首页
外语
计算机
考研
公务员
职业资格
财经
工程
司法
医学
专升本
自考
实用职业技能
登录
外语
We now find that a great many things we thought were Natural Laws are really human conventions. You know that even in the remote
We now find that a great many things we thought were Natural Laws are really human conventions. You know that even in the remote
admin
2013-01-20
17
问题
We now find that a great many things we thought were Natural Laws are really human conventions. You know that even in the remotest depth of stellar space there are still three feet to a yard. That is.no doubt, a very remarkable fact, but you would hardly call it a law of nature. And a great many things that have been regarded as laws of nature are of that kind. (1)
On the other hand, where you can get down to any knowledge of what atoms actually do, you will find that they are much less subject to law than people thought, and that the laws at which you arrive are sta tistical averages of just the sort that would emerge from chance.
There is, as we all know, a law that if you throw dice you will get double sixes only about once in thirty-six times, and we do not regard that as evidence that the fall of the dice is regulated by design;on the contrary, if the double sixes came every time we should think that there was design.
The laws of nature are of that sort a s regards to a great many of them. They are statistical averages such as would emerge from the laws of chance;and that makes the whole business of natural law much less impressive than it formerly was. (2)
Quite apart from that, which represents the momentary state of science that may change tomorrow, the whole idea that natural laws imply a law-giver is due to a confusion between natural and human laws.
Human laws are behests commanding you to behave a certain way, in which way you may choose to behave, or you may choose not to behave; (3)
but natural laws are a description of how things do in fact behave, and, being a mere description of what they in fact do, you cannot argue that there must be somebody who told them to do that, because even supposing that there were you are then faced with the question, Why did God issue just those natural laws and not others?
If you say that he did it simply from his own good pleasure, and without any reason, you then find that there is something which is not subject to law, and so your train of natural law is interrupted. If you say, as more orthodox theologians do, that in all the laws which God issues he had a reason for giving those laws rather than others—the reason, of course, being to create the best universe, although you would never think to look at it—if there was a reason for the laws which God gave, then God himself was subject to law and therefore you do not get any advantage by introducing God as an intermediary.
(4)
You really have a law outside and anterior to the divine edicts, and God does not serve your purpose, because he is not the ultimate law-giver.
In short, this whole argument from natural law no longer has anything like the strength that it used to have. I am traveling on in time in my review of these arguments. The arguments that are used for the existence of God change their character as time goes on. (5)
They were at first hard intellectual arguments embodying certain quite definite fallacies. As we come to modem times they become less respectable intellectually and more affected by a kind of moralizing vagueness.
选项
答案
但是自然法则是对事物真实运动的描述,它仅仅是对其行为的一种描述。你不能说一定是有人告诉它们这样做,因为假设真的有,你就要面对这样的问题:为什么上帝只创造了自然法则而不是其他呢?
解析
转载请注明原文地址:https://kaotiyun.com/show/sM2O777K
0
考博英语
相关试题推荐
______theearthtobeflat,manyfearedthatColumbuswouldfallofftheedgeoftheEarth.
TestshaveconfirmedthatfourpeopleinWisconsincontractedthemonkeypoxvirusaftercomingintoclosecontactwithpetprair
AlltherecentnewsonAIDSisbad.ThedeathofRockHudson【1】publicconcern-aboutthe【2】almosttothepointofpanic.Nowgen
AlltherecentnewsonAIDSisbad.ThedeathofRockHudson【1】publicconcern-aboutthe【2】almosttothepointofpanic.Nowgen
TomJones,who______aroundtheworld,willcometoAsianextmonth.
Ourape-menforefathershadnoobviousnaturalweaponsinthestruggleforsurvivalintheopen.Theyhadneitherthepowerfult
TheJapanesedesireformarriagehadbeenverystrong.Inthefifth"worldyouthattitudesurvey"【C1】______bytheManagementand
TheJapanesedesireformarriagehadbeenverystrong.Inthefifth"worldyouthattitudesurvey"【C1】______bytheManagementand
Atallageandatallstagesoflife,fearpresentsaproblemtoalmosteveryone."Wearelargelytheplaythingsofourfears,"
随机试题
社会团体、公民社会对公共政策的积极作用与消极影响有哪些?
Manystudentsfindtheexperienceofattendinguniversitylecturestobeaconfusingandfrustratingexperience.Thelecturersp
益气养阴法的代表方是
下列哪一项与中骨盆狭窄无关
2岁小儿,7个月时会翻身和独坐,现坐不稳,脸色渐苍白,肝右肋下4cm,脾左肋下3cm,外周血象见红细胞体积大,中性粒细胞呈分叶过多现象。此小儿最可能的诊断是()
患者,男,70岁。癌症晚期。患者极度衰弱。对周围事物无兴趣。常处嗜睡状态。护士评估该患者的心理反应是
莫某通过互联网认识蒋某后,以5500元人民币向蒋某购买了1100张面值100元的假人民币11万元。莫某携带此假币窜到某市,以假币购买小商品换取真人民币的方式到处作案,一共使用了52张100元面值的假人民币。派出所民警在巡逻过程中发现莫某在出售假币,并从其身
在票据转让中,转让汇票的背书人与受让汇票的被背书人在汇票上的签章依次前后衔接称为()。
舆情指在经过收集整理之后所分析归纳出的具有一定系统性和典型性的舆论意见、情况和信息的综合。下列不涉及舆情的是()。
BusinessinstitutionshavemoreprestigeinAmericansocietythananyotherkindoforganization,includingthegovernment.Most
最新回复
(
0
)