首页
外语
计算机
考研
公务员
职业资格
财经
工程
司法
医学
专升本
自考
实用职业技能
登录
外语
The College Calculation The most subversive question about higher education has always been whether the college makes the st
The College Calculation The most subversive question about higher education has always been whether the college makes the st
admin
2012-07-11
36
问题
The College Calculation
The most subversive question about higher education has always been whether the college makes the student or the student makes the college. Sure, Harvard graduates make more money than graduates of just about any other college. And most community-college students will end up making far less than graduates of flagship state universities. But of course these students didn’t enter college with the same preparation and skills. Colleges don’t help to clear up the situation either, because they do so little to measure what students learn between freshman and senior years. So doubt lurks (潜伏) how much does a college education — the actual teaching and learning that happens on campus — really matter?
A recession makes such doubt all the more outstanding. Last month, National Public Radio ran a segment called "Is a College Education Worth the Debt?" in which an economist noted that 12 percent of mail carriers have college degrees — the point being that they could have gotten the same jobs without the degrees. In January, "20/20" ran a similar segment, in which somebody identified as an education consultant and a career counselor summed up the case against college. "You could take the pool of college-bound students and you could lock them in a closet for four years," he said, and thanks to their smarts and work ethic, they would still outearn people who never went to college. I heard a more measured version of these concerns when I recently sat down with a group of college students. They were paying tuition and studying hard, and yet they weren’t sure what they would find on the other side of graduation.
Along with all this skepticism, though, economic downturns also create one big countervailing (抵消的) force that pushes people toward college: many of them have nothing better to do. They have lost their jobs, or they find no jobs waiting for them after high school. In economic terms, the opportunity cost of going to school has been reduced. Over the course of the 1930s, the percentage of 17-year-olds who graduated from high school jumped to 50 percent, from less than 30 percent. Boys — many of whom would have been working in better times — made up the bulk of the influx. In our Great Recession, students have surged into community colleges.
So who is right — these students or the skeptics? It isn’t too much of an exaggeration to say that the field of labor economics has spent the past 30 years trying to come up with an answer. In one paper after another, economists have tried to identify the portion of a person’s success for which schooling can fairly claim credit. One well-known study, co-written by Alan Krueger, a Princeton professor now serving as the Treasury Department’s chief economist, offered some support for the skeptics. It tracked top high-school students through their 30s and found that their alma maters (母校) had little impact on their earnings. Students who got into both, say, the University of Pennsylvania and Penn State made roughly the same amount of money, regardless of which they chose. Just as you might hope, the fine-grain status distinctions that preoccupy elite high-school seniors (and more to the point, their parents) seem to be overrated.
The rest of the evidence, however, has tended to point strongly in the other direction. Several studies have found a large earnings gap between more-and less-educated identical twins. Another study compared young men who happened to live close to a college with young men who did not. The two groups were similar except for how easy it was for them to get to school, and the upshot was that the additional education attained by the first group lifted their earnings. "College can’t guarantee anybody a good life," says Michael McPherson, an economist who runs the Spencer Foundation in Chicago, which finances education research. "But it sure ups the odds substantially."
Earnings may be a flawed measure of an education’s value, but they’re about the only tangible measure we have. And the work that labor economists have done suggests that colleges do indeed deserve credit for much of the earnings gaps between their graduates and everyone else. The median earnings of full-time workers with bachelor’s degrees was nearly $47,000 in 2007, according to the Census Bureau. The median for someone who had attended college but failed to get a four-year degree was nearly $33,000, and the median for a high-school graduate was nearly $27,000. Compare these numbers with the typical education debt that a college student has on graduation day — $20,000 — and it’s clear that a college education is worth the debt. McPherson slyly points out that even the pundits and professors who suggest otherwise seem to understand this; they tend to send their children to college, often to quite expensive ones.
Yet the skeptics do make one crucial point. Nationwide, half of all students who start college don’t end up with a four-year degree. Not only do these dropouts spend less time in class, but they also miss out on the signaling benefit of the degree — a mark of those who, among other things, have the discipline to finish what they start.
