首页
外语
计算机
考研
公务员
职业资格
财经
工程
司法
医学
专升本
自考
实用职业技能
登录
外语
According to the professor, what assumption might a reductionist make when analyzing ant colonies?
According to the professor, what assumption might a reductionist make when analyzing ant colonies?
admin
2018-08-16
49
问题
According to the professor, what assumption might a reductionist make when analyzing ant colonies?
Listen to part of a lecture in a philosophy class.
Professor: Today let’s explore two important philosophical concepts. They are two basically different ways of looking at things that have wide ranging influence on many disciplines like psychology, sociology, and animal behavior, and these approaches actually guide the way scientists do their research. You might have guessed I’m referring to holism and reductionism.
That’s holism—focusing on how an entity functions as a unit—and reductionism—reducing the whole to its parts. Suppose you’re looking at an ant colony, and the ant colony would be the whole, the whole system as it were and the ants are the part, with each individual ant representing the smallest part of that system. Reductionism is the belief that the workings of the system, any system, can be understood through an understanding of its smallest parts, how those parts work individually and also, the way any particular part interacts with another part. So in the case of the ant colony, a reductionist would investigate the behavior of individual ants within the colony and the way they interact with other ants in that colony. From that they would make generalizations about the behavior of the colony as a whole. Let’s take food for example. When an ant finds food, it takes that food back to the nest, and on its way back, it secretes a chemical, which leaves a trail that can be detected by other ants. In this way, it communicates about the location of food, and this behavior..., this communication describes an important way in which ants in a colony interact. To the extent we can understand the rule governing this behavior of that smallest part, the individual, then we can generalize about the behavior of larger groups of ants: following trails, finding food, leaving more trails, and so on. Eventually, we’ll understand the behavior of the entire colony and then, and this is an important part of the reductionist approach, we can predict what will happen in that colony.
Now, on the other hand, a holist believes that a system cannot really be understood by just understanding how the parts function. In other words, an old saying you might have heard before, "the whole is more than the sum of its parts." So when looking at an ant colony, the holist sees it from two perspectives: of the individual ant, and of the whole colony, because the behavior of the individual ants taken together has an impact on the colony as a whole, and the colony as a total system has an impact on the individual ants. You have to view the behavior of the colony as more than simply the total of the individual behaviors. One reason for looking at the behavior of the colony is that the colony as a whole seems to know what to do, to act for its own benefit in a way that any given individuals could not.
The holist believes that the collective behavior of the colony as a whole cannot be traced to specific individuals. In animal behavior, we refer to this as "collective intelligence," and it’s a good thing that ants have this collective intelligence because the individual ant is ill-suited to life outside the colony. So what’s an example of this collective intelligence? Well, sometimes the ants switch tasks, let’s say from taking care of the next generation to gathering food, and we don’t know exactly what triggers this behavior, but somehow they just know when more food gatherers are needed. There’s no leader in an ant colony, no one giving orders. And don’t confuse ant society with human society: there is a queen, but all she does is lay eggs. And of course, no single ant could possibly know how much food is needed in the whole colony, but somehow, as a group, they know to supply the colony with enough food. The most likely explanation for this is that it has something to do with chemical signals from ants in the colony.
选项
A、Small ant colonies are more efficient than large ones.
B、Individual ants know how much food the colony needs.
C、Each ant colony as a single entity acts in its own interest.
D、The colony’s behavior can be understood by analyzing individual ants’ behavior.
答案
D
解析
细节题。线索词为教授所说:So in the case of the ant colony,a reductionist would investigate the behavior of individual ants within the colony and the way they interact with other ants in that colony.From that they would make generalizations about the behavior of the colony as a whole.如原文所述,还原论者认为我们可以通过分析群体内个体蚂蚁的行为来理解整个群体的行为。A选项错误,因为文中未就大小蚁群的工作效率展开对比。B选项与原文相悖,个体蚂蚁不知道整个蚁群需要多少食物。而且,该选项所涉内容属于整体论的探讨范畴,并非还原论的。C选项错误原因同B选项的第二点错误原因。
转载请注明原文地址:https://kaotiyun.com/show/rAfO777K
0
托福(TOEFL)
相关试题推荐
Completetheformbelow.WriteNOMORETHANTWOWORDSAND/ORANUMBERforeachanswer.DurhamCountyCarShowPublicgrandopeni
Whatproblemsdothespeakersidentifyforthisproject?ChooseSEVENanswersfromtheboxandwritetheletters,A-H,nexttoq
Completetheformbelow.WriteNOMORETHANTWOWORDSAND/ORANUMBERforeachanswer.PhoneInterviewName:JohnMurphyExample
Completethesentencesbelow.WriteONEWORDONLYforeachanswer.Theprogramoperatesincooperationwiththe
Whatdothestudentsdecideaboutthefollowingpartsoftheproject?Writethecorrectletter,A,BorC,nexttoquestions27-
AccordingtoBetty,whatcanbesaidaboutthesalesofbothcheeseandoilinNewZealandandColombia?
ChooseTWOletters,A-E.WhichTWOpre-existingfeaturesofthesitearenowpartofthenewfacilities?AfootballstadiumBpl
Whichattitudeisassociatedwiththefollowingpeopleduringtheconversation?ChooseSIXanswersfromtheboxandwritetheco
Whatisthedesiredoutcometoeachofthefollowingcourseofaction?ChooseFIVEanswersfromtheboxandwritethecorrectle
AnimationTechnologyHistoryThomasEdison:firstcamera—1889StuartBlackton:firstanimatedfilmtechnique—u
随机试题
根据《产品质量法》的规定,生产者在产品中不得实施()
活动后左腰部绞痛,伴肉眼血尿、恶心、呕吐。首先考虑的疾病是
关于宪法实施,下列说法中错误的是哪些选项?()
裁决书中的文字有遗漏的,当事人可以自收到裁决书之日起()日内请求仲裁庭补正。
根据上级规划要求和本地土地资源特点,分解落实土地利用各项指标。这是()的主要任务之一。
具有技术简便、费用不多、应用面广和资料全面的优点,且在我国广泛采用的计时观察方法是()。
()过程主要是将原始分数转化为百分等级,再将百分等级转化为常态分布上相应的离均值,并可以表示为任何平均数和标准差。
参加神舟七号载人航天飞行的飞行员是()。
贯穿邓小平理论形成和发展的全过程,始终体现在邓小平理论所做出的每一项重大决策中的核心思想是()。
Notcontentwithitsdoubtfulclaimtoproducecheapfoodforourownpopulation,thefactoryfarmingindustryalsoarguesthat
最新回复
(
0
)