首页
外语
计算机
考研
公务员
职业资格
财经
工程
司法
医学
专升本
自考
实用职业技能
登录
外语
Why should anyone buy the latest volume in the ever-expanding Dictionary of National Biography? I do not mean that it is bad, as
Why should anyone buy the latest volume in the ever-expanding Dictionary of National Biography? I do not mean that it is bad, as
admin
2013-01-10
51
问题
Why should anyone buy the latest volume in the ever-expanding Dictionary of National Biography? I do not mean that it is bad, as the reviewers will agree. But it will cost you 65 pounds. And have you got the rest of volumes? You need the basic 22 plus the largely decennial supplements to bring the total to 31. Of course, it will be answered, public and academic libraries will want the new volume. After all, it adds 1,068 lives of people who escaped the net of the original compilers. Yet in 10 years’ time a revised version of the whole caboodle, called the New Dictionary of National Biography, will be published. Its editor, Professor Colin Matthew, tells me that he will have room for about 50,000 lives, some 13,000 more than in the current DNB. This rather puts the 1,068 in Missing Persons in the shade.
When Dr Nicholls wrote to The Spectator in 1989 asking for names of people whom readers had looked up in the DNB and had been disappointed not to find, she says that she received some 100,000 suggestions. (Well, she had written to "other quality newspapers" too.) As soon as her committee had whittled the numbers down, the professional problems of an editor began. Contributors didn’t file copy on time; some who did sent too much: 50,000 words instead of 500 is a record, according to Dr Nicholls.
There remains the dinner-party game of who’s in, who’s out. That is a game that the reviewers have played and will continue to play. Criminals were my initial worry. After all, the original edition of the DNB boasted: Malefactors whose crimes excite a permanent interest have received hardly less attention than benefactors. Mr. John Gross clearly had similar anxieties, for he complains that, while the murderer Christie is in, Crippen is out. One might say in reply that the injustice of the hanging of Evans instead of Christie was a force in the repeal of capital punishment in Britain, as Ludovie Kennedy (the author of Christie’s entry in Missing Persons) notes. But then Crippen was reputed as the first murderer to be caught by telegraphy (he had tried to escape by ship to America).
It is surprising to find Max Miller excluded when really not very memorable names get in. There has been a conscious effort to put in artists and architects from the Middle Ages. About their lives not much is always known.
Of Hugo of Bury St. Edmunds, a 12th-century illuminator whose date of birth and death are not recorded, his biographer comments: "Whether or not Hugo was a wall-painter, the records of his activities as carver and manuscript painter attest to his versatility". Then there had to be more women, too (12 percent, against the original DBN’s 3), such as Roy Strong’s subject, the Tudor painter Levina Teerlinc, of whom he remarks: "Her most characteristic feature is a head attached to a too small, spindly body. Her technique remained awkward, thin and often cursory." It doesn’t seem to qualify her as a memorable artist. Yet it may be better than the record of the original DNB, which included lives of people who never existed (such as Merlin) and even managed to give thanks to J. W. Clerke as a contributor, though, as a later edition admits in a shamefaced footnote, "except for the entry in the List of Contributors there is no trace of J. W. Clerke."
On the issue of who should be included in the DNB, the writer seems to suggest that ______.
选项
A、the editors had clear rules to follow.
B、there was too many criminals in the entries.
C、the editors clearly favored benefactors.
D、the editors were irrational in their choices
答案
D
解析
第三段指出:“There remain the dinner party game of who’s in, who’s out.”由此可以看出本文作者认为编者在选择对象时只是一场游戏,同时又举了一些例子说明此书存在的严重问题和错误以证明编者不谨慎的态度,因此选D。
转载请注明原文地址:https://kaotiyun.com/show/YpTO777K
0
研究生英语学位课统考(GET)
相关试题推荐
Upuntilthattime,hisinteresthadfocusedalmost______onfullymasteringtheskillsandtechniquesofhiscraft.(2015年北京航空航天大
Wehadamarvelousholiday.Onlythelasttwodayswereslightly______byweather.(2003年中国人民大学考博试题)
Historically,humansgetseriousaboutavoidingdisastersonlyafteronehasjuststruckthem.【C1】______thatlogic,2006should
科技进步是社会发展的重要标尺。1851年,英国举办第一届世博会,就是因为它是世界上最先开展工业革命的国家,并产生了很多科技产品。工业革命后带来的生产力发展令人震撼,在不到100年的时间中,人类社会所创造的生产力比过去一切时代创造的全部生产力还要多、还要大。
IhaveavegetablegardenandeverysummerIenjoyeatingmyownvegetables.OnedaylastsummerIpickedadozencarrots.Usual
TheorganizationknowntotheworldasInterpolhassometimesbeendescribedasanoutfitofchisel-jawedgimlet-eyedcrimefigh
In1896aGeorgiacouplesuingfordamagesintheaccidentaldeathoftheirtwoyearoldwastoldthatsincethechildhadmade
Thereareincreasinglyfraughtrelationshipsthatadultsarehavingwithchildren—inallwalksoflife,fromthepoliceandpoli
Femaleapplicantstopostdoctoralpositionsingeosciencewerenearlyhalfaslikelytoreceiveexcellentlettersofrecommendat
Ifyouwanttodowellontheexam,you______onthedirectionsthattheprofessorgivesandtakeexactnotes.(中国人民大学2008年试题)
随机试题
关于结核性腹膜炎哪条是错误的()。
与急性胰腺炎时代谢变化不符的结果是
男,25岁,左下颌磨牙区肿痛5个月,一个月前拔智牙后拔牙窝不愈,检查:张口度3cm,左下颌磨牙区及下颌支略膨隆,牙槽窝有绿色液体流出,X线片示左下颌体部及下颌升支囊性透射影,有骨白线包绕,最应考虑的诊断为()
工程招标代理机构资格分为()个级别。
阅读下面材料,回答问题。海洋是未来的粮仓①人口剧增,资源短缺,这是当今人类面临的最严重的环境问题之一。显然,能否妥善地解决这一问题,直接关系到人类未来的生死存亡。②资源短缺的表现之一,是可耕土地资源不足,粮食生产的增长赶不上人口的增长。正是出于这样的
张老师走进教室后,发现地上有一些碎纸片。“是哪个同学撕的废纸?”老师一问,同学们的目光不约而同地集中在陈伟的身上。“老师,是陈伟撕的。”“不是我!”教室里一下子热闹起来,你一言,我一语,吵得不可开交。张老师看在眼里,什么都明白了。这时张老师完全可以
给定资料1.2017年中央一号文件是21世纪以来指导“三农”工作的第14个中央一号文件。这份题为《中共中央国务院关于深入推进农业供给侧结构性改革加快培育农业农村发展新动能的若干意见》的文件,首次提出“田园综合体”概念,指出“支持有条件的乡村建设以农
某数的50%比它的2/3少1,这个数是( )
汉武帝时派张骞出使西域,想联络(),夹击匈奴。
设有表示学生选课的三张表,学生S(学号,姓名,性别,年龄,身份证号),课程C(课号,课名),选课SC(学号,课号,成绩),则表SC的关键字(键或码)为()。
最新回复
(
0
)