首页
外语
计算机
考研
公务员
职业资格
财经
工程
司法
医学
专升本
自考
实用职业技能
登录
考研
The right to a trial by jury is a fundamental part of the United States legal system. It is a right firmly rooted in our democra
The right to a trial by jury is a fundamental part of the United States legal system. It is a right firmly rooted in our democra
admin
2013-06-10
74
问题
The right to a trial by jury is a fundamental part of the United States legal system. It is a right firmly rooted in our democratic tradition. The jury system provides a buffer between the complex and often inflexible legal system and the average citizen on trial. The right to be judged by a jury is a right that most Americans feel very strongly about. However, due to recent jury decisions, some critics are questioning the value of this institution.
Our jury system is by no means flawless. It is subject to constant scrutiny and debate concerning its merit and its downfalls. As is true in all institutions, juries are capable of making mistakes. Psychological studies have been done on many aspects of jury behavior. Political scientists are also intrigued by juries and the manner in which they arrive at important decisions. Although most Americans believe in the jury system, there has been considerable controversy surrounding it lately. The public has become even more concerned about this institution recently. The outcomes of the Rodney King, the O.J. Simpson, and the Menendez brothers trials in Los Angeles and the dissatisfaction that followed the jury’s decisions are three examples of instances when the effectiveness of the jury system has come under fierce attack. From the public reaction to these decisions and others like them, it is very clear that the way in which juries reach their decisions is often as important to the American people as it is to the specific person on trial. Many people feel that the average jurist is not equipped to make the kinds of decisions they are faced with. These critics’ suggestions range from restructuring the system up to tally eliminating it.
Most average Americans, I believe, feel that the right to a jury trial is a fundamental one, and its guarantees should be honored. These people would argue that laws are inflexible. They cannot deal with the individual circumstances in each case, but juries can take these into account. Still others believe that juries are favorable because they reflect the morals and values of the community they come from. Indeed, many proponents of the jury support the system because of a particular kind of jury bias, the tendency for jurors, to place justice above the law.
Opponents of the system argue that juries are uneducated in legal procedures and should not be given the type of responsibility they have traditionally had. These people also argue that juries are biased. In fact, the psychological literature provides many examples of this bias. Jurors are less likely to punish a sad or distressed defendant, as opposed to a joyful one, apparently because the defendant is already being punished emotionally. Some opponents say that although juries are instructed not to pay attention to the media, they are more easily influenced by the news than judges. Critics of the jury system also point out that juries are expensive and are often unable to reach an agreement. They argue that the decision making should be left up to the people who know the law, judges and lawyers.
In between these two extremes are those people who agree with the jury system as a whole, but feel that some changes need to be implemented to improve its effectiveness. These people suggest that juries receive instruction prior to hearing testimony. They argue that this would improve the system by providing some working legal knowledge for the jury as well as giving them an idea of what they are to listen for. Research has shown that exposing jurors to the laws involved in their decision making resulted in significantly fewer verdicts of guilty. This finding suggests that lawyers and judges should have the responsibility of insuring that the jury is adequately informed of the legal issues at hand and the laws available to handle those issues.
On the whole, though, I feel that the American guarantee of trial by jury is a valuable one. I do feel, however, that in order to improve its utility, judges and lawyers need to accept the responsibility for educating the jury on relevant legal issues.
选项
A、the jury system is unnecessarily complex and rigid
B、recent jury decisions are made against the democratic tradition
C、there is constant debate about its merit and its downfalls
D、Some juries.have made mistakes recently
答案
D
解析
细节题。第一段末句提到最近陪审团的几次裁决错误已引起批评家对这一体制提出质问。接着在第二段举例说明陪审团犯错,因此答案为D。
转载请注明原文地址:https://kaotiyun.com/show/ffd4777K
0
考研英语一
相关试题推荐
Intheeyesoftheauthor,conventionalopiniononthestrategicimportanceoftheGulfoilisWhensaying"itisstillahefty
Mostofusaretaughttopayattentiontowhatissaid—thewords.Wordsdoprovideuswithsomeinformation,butmeaningsare(1
WhatwouldhappentotheU.S.economyifallitscommercialbankssuddenlyclosedtheirdoors?ThroughoutmostofAmericanhisto
WhentheVikingsinvadedGreatBritain,theydidmorethanslaughterthepopulation,ransackthecitiesandscorchtheearth.Th
ThestoryofJ.B.S.HaldaneismentionedinthetextAccordingthetheoryofkinselection,humanstendtoactaltruistically
Theauthor’spurposeinwritingthispassageisItseemsthatthewriterismostconcernedabout
Fromwhatyouhaveread,wouldyouexpectmannerstoimproveamongpeoplewhoIntheauthor’sview,thebestremedyforcoping
Peoplebelievedforalongtimethattheheartwasthecenterofaperson’semotions.Thatiswhytheheartisusedinsomanye
Whatcanbeinferredfromthesentence"Sometimeslifegetstobetoomuch"(Sentence4,Paragraph3)?Thebesttitleforthep
AlanthoughtitisdifficulttoexplainthescenetohisfellowMarinesbecauseWecanlearnfromthelastparagraphthat
随机试题
高等教育的大众教育阶段是指高等教育人学人数和适龄人口的比例为()。
教育督导机构分中央和地方两级的国家是()
A.听神经损害B.肝损害C.球后视神经炎D.胃肠道反应E.骨髓抑制链霉素的毒性反应
下列属于银行调查分析客户信用状况5C标准的有()。
某上市公司2006年度财务会计报告批准报出日为2007年4月20日。公司在2007年1月1日至4月20日发生的下列事项中,属于资产负债表日后调整事项的是()。
配置性评价
当社会有效需求严重不足、经济不景气时,政府可以采取的措施是()。
数字技术的发展,为文化遗产的保护提供了全新的高科技手段。各个国家纷纷推出相关的措施和计划。然而,数字技术毕竟只是技术手段,最终不可能代替人类的智慧和精神。如果没有正确的理念加以引导,它可能堕落成“数字陷阱”。虚拟性有可能让一种文化变成一种“真实的”幻境,同
南书房
ThetradeandinvestmentrelationshipbetweentheEuropeanUnionandtheUnitedStatesisthemostimportantintheworld.Despi
最新回复
(
0
)