Some would-be dropouts may stay in school if Congress approves a pending proposal to increase Pell Grants to needy students. Still, college tuitions are rising and resources are being cut — two factors that affect graduation rates. Federal spending cushions the blow but isn’t large enough to make up for state cutbacks. At Dyersburg State Community College, in northwest Tennessee, enrollment rose a staggering 28 percent this fall compared with last fall, but the state cut the college’s budget by 16 percent, thanks to the recession, Karen Bowyer, the college’s president, told me. For similar reasons, the University of California system plans to enroll fewer freshmen this year than last. Given the current debate in Washington, it’s worth noting that the rising cost of health care puts more pressure on state budgets than perhaps anything else.
When you look at what’s happening at Dyersburg State and dozens of similar places across the country, you’re left thinking that students understand that they don’t make the college. They need the college. The rest of us would probably say that they do, too. The cliches are familiar enough: the children are our future; I’ll be the education president, etc.
Yet when you look at our actual policies, you have to wonder. Many colleges and high schools still fail to do a good job, year after year, with little consequence. And in the deepest recession in a generation, at the very moment when education would be of most value, money for it is disappearing. It’s almost as if we’ve been convinced that college isn’t, after all, all that different from locking somebody in a closet for four years.
Alan Krueger’s study implies that______.
选项
A、the status of colleges doesn’t influence students’ earnings too much
B、students’ earnings are directly connected with their colleges’ fame
C、there exists no distinction between colleges with different reputation
D、parents should drive their children to go to colleges with good names
答案
A
解析
文中说Alan Krueger等研究发现母校对其毕业生收入影响甚微,学校地位的细微差别被夸大了,故答案为[A]。
转载请注明原文地址:https://kaotiyun.com/show/wvE7777K
0
大学英语六级
相关试题推荐
A、Themaincampus.B、Thestudentpopulation.C、Theage-oldideals.D、TheprogramsoftheDivisionofContinuingEducation.C细节题。
MarsfascinatesscientistsbecauseofitssimilaritytoEarth,anditfascinatesthepublicbecauseourmythof"Martians"isa
A、ShethinksLilyshouldtakeabusinessclass.B、ShegetsangrywithLilyatthemeeting.C、SheadmiresLilyforexpressingher
Thehumanbraincontains10thousandmillioncellsandeachofthesemayhaveathousandconnec-tions.Suchenormousnumbersus
A、Noblemencenturiesagodidnotliketraveling.B、Heredityisnottheonlythingthatinfluencesourcolor,C、Exposuretosunli
Aresearchersaysleadintheenvironmentcouldbeamajorcauseofviolencebyyoungpeople.DoctorHerbertNeedlemanisaprof
Thepassageismainlyabout______.Tocurethesnoringproblems,surgerycanbeusedtoimprove______.
A、Pollutionoftheenvironment.B、Anewgenerationofpestkillers.C、Over-killingbyhunters.D、Destructionoftheirnaturalho
IndustrialpollutionisnotonlyaproblemforthecountriesofEuropeandNorthAmerica.Itisanextremelyseriousproblemin
A、Athisapartment.B、Inahotelnearby.C、Inthewoman’shome.D、Inhisfriend’sdormitory.C由女士提到的Whynotcomewithustoour
随机试题
以口腔黏膜继发性溃疡为特征表现的疾病是
体液的pH可影响药物跨膜转运,主要是改变其
多年冻土地区的铁路工程的路线选线,正确的是()。
背景某机电设备安装公司经邀请招标投标,获得某厂生产线的机电设备安装工程,并与业主签订了施工合同。合同规定工程范围、工期、质量标准、安全环境要求。其中质量标准和要求按部颁标准执行,主要材料如钢材、电缆、φ50以上的管道阀门等由业主提供,安装现场的协
下列不属于细水雾灭火系统的特性的是()。
下列表述不完全符合《注册税务师资格制度暂行规定》中所列举的可以接受酌代理项目有()。
已知A=BP,其中,则A2012=_________.
依据惯例,美国卸任官员或议员______会著书,畅谈人生之路;还会利用各个场合发表演讲,借此既可以继续影响社会,也可以赚取“生活费”。虽然7年的政治生涯没落下什么“好名声”,但可以肯定的是,卸任后的施瓦辛格即将______“捞金时代”。依次填入划横线
设α1,α2,β1,β2为三维列向量组,且α1,α2与β1,β2都线性无关.证明:至少存在一个非零向量可同时由α1,α2和β1,β2线性表示;
TipsforApplyingtoU.S.CollegesI.GeorgeMasonUniversity-Thelargest【T1】______universityinVirginia-Morethan100
最新回复
(
0
)