首页
外语
计算机
考研
公务员
职业资格
财经
工程
司法
医学
专升本
自考
实用职业技能
登录
外语
In order to understand what a myth really is, must we choose between platitude and sophism? Some claim that human societies mere
In order to understand what a myth really is, must we choose between platitude and sophism? Some claim that human societies mere
admin
2013-03-27
53
问题
In order to understand what a myth really is, must we choose between platitude and sophism? Some claim that human societies merely express, through their mythology, fundamental feelings common to the whole of mankind, such as love, hate, or revenge or that they try to provide some kind of explanations for phenomena which they cannot otherwise understand—astronomical, meteorological, and the like. But why should these societies do it in such elaborate and devious ways, when all of them are also acquainted with empirical explanations? On the other hand, psychoanalysts and many anthropologists have shifted the problems away from the natural or cosmological toward the sociological and psychological fields. But then the interpretation becomes too easy: if a given mythology confers prominence on a certain figure, let us say an evil grandmother, it will be claimed that in such a society grandmothers are actually evil and that mythology reflects the social structure and the social relations; but should the actual data be conflicting, it would be as readily claimed that the purpose of mythology is to provide an outlet for repressed feelings. Whatever the situation, a clever dialectic will always find a way to pretend that a meaning has been found.
Mythology confronts the student with a situation which at first sight appears contradictory. On the one hand, it would seem that in the course of a myth anything is likely to happen. There is no logic, no continuity. Any characteristic can be attributed to any subject; every conceivable relation can be found. With myth, everything becomes possible. But on the other hand, this apparent arbitrariness is belied by the astounding similarity between myths collected in widely different regions. Therefore the problem: if the content of a myth is contingent, how are we going to explain the fact that myths throughout the world are so similar?
It is precisely this awareness of a basic antinomy pertaining to the nature of myth that may lead us toward its solution. For the contradiction which we face is very similar to that which in earlier times brought considerable worry to the first philosophers concerned with linguistic problems; linguistics could only begin to evolve as a science after this contradiction had been overcome. Ancient philosophers reasoned about language the way we do about mythology. On the one hand, they did notice that in a given language certain sequences of sounds were associated with definite meanings, and they earnestly aimed at discovering a reason for the linkage between those sounds and that meaning. Their attempt, however, was thwarted from the very beginning by the fact that the same sounds were equallypresent in other languages although the meaning they conveyed was entirely different. The contradiction was surmounted only by the discovery that it is the combination of sounds, not the sounds themselves, which provides the significant data.
To invite the mythologist to compare his precarious situation with that of the linguist in the pre-scientific stage is not enough. As a matter of fact we may thus be led only from one difficulty to another. There is a very good reason why myth cannot simply be treated as language if its specific problems are to be solved; myth is language; to be known, myth has to be told; it is a part of human speech. In order to preserve its specificity we must be able to show that it is both the same things as language. And also something different from it. Here, too, the past experience of linguists may help us. For language itself can be analyzed into things which are at the same time similar and yet different. This is precisely what is expressed in Saussure’s distinction between langue and parole, one being the structural side of language, the other the statistical aspect of it, langue belonging to a reversible time, parole being nonreversible. If those two levels already exist in language, then a third one can conceivably be isolated
What is the fundamental paradox that jars the understanding of mythology?
选项
A、Arbitrary yet logic.
B、Arbitrary and contingent.
C、Arbitrary yet universal.
D、Logic yet illogic.
答案
C
解析
总结题。根据第二段内容“But on the other hand,this apparent arbitrarinessis belied by the astounding similarity between myths collected in widely different regions.Therefore the problem:if the content of a myth is contingent,how are we going to explain the fact that myths throughout the world are so similar?”可知,不同地区之间神话惊人的相似性掩盖了这种显而易见的任意性。因此问题是:如果神话内容是视情况而异的,那我们如何解释这样的事实,即全世界的神话是如此相似?由此推之,神话的任意性是显而易见的,但又无法解释全世界神话相似的现象。所以正确答案是C选项。
转载请注明原文地址:https://kaotiyun.com/show/WxmO777K
0
考博英语
相关试题推荐
Probablyoneofthemostrevolutionaryinnovationsinscienceduringthiscenturywastherecognitionofthedualityofmatter;【
Finally,let’s______acriticalissueinanyhonestexplorationofourattitudestowardsoldpeople,namelythevaluewhichour
AlthoughordinarilyskepticalaboutthepurityofRobinson’smotives,inthisinstanceJenkinsdidnotconsiderRobinson’sgener
Manyinstructorsbelievethataninformal,relaxedclassroomenvironmentis【C1】______tolearningandinnovation.Itisnotuncom
Between1833and1837,thepublishersofa"pennypress"provedthatalow-pricedpaper,editedtointerestordinarypeople,cou
Ihavehadjustaboutenoughofbeingtreatedlikeasecond-classcitizen,simplybecauseIhappentobethatput-uponmemberof
Althoughsolutionstoaproblemareoftenthe.fruitofdirectinvestmentsintargetedresearch,themostrevolutionarysolution
Theweathermanbroadcaststhe______intemperaturetwiceaday.
Everysecond,【56】hectareoftheworld’srainforestisdestroyed.That’sonetotwofootballfields.This【57】rateofdestruct
Everysecond,【56】hectareoftheworld’srainforestisdestroyed.That’sonetotwofootballfields.This【57】rateofdestruct
随机试题
A/新药B/仿制药C/进口药D/国家基本药物E/基本医疗保险用药改变上市药品给药途径的药品注册按
患儿,男,4岁。突发高热,持续不退,神昏谵语,反复抽搐,呕吐,便秘,舌红苔黄,脉弦数。其诊断为
一发热病人,近5天来体温维持在39~41℃,24小时内体温波动相差不超过1℃。查体:腹部玫瑰疹,肝脾肿大。体温急剧上升至39℃或以上,持续数天后又骤然下降至正常水平,高热期与无热期各持续若干天后规律性交替一次,热型是()
使用或生产闪点________的可燃气体的工艺装置及其内部的设备、机械、建筑物的火灾危险性为甲类:闪点________的为乙类:闪点________的为丙类。()
根据《旅行社条例》规定,旅行社每设立一个经营出境旅游业务的分社,应当向其质量保证金账户增存()元。
某县县委组织部、县纪委、县土地管理局、某镇人民政府组成联合调查小组,调查处理某县违法占用土地问题。联合调查小组对张某作出了处理决定,没收其在非法占用的土地上所建的楼房。处理决定是以四单位联合发文的形式作出的,并且加盖了四单位的公章。李某不服,申请复议。本案
AstudypublishedintheInternationalJournalofBusinessAdministrationfoundthatwhatstudentsreadincollegedirectlyeffe
Passage1
WikiSoftwareTheUnitedNations,notoriousforendlessdeliberations,istryingatechnologicalquickfix.ItsGlobalCompa
A、In1959.B、In1896.C、In1867.D、In1872.C
最新回复
(
0
)