首页
外语
计算机
考研
公务员
职业资格
财经
工程
司法
医学
专升本
自考
实用职业技能
登录
考研
The conviction of seven Italian geological and disaster experts for their negligence in failing to predict the 6. 3 magnitude qu
The conviction of seven Italian geological and disaster experts for their negligence in failing to predict the 6. 3 magnitude qu
admin
2014-06-25
19
问题
The conviction of seven Italian geological and disaster experts for their negligence in failing to predict the 6. 3 magnitude quake in 2009 in the small town of Aquila has shocked the scientific community. Many are wondering whether the Dark Ages have returned to Italy. Galileo rarely trends on Twitter, yet Monday’s verdict by a three-judge panel had many alluding to his 1633 heresy conviction by the Catholic Church because he questioned whether the sun actually circled the Earth.
If the Earth is not the center of God’s universe, neither are scientists. Their concerns about scientific freedom and how the verdict will silence research are a little overblown and exceptionally righteous. The verdict, instead, should be understood as a celebration of science. Society has come to believe that science can help citizens make judgments about where to live, how to act, and whether to evacuate. Unlike in the time of Galileo, society has come to accept the value of evidence and deduction. The court’s ruling is a reminder to the scientific community that along with their God-given skills comes a certain a-mount of civic responsibility.
Science was not on trial; scientists were. The facts of the case are much more complicated than its critics care to explain. The judges did not argue that earthquake prediction is perfect; they did not demand flawless accuracy in a field that everyone knows is more an art form. Instead, they ruled that members of the so-called Great Risks Commission had not only failed to properly assess the evidence before them, but had actually communicated the exact opposite, despite evidence to the contrary.
Earthquake prediction may not be exact, but it isn’t witchcraft either. For those of us who have worked in crisis and disaster management, there is a thriving field of predictive analysis using earthquake modeling, small tremor tracking, and radon gas releases. These techniques provide experts, and public-safety entities who will have to respond, a hope to penetrate the mystery around earthquakes: Does this type of natural disaster actually drop hints before the Big One?
The defendants were sentenced because the public places a value on scientific assurances, much more so than political ones. Maybe the commission was used by politicians who, for reasons that are inexplicable, didn’t want to have to deal with a jittery public. One commission member even told everyone to chill with a glass of wine. The commission should have known, the court ruled, that its assurances would be understood by the citizens of Aquila to be like words from the heavens. The ruling wasn’t about demanding from science an exactitude that doesn’t exist. Instead, it validates the role science plays in helping to drive public behavior, as it has with climate change or tsunami warnings. Because the public believes in the value of data, hypothesis, and even generalized predictions, it expected much better of the Italian scientists.
In the author’s opinion. Monday’s verdict reflected______.
选项
A、a trend of increasing restrictions on scientific freedom
B、a widespread embrace of scientific knowledge
C、a public disappointment at scientific research
D、an excessive expectation on scientific responsibility
答案
B
解析
第二段第三句指出,该判决应该被视为科学的庆典。然后进行解释:该判决表明整个社会逐渐开始接受证据和推理的价值,开始相信科学能够帮助人们做出行动决定,[B]选项正确。
转载请注明原文地址:https://kaotiyun.com/show/wGK4777K
0
考研英语一
相关试题推荐
OnecountrythatiscertainoftheeffectoffilmsontourismisAustralia.TheTouristOfficeofQueenslandsaythatCrocodile
Theprotectionofculturaldiversityfromapoliticalandeconomicpointofviewinfactbecamepressingwithglobalization,whi
(46)Ifyouconsultcomparativeglobaleconomicandsocialstatistics,itisnotdifficulttopaintableakpictureofArabfailu
Fatehasnotbeenkindtothewesterngreywhale.Itsnumbershavedwindledto130orso,leavingit"criticallyendangered"in
Forthispart,youaresupposedtowriteacompositionbasedonthetopicNewspapers.1.Describepaper’sinfluenceandtheimpo
Whichofthefollowingwouldbethebesttitleforthetext?Wecanlearnfromthetextthatartcriticshaveahistoryof____
NewYorkTimeswasnotcriticizedbytheconservativebecauseofbeing______.Thecontentofsmartertimes.comincludesalloft
Asanation,Japanisunusuallywellpreparedfornaturaldisasters.IntheyearssinceWorldWarII,successivegovernmentshav
Expertshavelearnedfromstudyingotherdisasters,suchasOklahomaCitybombing,the【C1】______ofSept.11andthe【C2】______of
随机试题
A.活血祛瘀,固冲安胎B.益气养血,固冲安胎C.补填填精,固冲安胎D.温补肾阳,固冲安胎E.补肾健脾,调理冲任
蠕形螨寄生于
A.推动作用B.营养作用C.气化作用D.防御作用E.固摄作用元气的主要功能是()
下列各项中,属于会计政策变更的是()。(2015年学员回忆版)
(2013年)甲公司为实现多元化经营,决定对乙公司进行长期股权投资。甲公司和乙公司适用的企业所得税税率均为25%,按净利润的10%提取盈余公积。投资业务的相关资料如下: (1)2009年11月10日,甲公司与丙公司签订了收购其持有的乙公司2000万股普
甲汽车租赁公司拟购置一批新车用于出租,现有两种投资方案,相关信息如下:方案一:购买中档轿车100辆,每辆车价格10万元,另需支付车辆价格10%的购置相关税费,每年平均出租300天,日均租金150元/辆,车辆预计使用年限8年,8年后变现价值为0,前
由正脊、四条垂脊、四条戗脊组成的屋顶形式称为()
在社会策划模式实施过程中,自我评估指的是由社会工作者()。
证明:.
在用Open语句打开文件时,如果省略“For方式”,则打开的文件的存在方式是______。
最新回复
(
0
)