首页
外语
计算机
考研
公务员
职业资格
财经
工程
司法
医学
专升本
自考
实用职业技能
登录
外语
Which Voting System is Better? Voting is often portrayed as a very simple activity—all that is required being a list of name
Which Voting System is Better? Voting is often portrayed as a very simple activity—all that is required being a list of name
admin
2012-01-16
27
问题
Which Voting System is Better?
Voting is often portrayed as a very simple activity—all that is required being a list of names, boxes and a pen with which to tick the preferred option—but it is actually an intricate process that can take many different forms on which everyone from mathematicians to political scholars, interest groups, politicians and voters often have divergent opinions. Two of the most popular of these voting systems are known as First-Past-the-Post (FPP) and Mixed-Member Proportional (MMP), and they have quite different features.
FPP is one of the simplest voting systems. Voters select one person from a list of candidates in their electorate, and the candidate with the highest number of votes is elected to represent them. While this might sound simple and fair, it can have several undesirable effects. Firstly, because of the’ all or nothing’ result, FPP produces a large number of wasted votes—votes which do not affect the outcome of the election. This is the case in the majority of electorates, which are safe or relatively safe. Consequently, the party that gains the highest number of seats in Parliament may not actually gain the most votes—in the 2005 UK elections, for example, the Labor party governed alone with only 35 percent of the vote. Because of the pressure on voters not to ’ waste’ their vote, FPP tends to foster tactical voting for a rival but less popular candidate, thus sidelining minority voices and third party candidacies in favor of a race between two, often similar, contestants.
MMP attempts to create a parliament that represents a national consensus, rather than combining the results from dozens of local ’ mini-elections’. Voters select their electorate candidate, as in FPP, but they also select a party, which will gain seats in Parliament proportionate to the party vote. This opens the door for representation amongst parties that may have broad support nationally, but not enough support in any single geographical area to win an electorate seat. While Parliament as a whole may be more representative, however, the ability to affect change within parliament can often accrue to a centrist, smaller party that has the ability to essentially choose the government, by selecting between the major parties as coalition partners. This phenomenon is known as the ’tail wagging the dog’. Finally, the party vote tends to bring in Members of Parliament (MPs) in an order that is chosen, not by the electorate, but by the party itself. This is one of MMP’s undemocratic moves that favors party establishment and hierarchy over the will of the public.
New Zealand’s transition from FPP to MMP demonstrates the benefits and drawbacks of each system. In the 1970s, many New Zealanders grew disillusioned with the two-party system. FPP did not provide voters with another viable option; however, the leading third party received a considerable 16 percent of the vote in 1978 but gained only one of the 92 seats in parliament—three years later their vote share was up to 21 percent, but they gained only two seats. A Royal Commission subsequently recommended a shift to MMP, and in 1993 a state-wide referendum was held that passed in favor of the reform.
The 1996 elections wore away much public enthusiasm for MMP, however. The result was indecisive, and with neither major party able to govern alone, the power to form a coalition rested upon a third party, New Zealand First. Instead of forming a coalition with Labor—a party that many voters considered to be its natural ally—the New Zealand First party sided with the National party. This was followed by a subsequent rise in party-hopping—Members of Parliament (MPs) leaving the parties from which they were elected. Eventually, the coalition disbanded with Prime Minister Jenny Shipley sacking New Zealand First leader, Winston Peters, from Cabinet.
Nevertheless, after these initial teething problems, New Zealand voters and politicians have grown accustomed to MMP and learnt to focus on its possibilities rather than its hindrances. One of the most notable benefits is that Parliament has become far more representative of the diversity in modern New Zealand society. MMP introduced a number of MPs who had previously been marginalized from mainstream politics: women, people from diverse ethnic backgrounds, and community activists. Relationships between major and minor parties have also grown more stable, and in many ways minor parties now function as auditors keeping a check on the major parties. MMP is not without its flaws, but the transition has generally been a positive experience.
Questions 14-19
Do the following statements agree with the information given in Reading Passage 2?
FPP uses geographically-determined electorates as a basis for electing MPs.
选项
A、真
B、假
C、NOT GIVEN
答案
C
解析
转载请注明原文地址:https://kaotiyun.com/show/V7VO777K
本试题收录于:
雅思阅读题库雅思(IELTS)分类
0
雅思阅读
雅思(IELTS)
相关试题推荐
Eachofthefollowingnumbershastwodigitsblottedout.Whichofthenumberscouldbethenumberofhoursinxdays,wherexi
Directions:Inthefollowingtypeofquestion,twoquantitiesappear,oneinColumnAandoneinColumnB.Youmustcomparethem
Directions:Inthefollowingtypeofquestion,twoquantitiesappear,oneinColumnAandoneinColumnB.Youmustcomparethem
Ifxisapositiveinteger,whichofthefollowingCANNOTbeaninteger?
Intherectangularcoordinatesystem,segmentOPisrotatedcounterclockwisethroughanangleof90°topositionOQ(notshown).
Inthecoordinatesystembelow,findthefollowing.(a)CoordinatesofpointQ(b)LengthsofPQ,OR,andPR(c)Perimeterof△PQR
*Foreachyear,theworktime,inhours,requiredtopayforafooditemistheaveragepriceofthefooditemdividedbytheav
Attheratesshowninthegraph,whichofthefollowingisclosesttothenumberofhoursofworktimethatwasrequiredtopay
随机试题
T淋巴细胞的主要分化部位是
发明专利申请人于1999年5月4日以邮寄方式将其专利申请文件寄给国家专利局,但专利局通知申请人的专利申请日是1999年5月21日。造成这种结果的原因可能是( )。
风险分析在项目决策中的作用为()。
当()人民政府建设主管部门履行监督检查职责时,有权要求被检查人员出示注册证书。
下列岗位属于基本会计岗位的有()。
甲股份有限公司2016年有关所有者权益变动等的资料如下:(1)2016年7月1日按每股6.5元的发行价增发400万股普通股(每股面值1元);(2)2016年11月1日按每股10元的价格回购120万股普通股(每股面值1元)并予以注销;(3)截至2016
香港特别行政区维护国家安全委员会的职责为()。
当代建立世界新秩序需要一个在各地区内部确立秩序观的一致战略,并将不同地区的秩序相互联系起来。这些目标不一定完全相同或能自我调和。一种极端运动若是获胜,或许会给一个地区带来秩序,但有可能在其他地区造成冲突,或是引发与其他地区的冲突。一种肯定个人尊严和参与式治
郑女士:衡远市过去十年的GDP(国内生产总值)增长率比易阳市高,因此,衡远市的经济前景比易阳市好。胡先生:我不同意你的观点。衡远市的GDP增长率虽然比易阳市高,但易阳市的GDP数值却更大。以下哪项最为准确地概括了郑女士和胡先生争议的焦点
一般说来,在信息系统开发中应用【】的技术比应用正在探索的技术更有助于系统开发的成功和减少风险。
最新回复
(
0
)