首页
外语
计算机
考研
公务员
职业资格
财经
工程
司法
医学
专升本
自考
实用职业技能
登录
外语
How do you teach managers to manage? Henry Mintzberg, a professor of management at McGill University in Montreal, has long held
How do you teach managers to manage? Henry Mintzberg, a professor of management at McGill University in Montreal, has long held
admin
2010-01-10
58
问题
How do you teach managers to manage? Henry Mintzberg, a professor of management at McGill University in Montreal, has long held a contrary view to that proposed by most business schools. In this constantly stimulating book he divides his answer into two parts: first, he argues that the traditional qualification, the Masters of Business Administration (MBA), is the wrong way-he says it "prepares people to manage nothing". Then he expounds what he believes is the right way: an imprecise mix of personal reflection and the sharing of experience.
Mr Mintzberg finds fault with the emphasis that many MBA programs place on frenetic case studies which encourage students to come up with rapid answers based on meagre data. But more than that, he criticizes them for their concentration on dry analysis. Such courses, he says, enable their graduates to "speak convincingly in a group of 40 to 90 people", and make them believe they can leapfrog over experience. That, though, is not the sum total of what is required to manage a complex commercial organization.
Synthesis, not analysis, argues Mr Mintzberg, "is the very essence of management". On several occasions he cites Robert McNamara, once president of the Ford Motor Company and a United States secretary of defense in the 1960s, as the archetypal MBA, a man who thought that even in Vietnam "generic analysis could substitute for situational knowledge". More recently, the qualification has been thrown into deeper disrepute by the heavy dependence of companies such as Enron on MBA recruits. Its former chief executive Jeffrey Skilling, currently awaiting trial on 36 charges of fraud and insider trading, liked to boast that he came in the top 5% of his MBA class at the Harvard Business School.
And yet, if the MBA is so bad at teaching management, how come America has far more successful businesses than Europe and Japan, areas of the world that are significantly less enthusiastic about such methods of learning? Leaving aside the unprovable rejoinder that American firms would have done even better without the MBA, Mr Mintzberg argues that any list of America’s most admired corporate leaders is heavily loaded with people who don’t have the qualification: Bill Gates, Warren Buffett, Jack Welch, Michael Dell and Andy Grove, to name but a few. The fact that some 40% of the bosses of America’s biggest companies today have an MBA is, he claims, largely due to the fact that the system is self-perpetuating. "Enabling Harvard to place so many people at the top is the fact that Harvard already has so many people at the top."
Mr Mintzberg is not alone these days in questioning the value of the traditional MBA. Leading consultants such as McKinsey and Mercer are spreading their recruitment net much more widely. Mercer’s London office says that one year’s in-house training enables young graduates to "run circles round newly minted MBAs". In its February issue, the Harvard Business Review (no less) said that "an arts degree is now perhaps the hottest credential in the world of business", with corporate recruiters trawling places such as the Rhode Island School of Design.
"Managers not MBAs" throws a stone into the often complacent world of management education. It should be required reading for anyone who has the qualification, wants one, or just wonders what all the fuss is about.
Why does Mr. Mintzberg think that MBA course "prepare people to manage nothing"?
选项
A、Because it doesn’t teach any knowledge at all.
B、Because it only teaches with some case studies.
C、Because it doesn’t emphasize on synthesis.
D、Because it doesn’t teach students how to manage a real company.
答案
C
解析
转载请注明原文地址:https://kaotiyun.com/show/XWKd777K
本试题收录于:
BEC高级阅读题库BEC商务英语分类
0
BEC高级阅读
BEC商务英语
相关试题推荐
Whatkindofcompanydoesthespeakerworkfor?
Whatkindofcompanydoesthespeakerworkfor?
A、 B、 C、 B题干问的是“汤姆在哪个部门工作?”所以挑选出带有部门名称的答案即可。正确答案是提到销售部的(B)。(A)是用与department发音相似的apartment诱导错误答案的选项,而(C)则是完全不相干
Whichdepartmentdoesthespeakerspecificallythank?
1.(Thecandidatechoosesonetopicandspeaksaboutitforoneminute.)A.StaffManagement:howtoachieveandmaintainhighm
Strong语气生硬
•Youwillhearaninterviewwiththemanagerofacorporatetravelagency.•Foreachquestion23-30,markoneletter(A,Bor
A.beingontimeforanyinterviewB.beingnicetoeveryoneyoutalktoC.beinghonestintheinterviewD.become
PROBLEMSFACINGPOTENTIALEXPORTERS1Inordertobesuccessful,afirmmustclearly______,objectivesandpotentialproble
随机试题
简述胸腺的形态和位置。
关于基金监管原则,以下说法正确的是()。
现有甲、乙两个互斥方案,其规模相同或基本相同,如果其中一个方案的()时,则该方案是最理想的方案。
目前,在项目评估的固定资产折旧计算中,我国企业运用的是综合折旧法。()
综合实践活动的课时必须集中使用,这样有利于提高学生学习效率。()
截至2011年年底某市常住人口1100万人,其中本地人口800万人,外来人口300万人。常住人口的男、女比例为1.03:1。该市高校众多,教育水平远高于全国平均水平。“常住人口中具有大学本科及以上学历的超过20%。根据以上陈述,一定可以推出的是:
①建设文明单位,首先要_______文明单位的量化指标,再按指标对单位进行考评。②培养公民的法制观念是一个长期过程,_______从学生时代就进行法制教育_______起到潜移默化的作用。填入画横线部分最恰当的一项是()。
稷下学宫
张林是奇美公司的总经理,潘洪是奇美公司的财务主管。奇美公司每年生产的紫水晶占全世界紫水晶产品的2%。潘洪希望公司通过增加产量使公司利润增加。张林认为:增加产量将会导致全球紫水晶价格下降,反而会导致利润减少。以下哪项最为恰当地指出了张林的逻辑推断中的漏洞?
不正当竞争违反的原则是(20)。《中华人民共和国反不正当竞争法》中商业秘密的法律条件是(21)、价值性和保密性。
最新回复
(
0
)