首页
外语
计算机
考研
公务员
职业资格
财经
工程
司法
医学
专升本
自考
实用职业技能
登录
外语
You should spend about 20 minutes on Questions 27-40, which are based on Reading Passage 3 below. Musical Maladies Norman M. Wei
You should spend about 20 minutes on Questions 27-40, which are based on Reading Passage 3 below. Musical Maladies Norman M. Wei
admin
2018-09-11
20
问题
You should spend about 20 minutes on Questions 27-40, which are based on Reading Passage 3 below.
Musical Maladies
Norman M. Weinberger reviews the latest work of Oliver Sacks on music.
Music and the brain are both endlessly fascinating subjects, and as a neuroscientist specialising in auditory learning and memory, I find them especially intriguing. So I had high expectations of Musicophilia, the latest offering from neurologist and prolific author Oliver Sacks. And I confess to feeling a little guilty reporting that my reactions to the book are mixed.
Sacks himself is the best part of Musicophilia. He richly documents his own life in the book and reveals highly personal experiences. The photograph of him on the cover of the book— which shows him wearing headphones, eyes closed, clearly enchanted as he listens to Alfred Brendel perform Beethoven’s Pathetique Sonata—makes a positive impression that is borne out by the contents of the book. Sacks’s voice throughout is steady and erudite but never pontifical. He is neither self-conscious nor self-promoting. The preface gives a good idea of what the book will deliver. In it Sacks explains that he wants to convey the insights gleaned from the "enormous and rapidly growing body of work on the neural underpinnings of musical perception and imagery, and the complex and often bizarre disorders to which these are prone." He also stresses the importance of "the simple art of observation" and "the richness of the human context." He wants to combine "observation and description with the latest in technology," he says, and to imaginatively enter into the experience of his patients and subjects. The reader can see that Sacks, who has been practicing neurology for 40 years, is torn between the "old-fashioned" path of observation and the newfangled, high-tech approach: He knows that he needs to take heed of the latter, but his heart lies with the former.
The book consists mainly of detailed descriptions of cases, most of them involving patients whom Sacks has seen in his practice. Brief discussions of contemporary neuroscientific reports are sprinkled liberally throughout the text. Part I, "Haunted by Music," begins with the strange case of Tony Cicoria, a nonmusical, middle-aged surgeon who was consumed by a love of music after being hit by lightning. He suddenly began to crave listening to piano music, which he had never cared for in the past. He started to play the piano and then to compose music, which arose spontaneously in his mind in a "torrent" of notes. How could this happen? Was the cause psychological?(He had had a near-death experience when the lightning struck him.)Or was it the direct result of a change in the auditory regions of his cerebral cortex? Electroencephalography(EEG)showed his brain waves to be normal in the mid-1990s, just after his trauma and subsequent "conversion" to music. There are now more sensitive tests, but Cicoria has declined to undergo them; he does not want to delve into the causes of his musicality. What a shame!
Part II, "A Range of Musicality," covers a wider variety of topics, but unfortunately, some of the chapters offer little or nothing that is new. For example, chapter 13, which is five pages long, merely notes that the blind often have better hearing than the sighted. The most interesting chapters are those that present the strangest cases. Chapter 8 is about "amusia," an inability to hear sounds as music, and "dysharmonia," a highly specific impairment of the ability to hear harmony, with the ability to understand melody left intact. Such specific "dissociations" are found throughout the cases Sacks recounts.
To Sacks’s credit, part III, "Memory, Movement and Music," brings us into the underappreciated realm of music therapy. Chapter 16 explains how "melodic intonation therapy" is being used to help expressive aphasic patients(those unable to express their thoughts verbally following a stroke or other cerebral incident)once again become capable of fluent speech. In chapter 20, Sacks demonstrates the near-miraculous power of music to animate Parkinson’s patients and other people with severe movement disorders, even those who are frozen into odd postures. Scientists cannot yet explain how music achieves this effect.
To readers who are unfamiliar with neuroscience and music behavior, Musicophilia may be something of a revelation. But the book will not satisfy those seeking the causes and implications of the phenomena Sacks describes. For one thing, Sacks appears to be more at ease discussing patients than discussing experiments. And he tends to be rather uncritical in accepting scientific findings and theories.
It’s true that the causes of music-brain oddities remain poorly understood. However, Sacks could have done more to draw out some of the implications of the careful observations that he and other neurologists have made and of the treatments that have been successful. For example, he might have noted that the many specific dissociations among components of music comprehension, such as loss of the ability to perceive harmony but not melody, indicate that there is no music center in the brain. Because many people who read the book are likely to believe in the brain localisation of all mental functions, this was a missed educational opportunity.
