首页
外语
计算机
考研
公务员
职业资格
财经
工程
司法
医学
专升本
自考
实用职业技能
登录
外语
"It doesn’t matter what ethical assumptions you use", says Michael Grubb, an expert on climate change policy, cold financial arg
"It doesn’t matter what ethical assumptions you use", says Michael Grubb, an expert on climate change policy, cold financial arg
admin
2009-06-24
40
问题
"It doesn’t matter what ethical assumptions you use", says Michael Grubb, an expert on climate change policy, cold financial arguments are enough to decide what to do about global warming.
As arguments over the science behind climate change have cooled, the question of how much nations should be willing to pay has come to dominate the debate. Now Martin Weitzman has developed the first thorough method for including unlikely but extreme events in cost-benefit analyses. When you take into account extreme temperature rises of more than around 6℃, he says, they dominate all other options and effectively demand that investment aimed at stopping them be made now.
Economists say that such events are theoretically possible but are so unlikely and lie so far in the future that it is not cost-effective to spend money to prevent them. Computer models also suggest that using more renewable energy and reducing emissions in other ways would almost certainly avoid extreme temperature increases. But Weitzman’s results are so dramatic that some economists, many of whom argued in favour of caution, are shifting their position.
Environmental groups argue that the risk of extreme events justifies large investment now, but other groups, notably industry-orientated think tanks and many Republican politicians, have resisted such calls. "In the United States, cost-benefit analyses have been used to back up questions about whether investment is worth much mow", says Grubb. "This throws a pretty fundamental spanner in the works".
The new method also backs up the conclusions of the Stern Review on the Economics of Climate Change, albeit via different methods. Stem’s cost-benefit analysis, which was published in October 2006, did not consider extreme events. Even so, he found that the benefits of investing now would be enormous: The world could save $2.5 trillion a year if the rise in CO
2
was halted at levels around 50 percent greater than today. But when Stern put a price on the damages that rising temperatures could cause, he valued future costs in today’s money. Many economists, including Weitzman, criticized that assumption, arguing that it ignores the fact that investments made now are expected to be worth more in the future.
The debate remains unresolved, as ethical arguments continue to rage about how to value future generations. But Weitzman’s study shows that once extreme evens are included, the argument becomes irrelevant. This is because the potential cost of extreme evens is so great that they come to dominate the assessment of risk, whatever method is used to compare the value of present and future generations. "Weitzman’s work’ would have received substantial attention in the Stem report. He would have used it as supporting evidence". Says Grubb.
Weitzman could also create a headache for policy-makers. The analysis shows that traditional cost-benefit calculations are getting it wrong, but it does so only by providing that extreme events dominate the costs when included in the calculations. It cannot put a figure on how much should be spent now, unlike the old techniques.
选项
A、It is more sophisticated than traditional cost-benefit analysis.
B、It takes ethical assumptions into calculating the amount of investment.
C、Extreme events should be considered in cost-benefit analysis.
D、It tells us that we should take the problem much more seriously.
答案
D
解析
转载请注明原文地址:https://kaotiyun.com/show/TXTd777K
本试题收录于:
公共英语五级笔试题库公共英语(PETS)分类
0
公共英语五级笔试
公共英语(PETS)
相关试题推荐
Wehavetoaskthemtoquittalkinginorderthatallpeoplepresentcouldhearusclearly.
Itiseasytodeterminewhethersmokingishazardous.Malesmokershavealowerdeathratefromheartdiseasethanfemalesmoke
SmokingSince1939,numerousstudieshavebeenconductedtodeterminewhethersmokingisahealthhazard.Thetrendoftheev
SuccessStoriesOneofthemostsuccessfulfashioncompaniesintheworldisBenetton.TheBenettonfamilyopenedtheirfirst
WhatMakesaSoccerPlayerGreat?Soccerisplayedbymillionsofpeopleallovertheworld,buttherehaveonlybeenfewpla
SpaceResearchDoeswalkingonthemoonmakelifebetterforpeopleonearth?【51】alltheproblemsofourownworld,whyshou
WhyPeopleUsePseudonyms(假名字)?Youcan’tchoosethenameyouaregivenatbirth,butinmanycountriesyoucanchangeit
VoltsfromtheSky1Lightninghascausedaweandwondersinceoldtimes.AlthoughBenjaminFranklindemonstratedlightningasa
TradingcompaniesputupthemoneyforthefirstEnglishcoloniesinNorthAmerica.
Whatistrueaboutorganicallygrownfoods?
随机试题
试说明事务的ACID特性分别由DBMS的哪个子系统实现。
坚持马克思主义在意识形态领域指导地位的根本制度是()
A.结节病B.淋巴结核C.肺癌、纵隔淋巴结转移D.淋巴瘤E.胸腺瘤女性,30岁,近2周咳嗽、偶有少量白痰,无发热,胸片见双侧肺门及纵隔淋巴结对称性肿大,PPD皮试(一),应考虑
A.细胞毒素类B.抗代谢类C.抗生素类D.生物碱类E.激素类(2006年第126题)环磷酰胺属于化疗药物的
婴儿腹泻伴低钾血症时下列哪一项不正确
A、肼屈嗪B、硝普钠C、尼莫地平D、可乐定E、卡托普利高血压危象伴急性心肌梗死或左室功能衰竭者最好选用
强度、耐热性和抗蠕变性能好,耐水性优良,可用来制造干燥器壳体的是()。
下列施工现场应设置临时室外消防给水系统的有()。
某施工企业年初向银行贷款流动资金100万元,按季计算并支付利息,季度利率2%,则一年支付的利息总和为()万元。
请在【答题】菜单下选择【进入考生文件夹】命令,并按照题目要求完成下面的操作。注意:以下的文件必须都保存在考生文件夹下。销售部助理小王需要针对2012年和2013年的公司产品销售情况进行统计分析,以便制订新的销售计划和工作任务。现在,请按
最新回复
(
0
)