首页
外语
计算机
考研
公务员
职业资格
财经
工程
司法
医学
专升本
自考
实用职业技能
登录
外语
EATS,SHOOTS AND LEAVES —a book review The title of Eats, Shoots and Leaves refers to a famously misp
EATS,SHOOTS AND LEAVES —a book review The title of Eats, Shoots and Leaves refers to a famously misp
admin
2012-01-16
82
问题
EATS,SHOOTS AND LEAVES
—a book review
The title of Eats, Shoots and Leaves refers to a famously misplaced comma in a wildlife manual that ended up suggesting a panda rather violently "eats, shoots and leaves" instead of eating shoots and leaves. The author of this book, journalist Lynne Truss, is something akin to a militant linguist, dedicating this "zero tolerance" manifesto on grammar to the striking Bolshevik printers of St. Petersburg who, in demanding the same remuneration for punctuation as they received for letters, ended up setting in motion the first Russian Revolution.
Some of the book involves humorous attacks on erroneous punctuation. There is the confused Shakespearian thespian who inadvertently turns a frantic plea: "Go, get him surgeons!" into the cheerful encouragement of "Go get him, surgeons!" Street and shop signs have a ubiquitous presence. A bakery declares "FRESH DONUT’S SOLD HERE" and a florist curiously announces that "Pansy’s here!" (Is she?). The shameless title of a Hollywood film Two Weeks Notice is reeled in for criticism—"Would they similarly call it One Weeks Notice?", Truss enquires--and sometimes, as in the case of signs promoting "ANTIQUE’S" and "Potato’s"—one questions whether we are bearing witness to new depths of grammar ignorance, or a postmodern caricature of atrocious punctuation.
Eats, Shoots and leaves is not just a piece of comedy and ridicule, however, and Truss has plenty to offer on the question of proper grammar usage. If you have ever wondered whether it is acceptable to simply use an "elm dash” I in place of a comma—the verdict from Truss is that you can. "The dash is less formal than the semicolon, which makes it more attractive, " she suggests. "lt enhances conversational tone; and...it is capable of quite subtle effects." The author concludes, with characteristic wry condescension, that the elm dash’s popularity largely rests on people knowing it is almost impossible to use incorrectly. Truss is a personal champion of the semicolon, a historically contentious punctuation mark elsewhere maligned by novelist Kurt Vonnegut Jr., as a "transvestite hermaphrodite representing absolutely nothing". Coming to the semicolon’s defense, Truss suggests that, while it can certainly be over-used—she refers to the dying words of one 20th century writer: "I should have used fewer semicolons"—the semicolon can perform the role of a "a kind of Special Policeman in the event of comma fights".
Truss has come under criticism on two broad points. The first argument criticizes the legitimacy of her authority as a punctuation autocrat. Louis Men and, writing in the New Yorker, details Eats, Shoots and Leaves’ numerous grammatical and punctuation sins: a comma-free non-restrictive clause; a superfluous ellipsis; a misplaced apostrophe; a misused parenthesis; two misused semicolons; an erroneous hyphen in the word "abuzz", and so on. In fact, as Men and notes, half the semicolons in the Truss book are spuriously deployed because they stem from the author’s open flouting of the rule that semicolons must only connect two independent clauses. "Why would a person not just vague about the rules but disinclined to follow them bother to produce a guide to punctuation.’?" Men and inquires. Ultimately, he holds Truss accused of producing a book that pleases those who "just need to vent" and concludes that Eats, Shoots and Leaves is actually a tirade against the decline of language and print that disguises itself, thinly and poorly, as some kind of a style manual.
Linguist David Crystal has criticized what he describes as a "linguistic purism" coursing through Truss’ book. Linguistic purism is the notion that one variety of language is somehow more pure than others, with this sense of purity often based on an idealized historical point in the language’s development, but sometimes simply in reference to an abstract ideal. In The Fight for English. How Language Pundits Ate, Shot and Left, Crystal--a former colleague of Truss--condemns the no-holds-barred approach to punctuation and grammar. "Zero tolerance does not allow for flexibility," he argues. "It is prescriptivism taken to extremes. It suggests that language is in a state where all the rules are established with 100 per cent certainty. The suggestion is false. We do not know what all the rules of punctuation are. And no rule of punctuation is followed by all of the people all of the time."
