首页
外语
计算机
考研
公务员
职业资格
财经
工程
司法
医学
专升本
自考
实用职业技能
登录
外语
Where does morality come from? Throughout the history of Western civilization thinkers have usually answered either that it come
Where does morality come from? Throughout the history of Western civilization thinkers have usually answered either that it come
admin
2015-01-09
56
问题
Where does morality come from? Throughout the history of Western civilization thinkers have usually answered either that it comes from God, or else through the application of reason.
But in The Bonobo and the Atheist, primatologist Frans de Waal argues that there’s another answer that fits the data better: morality comes from our evolutionary past as a social primate. Like our closest relatives, the apes, humans evolved in small, tightly knit, cooperative groups. As a result, again like the apes, we are exquisitely sensitive to one another’s moods, needs and intentions.
This well-developed empathy provided the trellis on which morality later flowered. De Waal, who is based at Emory University in Atlanta, Georgia, has been making this case eloquently for many years and over several books, notably in Good Natured back in 1997, and in Primates and Philosophers, 12 years later.
In his new work, he bolsters the argument by drawing on a lot of new research, carefully footnoted for those who want to dig deeper. De Waal distinguishes two degrees of morality. The first he calls "one-on-one morality", which governs how an individual can expect to be treated, and the second "community concern", a larger, more abstract concept that extends to the harmony of the group as a whole.
Chimps and bonobos certainly have the former—they respect ownership, for example, and expect to be treated according to their place in the hierarchy. But de Waal presents several examples—such as a chimp stepping in to stop a fight between two others—that suggest that they also have a rudimentary form of the latter.
The book’s title, incidentally, draws on bonobos because they are more likely than chimps to behave morally, to have concern for each other, to value harmony and so on. This, imagines, de Waal, is something morally inclined atheists would want to emulate. If humans inherited morality from our ancestors, though, what are we to make of religion? Here de Waal moves into the territory he has not explored before. Clearly, religion must do something important, since every human culture has it. But instead of religion giving us morality, de Waal turns the tables. Morality, he argues, probably gave us religion as a way of reinforcing the pre-existing community concern.
If he’s right, then there may be no absolute code of right and wrong out there to be discovered. Instead, each individual’s evolved sense of empathy and concern for the group may help shape the group’s consensus on what kind of behaviour is appropriate. In short, says de Waal, morality may be something we all have to work out together. It’s a persuasive argument, and de Waal’s cautious and evidence-based approach is one that many New Scientist readers are sure to find congenial.
That careful approach is less evident in another book covering some of the same ground. In How Animals Grieve, anthropologist Barbara King sets out to explore the question of whether non-human animals grieve for their dead. It’s an intriguing question, but unfortunately King’s book is largely a succession of anecdotes: the cat who roams the house, crying, in search of its dead litter mate; the dog who waits daily at the train station for its dead master; a dolphin trying to keep her dead calf afloat for days.
Some of these stories make a persuasive case for some animals—especially apes, elephants and cetaceans— sometimes grieving. No surprises there: I suspect most readers would have conceded that ground right from the start.
But King makes little effort to dig any deeper by exploring, for example, the neural machinery and cognitive skills an animal needs in order to be capable of grief. After all, solitary species such as cats have less need for empathy- and its corollary, grief—than social animals, and small-brained creatures such as turtles may simply lack the brainpower or not form lasting pair bonds.
To his credit, de Waal takes full note of such distinctions; King, not so much.
Which statement would Frans de Waal most probably agree to?
选项
A、Bonobos are not as concerned about each other as chimps.
B、Atheists would like to emulate the harmony among Bonobos.
C、Bonobos are a good example to show where morality comes from.
D、Atheists are a group of people who are lack of moral standards.
答案
C
解析
细节题。作者在第六段第一句提到Frans de Waal的书时指出,这本书的名字用倭黑猩猩(bonobos)是因为它们比黑猩猩(chimps)在行为上表现得更道德,故可知,Frans de Waal认为倭黑猩猩是说明道德来源的好例子,故[C]为答案。
转载请注明原文地址:https://kaotiyun.com/show/h5dO777K
0
专业英语八级
相关试题推荐
LondonissteepedinDickensianhistory.Everyplacehevisited,everypersonhemet,wouldbedrawnintohisimaginationandre
Accordingtothenews,thehealthcarereformbyObamabenefits
AnAmericansurveyhasshownthateachyeareveryemployedpersonlosesthreetofourworkingdaysfromcoldsandalliedcomplai
ImprovingthebalancebetweentheworkingpartofthedayandtherestofitisagoalofagrowingnumberofworkersinrichWe
TheNationalPeople’sCongressaimedtodoallthefollowingEXCEPT
人生是什么?人生的真相如何?人生的意义何在?人生的目的是何?这些人生最重大最中心的问题,不只是古来一切大宗教家哲学家所殚精竭虑以求解答的。世界上第一流的大诗人凝神冥想,深入灵魂的幽邃,或纵身大化中,于一朵花中窥见天国.一滴露水参悟生命。然后用他们生花之笔.
UltimoVargashadbeeninHatch,NewMexico,onlysixmonths,sinceMarch,andalreadyheownedhisownbusinesstocompetewith
Stoppingcigarettesmokinghasbecomeabigproblemforallgovernments.Indemocraticcountries,theeconomicstrengthofthe
我的第一个先生就是我母亲。我已经说过使我认识“爱”字的是她。在我幼儿的时候,她是我的世界的中心。她很完满地体现了一个“爱”字。她使我知道人间的温暖;她使我知道爱与被爱的幸福。她常常用温和的口气,对我解释种种的事情。她教我爱一切的人,不管他们贫或富;她教我帮
“开卷有益”是古人鼓励读书的一句成语。从前读到一册坏书,读后每觉得为古人所欺;现在多了一点智识,反过来又觉得古人的不欺我了。总之,好书读了,原有所得,就是可以知道它的好处在哪里。可是坏书读了,而知道它的坏的原因与地方,岂不也是一得?从前孔子说的“三人行,必
随机试题
被告人骆某因强奸未遂被某县人民法院判处有期徒刑3年,缓刑3年。骆某不服,以双方谈恋爱并非强奸为由提起上诉;第二审人民法院经过审理,认为骆某一贯猥亵妇女,造成社会不安定,具有人身危险性,决定改判有期徒刑3年,宣判后收监执行。对此,下列说法中,正确的有(
非常规型决策是要解决()的问题,往往缺乏类似问题处理经验。
下列关于估计资产的公允价值减去处置费用后的净额的说法中正确的是()。
患者,男,15岁,糖尿病史1年。1天前感冒发热,食欲下降而停用胰岛素。一天来恶心、呕吐,查体:睡眠状态,大声呼唤可醒,很快又入睡,醒时答话含糊,该患者意识障碍属于()。
根据以下资料,回答下列题。截至2012年底,生存时间5—10年的企业占企业总量的()。
下列关于权利能力和行为能力的表述,能够成立的有()。
ErnestHemingwaywasoneofthemostimportantAmericanwritersinthehistoryofcontemporaryAmericanliterature.Hewasthe【1
Whatistherelationshipbetweenthetwospeakers?
MalnutritionandtheDiseasesofPovertyMalnutritiondisproportionatelyaffectsthoseinsub-SaharanAfrica.Over35percent
A、Ithelpstheteacherorganizeextra-curriculaactivitieseasily.B、Ithelpsestablishthereputationofthewholeschool.C、It
最新回复
(
0
)