首页
外语
计算机
考研
公务员
职业资格
财经
工程
司法
医学
专升本
自考
实用职业技能
登录
外语
In Plato’s Republic we find a discussion about morality and selfishness. Plato’s brother Glaucon is trying to make Socrates give
In Plato’s Republic we find a discussion about morality and selfishness. Plato’s brother Glaucon is trying to make Socrates give
admin
2016-09-24
43
问题
In Plato’s Republic we find a discussion about morality and selfishness. Plato’s brother Glaucon is trying to make Socrates give some good reasons for why it is better to be just than to be unjust. Glaucon insists that all people by nature look after themselves, and whenever we can get away with something, we will do it, regardless of how unjust it may be to others. Unfortunately, we may receive the same treatment from others, which is highly unpleasant, so for the sake of peace and security we agree to treat each other decently—not because we want to, but because we are playing it safe. Morality is just a result of our looking out for ourselves. If we can get away with something, it is our nature to make the most of it.
What Glaucon is suggesting here about the origin of society is a first in Western thought. His theory is an example of what has become known as social contract theory, and this type of theory became particularly influential much later, in the eighteenth century. A social contract theory assumes that humans used to live in a pre-social setting(without rules, regulations, or cooperation)and then, for various reasons, got together and agreed on setting up a society. Generally, social contract theories assume that humans decide to build a society with rules for the sake of the common good or for the sake of self-protection. The theory is today known as psychological egoism.
To Glaucon, decent persons will do "unjust" things just as quickly as scoundrels if they know they can get away with it since their human natures are identical. Here Glaucon is acting as the devil’s advocate in order to make Socrates defend justice as something that is good in itself. Surely we all can remember events in our lives that show that we don’t always act out of self-interest. We may remember that Mother Teresa and other unselfish souls have spent their lives helping others. The psychological egoist would contend that they may not have been aware of their true motives, but selfish it was, somehow. These people, probably, wanted to get to Heaven, to atone for past wrongdoing, or maybe they just wanted to feel warm inside.
This theory, cynical as it may sound, has established itself firmly in the minds of many modern people. Somehow, this theory removes the halo from above the head of every hero and every unselfish person in the history of humankind. One reason, then, for this theory’s popularity is its presumed honesty. Closely related to the notion of honesty is our modern fascination with cynicism. Oftentimes, people are truly selfish and devious, and things are not what they seem. However, there is a difference between this kind of prudent skepticism and a universal cynicism that borders on paranoia. Such radical cynicism doesn’t allow for the possibility of the existence of goodness and kindness, and this is one of the errors psychological egoists are prone to. Psychological egoists never say that we can’t help being selfish to the bone—they just say that there is some hidden selfish motive for whatever we do that we may not be even aware of.
How would psychological egoists interpret the example of Mother Teresa?
选项
A、She helps others for the sake of herself.
B、Justice is good in itself to the devil’s advocate.
C、Descent persons will do unjust things as well.
D、She is a typical person with feelings of paranoia.
答案
A
解析
心理自我主义者会怎样解释修女特蕾莎的例子?为了自己,她帮助别人。第三段后三句说,我们也许记得修女特蕾莎和其他无私的人终生帮助别人。心理自我主义者会认为,这些人也许没有意识到他们真正的动机。从某种角度讲,其动机便是自私。这些人很可能想上天堂,赎回过去的罪行,或者说,他们也许只是想要内心感到温暖。
转载请注明原文地址:https://kaotiyun.com/show/dPGO777K
0
考博英语
相关试题推荐
Theheadlightsoftheapproachingcarwereso______thatthecyclisthadtostopriding.
AreweatthebeginningofanotherAgeofExploration?Perhapsevenmoreimportant,areweatthebeginningof【C1】______AgeofC
Tofightagainstcomputercrimes,acomputersystemneedsasurewayofidentifyingitsrightusersandrejectingthosewhoare
首先,额外的学习对孩子的身体发育是不利的。教育专家指出,孩子在枯燥的教室里待了一整天之后,参加一些体育活动,而不是额外的学习,是非常重要的。孩子们正处于身体快速发育时期,缺乏体育锻炼可能会对他们的生活造成严重的影响。第二,从心理上讲,大部分孩子似乎对额外学
Foranyonewhohasexperiencedanearthquake,theexperiencecanbefrighteningandtraumatic.Inadditionofthemovementofth
Inmoderndays,onthewesternbankoftheupperTigrisRiverstandsanIraqicitycalledQal’atShartlat.Thousandsofyearsag
Goodwritersareoftenalso______readerswhoenjoyequallyfictionandnonfiction,proseandpoetry,philosophyandscience.
Today,theTowerofLondonisoneofthemostpopulartourist【C1】______andattractsoverthreemillionvisitorsayear.Itw
这次到台湾访问交流,虽然行色匆匆,但是,看了不少地方,访了旧友,交了新知,大家走到一起,谈论的一个重要话题就是中华民族在21世纪的强盛。虽然祖国大陆、台湾的青年生活在不同的社会环境中,有着各自不同的生活经历,但大家的内心都深深铭刻着中华文化优秀传统的印记,
A______examinationforthepostofdepartmentmanagerwillbeheldnextTuesday.
随机试题
设函数f在[a,b]上有定义,且对任给的ε>0,存在[a,b]上的可积函数g,使得|f(x)-g(x)|<ε,x∈[a,b].证明f在[a,b]上可积.
维持身体平衡的不包括
按照“建筑工程一切险”保险合同的规定,保险公司对被保险人的损失不承担赔偿责任的情况包括()。
下列关于单元工程施工质量评定的说法正确的是()。
某食品加工企业(非房地产开发企业)整体出售了其新建的商品房,与商品房相关的取得土地使用权所支付的金额为6000万元,开发成本共计4000万元;该企业不能按转让房地产项目计算分摊银行借款利息;该项目所在省政府规定计征土地增值税时,房地产开发费用扣除比例按10
金融市场的客体是指()。
消费税的纳税环节是()。
下列选项中,属于盈余公积项目核算的有()。
被苏轼赞为“诗中有画,画中有诗”的唐代诗人是()。
无符号二进制整数111111转换成十进制数是()。
最新回复
(
0
)