Other detractors of Truss’ "prescriptivism" are careful to disassociate needless purism from robust and sensible criticism, an oppositional stance they call descriptivism. "Don’t ever imagine," Geoffrey K. Plum on the Language Log emphasizes, "that I think all honest attempts at using English are just as good as any others. [ Bad ~ writing needs to be fixed. But let’s make sure we fix the right things." In other words, we do not require a dogmatic approach to clean up misused language. Charles Gaulle concurs, noting that his opposition to "prescriptivism" does not require contending with the existence of standards themselves, but questioning whether our standards should determine what works, or whether what works should determine our standards.
Ultimately, it is unlikely the purists and pedagogues will ever make absolute peace with those who see language as a fluid, creative process within which everyone has a role to play. Both sides can learn to live in a sort of contentious harmony, however. Creativity typically involves extending, adapting and critiquing the status quo, and revising and reviving old traditions while constructing new ones. Rules must exist in order for this process to take place, if only for them to be broken. On the flip side, rules have an important role to play in guiding our language into forms that can be accessed by people across all manner of differences, so it is vital to acknowledge the extent to which they can be democratic, rather than merely autocratic in function. Nevertheless, all the regulations in the world cannot stem the natural spring of language, which bursts through rivets and snakes around the dams that linguistic authorities may try to put in place. We should celebrate rather than curse these inevitable tensions.
Questions 27-32
Look at the following statements (Questions 27-32) and the list of people below. Match each statement with the correct person, A-E.
Write the correct letter, A-E, in boxes 27-32 on your answer sheet.
NB You may use any letter more than once.
List of People
A.Kurt Vonnegut Jr.
B.Louis Men and
C.David Crystal
D.Geoffrey K. Plum
E.Charles Gaulle
We can ask whether rules are helpful without undermining the need for rules.
选项
答案
E
解析
转载请注明原文地址:https://kaotiyun.com/show/boNO777K
本试题收录于:
雅思阅读题库雅思(IELTS)分类
0
雅思阅读
雅思(IELTS)
相关试题推荐
Anintegerfrom10through99,inclusive,istobechosenatrandom.Whatistheprobabilitythatthenumberchosenwillhave0
AInthisquestionyouareaskedtocomparetheareaofrectangleAandtheareaofrectangleB.Sincetheinformationgivenrela
Inthexy-plane,lineA;isalinethatdoesnotpassthroughtheorigin.Whichofthefollowingstatementsindividuallyprovide
Inaboxof10electricalparts,2aredefective.(a)Ifyouchooseonepartatrandomfromthebox,whatistheprobabilitythat
A、Althoughthefutureofopticalcomputingisimpressive,itsapplicationsaretoolimitedinscopetojustifymuchoptimism.B、
A、Thesecondparagraphreliesondifferentevidenceindrawingaconclusionsimilartothatexpressedinthefirstparagraph.B、
Areresponsestoodorsacquiredasafunctionoftheemotionalcontextinwhichtheyareinitiallyperceived?Researchers
Wefelt______oncethecommitteeissueditsreportthatauthenticatedouractions.
Althoughcondemnedbythereviewpanel,tofilmcriticPaulineKaelthemovieseemedentirely______andunlikelytooffend.
GwendolynBrookswas______writer:shewrotemorethantwentybooksofpoetryaswellasnumerousessaysandreviews.
随机试题
患者,女性,45岁。胸部撕裂样痛3小时伴晕厥1次入院,既往有高血压病史,未服降压药物。查体:血压180/130mmHg,脉搏75次/分,呼吸稍促,气管居中,双肺呼吸音正常对称,心界不大,心音有力,主动脉瓣区可闻及舒张期杂音。心电图示胸前导联ST一T改变。
以下除哪项外均属五苓散的主治病症
钢材的冲击韧性是钢材在冲击荷载作用下断裂时吸收能量的能力。()
根据《城市给水工程规划规范》,城市有地形可供利用时,宜采用()系统。
用强制确定法进行0-1功能打分时,重要功能得分为( )分。
下列有关固定资产会计处理的表述中,正确的有()。
在国际多式联运中,陆桥运输起着重要的作用。严格地讲,陆桥运输也是一种海陆联运形式。()
著名的瑞士心理学家皮亚杰认为儿童认知发展的形式运算阶段是在()。
下列关于OSPF协议分区的描述中,错误的是______。
下列两个二进制数进行算术运算,11101+10011=______。
最新回复
(
0
)