Another conclusion one could draw is that there seem to be no "cures" for neurological problems involving music. A drug can alleviate a symptom in one patient and aggravate it in another, or can have both positive and negative effects in the same patient. Treatments mentioned seem to be almost exclusively antiepileptic medications, which "damp down" the excitability of the brain in general; their effectiveness varies widely.
Finally, in many of the cases described here the patient with music-brain symptoms is reported to have "normal" EEG results. Although Sacks recognises the existence of new technologies, among them far more sensitive ways to analyze brain waves than the standard neurological EEG test, he does not call for their use. In fact, although he exhibits the greatest compassion for patients, he conveys no sense of urgency about the pursuit of new avenues in the diagnosis and treatment of music-brain disorders. This absence echoes the book’s preface, in which Sacks expresses fear that "the simple art of observation may be lost" if we rely too much on new technologies. He does call for both approaches, though, and we can only hope that the neurological community will respond.
Questions 27-30
Choose the correct letter, A, B, C or D.
Write the correct letter in boxes 27-30 on your answer sheet.
What is the best part of the book?
选项
A、the photo of Sacks listening to music
B、the tone of voice of the book
C、the autobiographical description in the book
D、the description of Sacks’s wealth
答案
C
解析
利用细节信息“best part of the book”和顺序原则定位于原文第二段第一句话“Sackshimself is the best part of Musicophilia”,第二句话接着讲述“He richly documents hisown life in the book and reveals highly personal experiences”,也就是说作者认为该书最好的部分在于Sacks对自己的经历的描述,对应选项C“the autobiographical description in the book”。选项A“the photo of Sacks listening to music”,虽然原文也有提及,但这只是此书最好的部分的一个表现,或者按照作者的原话“a positive impressionthat is borne out by the contents of the book”,即一个由书籍内容所支持的留给读者的正面印象,而非最好的部分,所以应该排除。虽然原文第二段最后也提及本书写作的语气“steady and erudite but never pontifical…neither self-conscious nor self-promoting”,表示肯定,但是这也并非此书最好的部分,所以排除。选项D“the descriptionof Sacks’s wealth”完全和原文不相关,原文的“richly documents…”指的根本不是财富,所以也被排除。综上所述,正确答案为选项C。
转载请注明原文地址:https://kaotiyun.com/show/cpNO777K
本试题收录于:
雅思阅读题库雅思(IELTS)分类
0
雅思阅读
雅思(IELTS)
相关试题推荐
His______oftheassignedpageswasitselfamuchtoolengthysummary;byallaccounts,ifhewishestosucceedbythestandards
Directions:Eachofthefollowingreadingcomprehensionquestionsisbasedonthecontentofthefollowingpassage.Readthepas
Directions:Eachofthefollowingreadingcomprehensionquestionsisbasedonthecontentofthefollowingpassage.Readthepas
ThispassageisadaptedfromTheAmericanRepublic:Constitution,Tendencies,andDestinybyO.A.Brownson,1866.Thean
ThispassageisadaptedfromTheAmericanRepublic:Constitution,Tendencies,andDestinybyO.A.Brownson,1866.Thean
ThispassageisadaptedfromTheAmericanRepublic:Constitution,Tendencies,andDestinybyO.A.Brownson,1866.Thean
ThispassageisadaptedfromTheAmericanRepublic:Constitution,Tendencies,andDestinybyO.A.Brownson,1866.Thean
Thispassageisadaptedfrommaterialpublishedin2001.FrederickDouglasswasunquestionablythemostfamousAfricanAmerican
随机试题
新斯的明与毒扁豆碱均能抑制胆碱酯酶,故均用于治疗重症肌无力。()
A.艾条灸B.艾炷灸C.温和灸D.温针灸E.天灸白芥子灸属
[2011年第100题]图像中的像素实际上就是图像中的一个个光点,这光点()。
下列焊缝外观检查项目中,不须用焊接检验尺进行检查测量的是()。
期货交易的金字塔式买入卖出方法认为,若建仓后市场行情与预料相同并已使投机者盈利,则可以()。
Toappreciatesomethingmeanstobegratefulorthankfulforit.Whenyouaregrateful,youliterally【C1】________yourselfupto
根据所给资料,回答下列问题。2015年我国车辆和驾驶人保持快速增长,至2015年年底,全国机动车保有量达2.79亿辆,比上年增长11.7%,全国机动车驾驶人数量达3.24亿人,比上年增长8.0%。其中,我国汽车保有量达1.72亿辆,是2003年汽
北大作为中国高等教育体制和水平的代表性学府,遭到舆论的更多______是正常的,也是它必须承受的。但反对极端性指责,要求批评更加______,这是社会对围绕北大争议的应有态度。填入划横线部分最恰当的一项是:
请你就农村金融体制改革谈谈看法。
IsYourChild’sStomachPainAllinHisHead?Weallknowtherearetimesthatkidsseemtocomplain(51)astomachacheto
最新回复
(
0
)