首页
外语
计算机
考研
公务员
职业资格
财经
工程
司法
医学
专升本
自考
实用职业技能
登录
外语
Historian E. H Carr’s thesis that all debates concerning the explanation of historical phenomena revolve around “the question of
Historian E. H Carr’s thesis that all debates concerning the explanation of historical phenomena revolve around “the question of
admin
2020-03-28
118
问题
Historian E. H Carr’s thesis that all debates concerning the explanation of historical phenomena revolve around “the question of the priority of causes” is so familiar to historians as to constitute orthodoxy within their profession. The “true historian”, as Carr puts it, will feel a professional obligation to place the multiple causes of a historical event in a hierarchy by means of which the primary or ultimate cause of the event can be identified. In the Marxist mode of historical explanation (historical materialism), a universal hierarchy of causes is posited in which economic factors are always primary. In the classic, more widely accepted alternative ultimately derived from Weberian sociology, hierarchies of causes are treated as historically specific: explanatory primacy in any particular historical situation must be established by empirical investigation of that situation, not by applying a universal model of historical causation.
While the need to rank historical causes in some order of importance may seem obvious to most historians, such hierarchies raise serious philosophical difficulties. If any historical event is the product of a number of factors, then each of these factors is indispensable to the occurrence of the event. But how can one cause be “more indispensable” than another? And if it cannot, how can there be a hierarchy of indispensable causes? It was this problem that first led Weber himself to argue for the impossibility of any general formula specifying the relative importance of causes; we cannot, for example, conclude that in every capitalist society religious change has been more significant than economic change (or vice versa) in explaining the rise of capitalism.
Runciman offers a different argument leading to the same conclusion. He points out that it is possible to identify specific factors as the primary causes of a particular historical event only relative to an initial set of background conditions. For instance, if we accept English defeats after 1369 in the Hundred Years War as a given, then we may identify the high levels of taxation necessitated by these military reverses as the “main” cause of the Peasants Revolt of 1381. If instead we regard the financing of warfare by taxation in this period as a background condition, then we will see the English reverses themselves as the main cause of the revolt. However, neither ordinary life nor historical practice offer reliable criteria by which to distinguish causes from background conditions and thus to resolve historical debates about the relative importance of causes. And this difficulty casts doubt not only on the Marxist effort to identify a universal hierarchy of causes, but also on any attempt to identify an objective hierarchy of causes—even of the historically specific kind favored by non-Marxists.
In the second paragraph of the passage, the author uses the concept of an indispensable cause primarily in order to question which of the following claims?
选项
A、Generalizations about the origins of capitalist societies are defensible.
B、The study of history is largely independent of philosophical concerns.
C、A universal model of historical causation is indefensible.
D、A historical event is caused by many factors.
E、A hierarchy of the causes of a historical event can be determined.
答案
E
解析
根据indispensable cause可知,其功能在于说明不能排序,但要注意本题问的是indispensable cause用于“质疑”什么,所以答案要找“可以排序”,选项E正确。C项袁述相反。D项这并不是被质疑的。
转载请注明原文地址:https://kaotiyun.com/show/ZmVO777K
本试题收录于:
GRE VERBAL题库GRE分类
0
GRE VERBAL
GRE
相关试题推荐
Thequestionsinthisgrouparebasedonthecontentofapassage.Afterreadingthepassage,choosethebestanswertoeachque
Thequestionsinthisgrouparebasedonthecontentofapassage.Afterreadingthepassage,choosethebestanswertoeachque
Althoughmanypeoplewouldnotbelieveit,themosquitoisactuallythemostdangerousanimalinAfrica.Whilethebiteoftheb
MosteconomistsintheUnitedStatesseemcaptivatedbythespellofthefreemarket.Consequently,nothingseemsgoodornormal
Althoughgeneticmutationsinbacteriaandvirusescanleadtoepidemics,someepidemicsarecausedbybacteriaandvirusesthat
MilankovitchproposedintheearlytwentiethcenturythattheiceageswerecausedbyvariationsintheEarth’sorbitaroundthe
Caterpillarsoffallspeciesproduceanidenticalhormonecalled"juvenilehormone"thatmaintainsfeedingbehavior.Onlywhena
GrazinglivestockonpubliclandinthewesternUnitedStatesisnotcausingwidespreadenvironmentaldamageintheregion,sinc
Hereisanewideainagriculturalweedcontrol.Ratherthantryingtoformulateherbicidesthatkillspecificweedsbutarehar
ComparingtheQuechanswithotherNativeAmericansoftheSouthwest,theQuechansweresingularlyuninterestedintheaccumulati
随机试题
业主与物业管理企业间的物业管理关系基于()
关于腕部骨化中心,下列那一项是错误的
病人李某,腹膜炎术后采取半坐卧位的目的是
案情:陈某见熟人赵某做生意赚了不少钱便产生歹意,勾结高某,谎称赵某欠自己10万元货款未还,请高某协助索要,并承诺要回款项后给高某1万元作为酬谢。高某同意。某日,陈某和高某以谈生意为名把赵某诱骗到稻香楼宾馆某房间,共同将赵某扣押,并由高某对赵某进行看管。次日
如果个人委托代理人对个人信用报告提出异议申请,代理人须提供()。
下列情形中,需办理注销税务登记的有()。
教育目的的性质和方向是由()决定的。
(1)资料失真(2)经济普查(3)经济损失(4)经济出现新增长(5)数据更新
①建立一些新的交通网和新的管理制度,都是为了要把若干互相冲突的地区,重新放在一个系统之内②朝代刚兴盛的时候,新秩序产生,各个地区可以重新调节,彼此形成互补的关系③自古以来有一句话:分久必合,合久必分。朝代由盛转衰是一定的,开国时多是兴盛太平,结束时必是
NinetypercentofAmericansknowthatmostoftheircompatriotsareoverweight,butjust40percentbelievethemselvestobetoo
最新回复
(
0
)