首页
外语
计算机
考研
公务员
职业资格
财经
工程
司法
医学
专升本
自考
实用职业技能
登录
考研
If you lock a bunch of high-IQ people in a room and tell them to get on with a task, what will they e-merge with? Lower IQs, for
If you lock a bunch of high-IQ people in a room and tell them to get on with a task, what will they e-merge with? Lower IQs, for
admin
2014-06-25
37
问题
If you lock a bunch of high-IQ people in a room and tell them to get on with a task, what will they e-merge with? Lower IQs, for one thing. A study done by Virginia Tech tried to replicate how people think under social pressure. Subjects with an average IQ of 126 were clustered into problem-solving groups and exposed to judgments about their work. A pecking order formed. The low performers showed high responses in the part of the brain that regulates fear. The scientists concluded that "individuals express diminished cognitive capacity in groups, an effect that is worsened by perceived lower status".
This is the first ill word any scientist has had for the way groups think in a very long time. Over the past decade or two, story after story has spoken glowingly of "hive mind" and the "wisdom of crowds". Are these profound new insights or are they a cognitive-science trend on which the tide is now receding?
They are both. There is certainly something measurable that can be called collective intelligence. A fascinating study of its operation was published in the magazine Science two years ago. They asked small groups to do a variety of mental tests and then play a game of draughts. A collective equivalent of general intelligence is just what they found. Moreover, it was not just an artefact of the individual intelligences that made up the groups. The correlation of group thinking with the average intelligence of the group, or with the intelligence of the group’s smartest member, was weak. Strong correlations were with the "average social sensitivity of group members and the equality in distribution of conversation turn-taking". Office bullies and those who can’t shut up drive down productivity.
These two findings—that there is such a thing as collective intelligence and that working in groups makes individuals a bit duller are not necessarily contradictory. A human being probably loses a bit of thinking capacity in subordinating himself to a group, no matter what feats the collective is able to carry out. Whether this trade-off is worthwhile depends on what the groups are doing. If western culture as it existed until two decades ago stood for any one thing, it was the defence of the individual against the herd. Individuals produced King Lear and the Discourse on the Method. The "wisdom of crowds" produces a few retail fads at best, book-burnings and pogroms at worst.
Our own time thinks itself different. It is marked by integration of markets and innovations in networking and sales. Crowd-sourced Wikipedia(flawed, quick and free)helped drive Britannica(authoritative, labour-intensive and dear)out of the paper encyclopedia business. No one has the time to read King Lear, let alone write it. Anybody who can spark a retail fad is acclaimed a genius. The wisdom of crowds: in fact, may be just an updated version of the age-old wisdom of retail; when it comes to what the crowd wants, the crowd is all-knowing.
The two findings introduced in paragraphs 1 and 3 can be used to justify the statement that.
选项
A、every coin has two sides
B、everything is evolutionary
C、scientific findings might be contradictory
D、science is culturally defined
答案
A
解析
第一段研究说明:当成组工作时,个体的认知能力会下降。第三段的研究说明:群体智慧高于个人。第四段作者对两项研究发现做出评价:“群体智慧确实存在”和“群体工作会让个体变笨”并不矛盾,我们可以根据所面对任务的性质在二者之间进行折中。可见,[A]选项是对两者关系的正确阐释。
转载请注明原文地址:https://kaotiyun.com/show/aUK4777K
0
考研英语一
相关试题推荐
Untilthelate1940swhentelevisionbeganfindingitswayintoAmericanhomes,companiesreliedmainlyonprintandradiotopr
HowdoyougettoCarnegieHall?Practice.Inagroundbreakingpaperpublishedin1993,cognitivepsychologistAndersEricssona
Lookaroundtheworldandtheforcesaremassing.OnonesideareCalifornianprisonguards,Britishpolicemen,Frenchrailworke
Writeanessayof160~200wordsbasedonthefollowingdrawing.Inyouressay,youshould1)describethedrawing,2)interpre
ItwasreportedrecentlythatonewomanfollowedactorAndyLauaroundfortenyears.Whatisyouropinionofthosewhoblindly
Therehasbeenadiscussionrecentlyontheissueoftraditioninanewspaper.Writeanessayofabout200wordstothenewspape
"Innovation"diedin2008,killedoffbyoveruse,misuse,narrowness,incrementalismandfailuretoevolve.ItwasdoneinbyCE
Youaregoingtoreadatextaboutbeingabetterfriend,followedbyalistofimportantways.Choosethebestwayfromthelis
Whichofthefollowingwouldbethebesttitleforthetext?Wecanlearnfromthetextthatartcriticshaveahistoryof____
Thegreatchariotofsociety,whichforsolonghadrundownthegentleslopeoftradition,nowfounditselfpoweredbyaninter
随机试题
瞒天过海2001年7月17凌晨3时许,南丹龙泉矿冶总厂拉甲坡矿发生特大透水事故,致使在井下作业的81名矿工遇难。事故发生14小时后,龙泉矿冶总经理黎某才第一次把事故情况报告给当时分管南丹矿业的县委副书记,并请求县里不要上报,由龙泉公司自己处理。7月18日
A.腹痛突然发生或加重,呈持续性剧痛B.起病缓慢,腹痛由轻至重,呈持续性C.腹痛轻,呈持续性D.起病急,呈持续性阵发性加重E.发病急,呈阵发性腹部绞痛绞窄性急腹症腹痛的特点是
β-CD可以应用于
某建筑场地抗震设防烈度为8度,设计基本地震加速度为0.30g,设计地震分组为第二组,场地类别为Ⅲ类,建筑物结构白振周期T=1.65s,结构阻尼比ξ取0。05,当进行多遇地震作用下的截面抗震验算时,相应于结构自振周期的水平地震影响系数值最接近( )。
依据《关于预防煤矿生产安全事故的别规定》,煤矿若存在下列情形,有关执法部门应当提请政府对其予以关闭的有()。
希克斯和尼汉斯认为金融创新的支配因素是()。
失独家庭可领养子女,民政局要统计各区县人数。想要做一个调查。让你组织,你怎么做?
[*]
Bilingualeducationinschoolshaslongbeenapoliticalhotpotato—itwasbannedinCaliforniabya1998ballotmeasure,which
今天中国幼儿园里的大多数孩子都是独生子女。他们机灵、好学、想象力丰富、精力充沛,但往往以自我为中心,不守纪律,而且比较脆弱。一般来说,刚进幼儿园的4至6岁的孩子都是以自我为中心的,但9至10岁的孩子则表现出有自制力、不怕挫折的优点。因此我们的教育强调集体主
最新回复
(
0
)