首页
外语
计算机
考研
公务员
职业资格
财经
工程
司法
医学
专升本
自考
实用职业技能
登录
外语
Two related paradoxes also emerge from the same basic conception of the aesthetic experience. The first was given extended consi
Two related paradoxes also emerge from the same basic conception of the aesthetic experience. The first was given extended consi
admin
2010-10-28
26
问题
Two related paradoxes also emerge from the same basic conception of the aesthetic experience. The first was given extended consideration by Hegel, who argued roughly as follows: our sensuous attention and that gives to the work of art its peculiar individuality. Because it addresses itself to our sensory appreciation, the work of art is essentially concrete, to be understood by an act of perception rather than by a process of discursive thought.
At the same time, our understanding of the work of art is in part intellectual; we seek in it a conceptual content, which it presents to us in the form of an idea. One purpose of critical interpretation is to expound this idea in discursive form—to give the equivalent of the content of the work of art in another, nonsensuous idiom. But criticism can never succeed in this task, for, by separating the content from the particular form, it abolishes its individuality. The content presented then ceases to be the exact content of that work of art. In losing its individuality, the content loses its aesthetic reality; it thus ceases to be a reason for attending to the particular work and that first attracted our critical attention. It cannot be this that we saw in the original work and that explained its power over us.
For this content, displayed in the discursive idiom of the critical intellect, is no more than a husk, a discarded relic of a meaning that eluded us in the act of seizing it. If the content is to be the true object of aesthetic interest, it must remain wedded to its individuality: it cannot be detached from its "sensuous embodiment" without being detached from itself. Content is, therefore, inseparable from form and form in turn inseparable from content. (It is the form that it is only by virtue of the content that it embodies.)
Hegel’s argument is the archetype of many, all aimed at showing that it is both necessary to distinguish form from content and also impossible to do so. This paradox may be resolved by rejecting either of its premises, but, as with Kant’s antinomy, neither premise seems dispensable. To suppose that content and form are inseparable is, in effect, to dismiss both ideas as illusory, since no two works of art can then share either a content or a form—the form being definitive of each work’s individuality.
In this case, no one could ever justify his interest in a work of art by reference to its meaning. The intensity of aesthetic interest becomes a puzzling, and ultimately inexplicable, feature of our mental life. If, on the other hand, we insist that content and form are separable, we shall never be able to find, through a study of content, the reason for attending to the particular work of art that intrigues us. Every work of art stands proxy for its paraphrase. An impassable gap then opens between aesthetic experience and its ground, and the claim that aesthetic experience is intrinsically valuable is thrown in doubt.
It can be inferred from this passage that ______ .
选项
A、it is necessary to distinguish form from content and also impossible to do so
B、both content and form of the work of art are illusory
C、the content and form of the work of art are separable
D、aesthetic experience is not intrinsically valuable
答案
A
解析
细节推断题 。黑格尔及众人都表示,有必要区分开内容与形式,但同时这样做也是不可能的。放弃这对矛盾的任何一个前提或许可以解决这个矛盾,但正如康德的自相矛盾论,任何一个前提都是不可分割的。A “有必要区分开内容与形式,但同时这也是不可能实现的”与之符合,故为正确答案。
转载请注明原文地址:https://kaotiyun.com/show/g9s7777K
0
大学英语六级
相关试题推荐
Therecentgrowthofexportsurplusesontheworldfoodmarkethascertainlybeenunexpectedlygreat,partlybecauseastranges
A、Becausestudentsneedindividualattention.B、Becausestudentsneedtobestimulated.C、Becausestudentsneedexactlythesame
A、Winterishisfavoritetimeforsports.B、Sportsarequiteimportanttohim.C、Heshouldbemoreenthusiastic.D、Heplaysbett
A、Theyareveryrewarding.B、Theygivehertoomuchtrouble.C、Theteacheristoostrict.D、Shedoesn’tlikethelessonsbecause
A、Shehastoreadalotofliteraturebooks.B、Shehasfailedtomeetthedeadlineforherreadingassignmentagain.C、TheEaste
TheLawofSupplyandDemandIftradeistotakeplace,atleasttwoeconomicunitsmustbeinvolved(business,households,
Smartfirmscanminimizetheirrisksbyconductingweaknessappraisals,choosingexperiencedsecuritypersonnelandestablishin
Theroleofmanagerisanothercriticalcomponentinthedevelopmentofanoffice-systemscareer.Onestudyreportedthatin76
A、Theyeatonlyfreshvegetable.B、Theyeatredmeatbutnofat.C、Theyeatnomeat.D、Theylivealonglife.C选项和他们的饮食,生活有关。本题是
A、FromThanksgivingtoChristmas.B、FromthedayafterThanksgivingtoChristmas.C、FromThanksgivingtoChristmasEve.D、Fromt
随机试题
被教唆人没有犯被教唆罪是指:
生产费用是指与企业日常生产经营活动有关的费用,按其经济用途可分为直接材料、直接人工和制造费用。()
机械加工车间的设备基础费率在我国的取费标准一般是()。
甲公司因当地政府城市规划的需要,2010年对其拥有的厂房及其相关设施进行拆除。按与政府签订的搬迁补偿协议,11月5日,公司收到财政部门拨入的全部搬迁补偿费6000万元;11月31日公司整体一次性搬迁,公司的房屋建筑物账面价值480万元(原值1000万元,累
生产企业自营出口或委托企业代理出口的自产货物在出口产品退还增值税、消费税时,一并退还已缴纳的城建税;有出口经营权的外贸企业收购后直接出口或委托其他外贸企业代理出口的货物在出门产品退还增值税、消费税时,不退还已缴纳的城建税。()
2014年9月,中国银行、华夏银行先后宣布在香港发行优先股。称证监会已核准其非公开发行优先股。10月16日,中国银行在香港发行我国首单优先股。这标志着我国金融改革又向前迈出了一大步。请回答以下问题:[对外经济贸易大学2015研]商业银行发行优先股的动机
程序编制有3个层次,其实施顺序应是()。
计算机的主机由哪些部件组成?
A、HearinglossmakesithardtogrowcropsinAlaska.B、Hearinglossisnotalocaldiseasebutaglobalone.C、About11million
Technologyisanothergreatforceforchange.Inpart,technologyhascausedthepopulationexplosion;manyofuswon’tnowbea
最新回复
(
0
)