2. 考研
  3. Many states have gone on prison-building sprees, yet the penal system is choked to bursting. To ease the pressure, nearly all co

Many states have gone on prison-building sprees, yet the penal system is choked to bursting. To ease the pressure, nearly all co

admin2013-01-28  63
问题     Many states have gone on prison-building sprees, yet the penal system is choked to bursting. To ease the pressure, nearly all convicted felons are released early—or not locked up at all. "About three of every four convicted criminals," says John Dilulio, a noted Princeton criminologist, " are on the streets without meaningful probation or parole supervision. " And while everyone knows that amateur thugs should be deterred before they become career criminals, it is almost unheard of for judges to send first or second-time offenders to prison.
    Meanwhile, the price of keeping criminals in cages is appalling—a common estimate is $ 30,000 per inmate per year. (To be sure, the cost to society of turning many inmates loose would be even higher.) For tens of thousands of convicts, prison is a graduate school of criminal studies; They emerge more ruthless and savvy than when they entered. And for many offenders, there is even a certain cachet to doing time—a stint in prison becomes a sign of manhood, a status symbol.
But there would be no cachet in chaining a criminal to an outdoor post and flogging him. If young punks were horsewhipped in public after their first conviction, fewer of them would harden into lifelong felons. A humiliating and painful paddling can be applied to the rear end of a crook for a lot less than $30, 000—and prove a lot more educational than 10 years’ worth of prison meals and lockdowns.
    Are we quite certain the Puritans have nothing to teach us about dealing with criminals?
    Of course, their crimes are not our crimes: we do not arrest blasphemers or adulterers. and only gun control fanatics would criminalize the sale of weapons to Indians. (They would criminalize the sale of weapons to anybody.) Nor would the ordeal suffered by poor Joseph Gatchell—the tongue " pierce through" with a hot poker—be regarded today as anything less than torture.
    But what is the objection to corporal punishment that doesn’t maim or mutilate? Instead of a prison term, why not sentence at least some criminals—say, thieves and drunk drivers—to a public whipping?
    "Too degrading," some will say. "Too brutal. " But where is it written that being whipped is more degrading than being caged? Why is it more brutal to flog a wrongdoer than to throw him in prison— where the risk of being beaten, raped, or murdered is terrifyingly high?
    The Boston Globe reported in 1994 that more than 200,000 prison inmates are raped each year, u-sually to the indifference of the guards. "The horrors experienced by many young inmates, particularly those who are convicted of nonviolent offenses," former Supreme Court Justice Harry Blackmun has written, "border on the unimaginable". Are those horrors preferable to the short, sharp shame of corporal punishment?
    Perhaps the Puritans were more enlightened than we think, at least on the subject of punishment. Their sanctions were humiliating and painful, but quick and cheap. Maybe we should readopt a few.
The author is highly suspicious of______.
选项 A、the Puritan values
B、probation and parole supervision
C、humiliating and painful paddling
D、punishment by way of imprisonment
答案D
解析 推理题。第二段提到：监禁犯人成本高，也不能达到改造犯人的目的，罪犯还可能因为坐牢的经历受到其他人的羡慕。从第三段开始，作者提出用清教徒曾经用过的某些体罚方式来代替监禁，既可以起到教育犯罪者的作用，也可以少花钱。可以通过当众体罚的方式，让罪犯蒙羞，使他感到做坏事脸上无光，受人讥笑。由此可知，作者对于用监禁的方式惩罚犯人持怀疑态度，而更加倾向于用清教徒体罚的方式来惩罚犯人。故D符合题意，为正确选项。
转载请注明原文地址:https://kaotiyun.com/show/Usd4777K
0

考研英语一

相关试题推荐
随机试题
最新回复(0)