首页
外语
计算机
考研
公务员
职业资格
财经
工程
司法
医学
专升本
自考
实用职业技能
登录
考研
Personalized medicine has proved an elusive dream. Biotechnology companies have claimed that by matching a person’s genetic make
Personalized medicine has proved an elusive dream. Biotechnology companies have claimed that by matching a person’s genetic make
admin
2013-01-25
85
问题
Personalized medicine has proved an elusive dream. Biotechnology companies have claimed that by matching a person’s genetic make-up with specialised treatments, they can tailor drugs to maximise benefits and minimise side effects. Alas, researchers have discovered that the link between a given person’s genetic make-up and specific diseases is much more complex than they had hoped. The tantalizing vision remains out of reach.
A rare exception has been the success that Myriad Genetics, an American firm, has had with two genes called BRCA1 and BRCA2. Certain versions of these genes, it has been shown, are associated with a high risk of breast and ovarian cancer. The University of Utah has patented the genes and licenses them to Myriad. The firm uses that exclusivity to create expensive genetic tests for cancer risk which only it offers for sale.
The BRCA patents have long frustrated medical researchers and legal activists. They claim that the firm’s grip on the two genes unlawfully stifles both innovation and basic science. Given the history of patent rulings in America, that has been a fringe argument— until now.
On March 29th a federal district court in New York made a ruling that, taken at face value,
turns
America’s approach to the patent protection of genes
on its head
. A coalition led by the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) had challenged the very basis of Myriad’s patents. The nub of the case was this question; "Are isolated human genes and the comparison of their sequences patentable things?"
Until now, the answer had been "Yes". But Robert Sweet, the presiding judge, disagreed. He ruled: "It is concluded that DNA’s existence in an ’isolated’ form alters neither this fundamental quality of DNA as it exists in the body nor the information it encodes. Therefore, the patents at issues directed to ’isolated DNA’ containing sequences found in nature are unsustainable as a matter of law and are deemed unpatentable subject matter. "
As a rule, patents are not granted for rules of nature or naturally occurring phenomena, but the American patent office has allowed genes to be patented if they are isolated and "purified. " Perhaps no longer, if this decision is upheld. The ACLU gleefully declared that this ruling "marks the first time a court has found patents on genes unlawful and calls into question the validity of patents now held on approximately 2,000 human genes. "
So is this really such a landmark ruling? It is clear that the judge has the history books in mind. His ruling cites Stephen Breyer, a member of America’s Supreme Court, who argued that "sometimes too much patent protection can impede rather than ’promote the Progress of Science and useful Arts,’ the constitutional objective of patent and copyright protection. "
However, the majority of the Supreme Court did not agree with Justice Breyer. Dianne Nicol, a professor of law, observes that "this case turns on whether an isolated gene sequence has markedly different characteristics from a gene that occurs in the human body. The judge in this case has said it does not have different characteristics but it will be interesting to see if the higher courts agree with that. "[520 words]
Who is most likely to side with Myriad Genetics?
选项
A、The ACLU.
B、Robert Sweet.
C、Stephen Breyer.
D、Dianne Nicol.
答案
D
解析
本题考查文中人物观点。
转载请注明原文地址:https://kaotiyun.com/show/vZp4777K
0
考研英语一
相关试题推荐
BlackdeaththatdroveNewtonfromhiscollegeandintoamomentousdiscovery,(1)_____Englandin1665.Astronomicalrecordsof
NaturalismbelievesthatManystrictnaturalists’attitudestowardsthecategorizingofnaturalistsmightbe
ThefirstwhitementovisitSamoafoundpeoplewho______.WhydidShaeferputthepaperunderglass?
Themostgeneraldefinitionthatcanbegiven,is,thatthePhilosophyofHistorymeansnothingbutthethoughtfulconsideration
Whenanyoneopensacurrentaccountatabank,heislendingthebankmoney.Hemay(1)_____therepaymentofthemoneyatanyt
Thefirstparagraphiswrittento______.Onereasonthatmanycollegesadoptthewebsiteisto______.
Thefirstparagraphiswrittento______.Inthetext,acomparisonismadesoasto______.
Theword"nascent"inthefirstparagraphofthetextmostprobablymeans______.Paragraph2iswrittento______.
(46)Itmustbestressedthatacharacteristicaspectofthepresenttimeisthatscienceisexercisingadecisiveinfluenceont
随机试题
常规钢抽油杆制造工艺简单、成本低、直径小、适用范围广,约占有杆泵抽油井的()以上。
脱水药不能用于下列何种病人()
宏远公司2012年6月初固定资产期初余额为4300000元,累计折旧期初余额为230000元(其中6月初生产车间计提的折旧额为62000元,管理部门计提的折旧额为15000元),6月和7月发生经济业务如下:(1)6月3日,自行购建的生产
募集机构应当自行或者委托第三方机构对私募基金进行风险评级,建立科学有效的私募基金风险评级标准和方法。募集机构应当根据私募基金的风险类型和评级结果,向投资者推介与其风险识别能力和()相匹配的私募基金。
公安机关贯彻社会治安综合的工作方针,应坚持()的原则。
关于胰岛素治疗,下列哪项是错误的
执行返回指令,退出中断服务程序,这时返回地址来自( )。
Asregardssocialconventions,wemustsayawordabouttheEnglishclasssystem.ThisisanembarrassingsubjectforEnglishpe
Consumersshoulddo________thansimplycomplainaboutthepoorqualityofgoods.
Passwordsareapainintheass.They’reeithereasyto【C1】______orhardtoremember,andwhenbreaches(破坏)【C2】______youhave
最新回复
(
0
)