首页
外语
计算机
考研
公务员
职业资格
财经
工程
司法
医学
专升本
自考
实用职业技能
登录
考研
Should anyone much care whether an American boy living overseas gets six vicious thwacks on his backside? So much has been argue
Should anyone much care whether an American boy living overseas gets six vicious thwacks on his backside? So much has been argue
admin
2009-04-26
70
问题
Should anyone much care whether an American boy living overseas gets six vicious thwacks on his backside? So much has been argued, rejoined and rehashed about the case of Michael Fay, an 18-year-old convicted of vandalism and sentenced to a caning in Singapore, that an otherwise sorry little episode has shaded into a certified International Incident, complete with intercessions by the U.S. head of state. An affair has outraged American libertarians even as it has animated a general debate about morality East and West and the proper functioning of U.S. law and order.
Which, to all appearances, is what Singapore wanted. The question of whether anyone should care about Michael Fay is idle. Though Singapore officials profess shock at the attention his case had drawn, they know Americans care deeply about the many sides of this issue. Does a teenager convicted of spraying cars with easily removable paint deserve half a dozen powerful strokes? At what point does swift, sure punishment become torture? By what moral authority can America, with its high rates of lawlessness and license, preach of a safe society about human rights?
The caning sentence has concentrated minds wondrously on an already lively domestic debate over what constitutes a due balance between individual and majority rights. Too bad Michael Fay has become a focus for this discussion. Not only does he seem destined to be pummeled and immobilized, but the use of Singapore as a standard for judging any other society, let alone the cacophonous U.S., is fairly worthless.
To begin with, Singapore is an offshore republic that tightly limits immigration. Imagine crime-ridden Los Angeles, to which Singapore is sometimes contrasted, with hardly any inflow of the hard-luck, often desperate fortune seekers who flock to big cities. Even without its government’s disciplinary measures, Singapore more than plausibly would be much the same as it is now. An academic commonplace today is that the major factor determining social peace and prosperity is culture—a sense of common identity, tradition and values.
Unlike Singapore, though, the U.S. today is a nation in search of a common culture, trying to be a universal society that assimilates the traditions of people from all over the world. Efforts to safeguard minority as well as individual rights have produced a gridlock in the justice system. Its troubles stem more from the decay of family life than from any government failures. Few societies can afford to look on complacently. As travel eases and cultures intermix, the American experience is becoming the world’s.
The circumstances of this affair—evidently no Singaporean has ever been punished under the Vandalism Act for defacing private property—suggest that Singapore has used Fay as an unwilling point man in a growing quarrel between East and West about human rights.
选项
A、His case captured worldwide attention.
B、He received severe punishment.
C、His experience was out of the ordinary.
D、He was likely to be disabled.
答案
B
解析
转载请注明原文地址:https://kaotiyun.com/show/pma4777K
0
考研英语一
相关试题推荐
YouhavejustcomebackfromtheU.S.asamemberofaSino-Americanculturalexchangeprogram.WritealettertoyourAmerican
Politiciansshouldneverlose______oftheneedsofthepeopletheyrepresent.
Asyoucanseebyyourself,things______tobeexactlyastheprofessorhadforeseen.
Readthefollowingtextandanswerthequestionsbyfindinginformationfromtherightcolumnthatcorrespondstoeachofthema
Applicantsshouldnotethatallpositionsare______toAustraliancitizenshiprequirements.
Readthefollowingtextandchoosethebestanswerfromtherightcolumntocompleteeachoftheunfinishedstatementsinthele
Writeanessaybasedonthefollowinggraphs.Inyouressay,youshould1)interpretthegraphs,and2)giveyourcomments
Afterclashesbetweenriotpoliceandprotesters,workersattheKeihinHotelinTokyowereforciblyejectedonJanuary25th.Th
Moveover,organic,fairtradeandfreerange—thelatestinenlightenedediblesishere:foodwith"embedded"positiveintention
We’refairlygoodatjudgingpeoplebasedonfirstimpressions,thinslicesofexperiencerangingfromaglimpseofaphototoa
随机试题
胃十二指肠溃疡
下列属于第一次世界大战的的主要战役有()
哮喘性支气管炎的治疗原则应包括()
小儿五脏辨证,不属于肝经本病的是
构成护理程序的框架的理论基础是
郭某原系一名普通司机,通过努力,受到重视,开始担任某公交公司会计,后因公司部分资金去向不明,主管领导向公安机关报案。侦查过程中,郭某被公安机关以涉嫌职务侵占拘传。在拘传过程中,郭某对侦查人员提出的哪些问题有权不予回答?()
有一建筑高度在249m具有办公、购物、娱乐、休闲及旅馆等多种服务功能的民用建筑,地下3层,裙楼5层,地上共计60层,内设有地下影院、地下商场、游泳馆、娱乐场所及自备发电机房等设备、设施。有设置在六层以上的会议厅,可停放98辆汽车的地下复式汽车库。请就该建筑
保险代理机构及其分支机构未按本规定报送有关报告、报表、文件或者资料的,由中国保监会责令改正,逾期不改正的,处以( )罚款;对该机构直接负责的高级管理人员和其他直接责任人员,给予警告,并处5000元罚款。
广义的资本市场包括两大部分,一是银行中长期存贷款市场,二是()。
A市的图书销售量高于B市,因此,A市的居民比B市的居民更喜爱阅读。以下各项除了哪一项,都会削弱以上结论?()。
最新回复
(
0
)