersinsistedthatwedidn’tknow
Arecentstudy,whichwaspublishedinlastweek’sJournaloftheAmericanMedicalAssociation,offersapictureofhowriskyit
Large,multinationalcorporationsmaybethecompanieswhoseupsanddownsseizeheadlines.Buttoafargreaterextentthanmos
Somedayastrangerwillreadyoure-mailwithoutyourpermissionorscantheWebsiteyou’vevisited.Orperhapssomeonewillcas
Wemaintainthatingeneralafocusonpositiveinformationbenefitswell-being.However,thereareprobablyconditionswhenac
Ifplanningofferssomanytangiblebenefits,whydomanyprofessionalsresistit?Somearemorecomfortablewithacting,rather
Expertshavelongknownthatchildrenimitatemanyofthedeeds—goodandbad—thattheyseeontelevision.Butithasrarelybeen
随机试题
CCITT对30/32路PCM。系统的同步系统规定,复帧前方保护时间为()。
A.血管通透性增加B.中性粒细胞趋化作用C.两者均有D.两者均无缓激肽
A.阴虚B.标实本虚C.属实属热D.伏痰遇感引触肺胀的病理性质多属
心脏收缩力增强时,静脉回心血量增加,这主要是因为()(1999年)
生物碱最常用的沉淀反应试剂是
根据《土地管理法》及其他相关自然资源立法的规定,下列说法中正确的是()。
当项目处于规划或项目建议书阶段,又无其他类似工程可以参照时,其投资估算的编制方法一般采用()。
小众经济:指面向小众人群的个性化定制模式,即采用个性化生产加工方式为用户提供独一无二的产品,实现精准服务,以满足消费者需求。下列不属于小众经济的是()。
汉代首先提出“独尊儒术"思想的是()
在大数据技术框架中,不包括__________环节。
最新回复
(
0
)