首页
外语
计算机
考研
公务员
职业资格
财经
工程
司法
医学
专升本
自考
实用职业技能
登录
外语
How efficient is our system of criminal trial? Does it really do the basic job we ask of it—convicting the guilty and acquitting
How efficient is our system of criminal trial? Does it really do the basic job we ask of it—convicting the guilty and acquitting
admin
2011-05-29
58
问题
How efficient is our system of criminal trial? Does it really do the basic job we ask of it—convicting the guilty and acquitting the innocent? It is often said that the British trial system is more like a game than a serious attempt to do justice. The lawyers on each side are so engrossed in playing hard to win, challenging each other and the judge on technical points, that the object of finding out the truth is almost forgotten. All the effort is concentrated on the big day, on the dramatic cross-examination of the key witnesses in front of the jury. Critics like to compare our "adversarial" system (resembling two adversaries engaged in a contest) with the Continental "inquisitorial" system, under which the judge plays a more important inquiring role.
In early times, in the Middle Ages, the systems of trial across Europe were similar. At that time trial by "ordeal"— essentially a religious event—was the main way of testing guilt or innocence. When this was eventually abandoned, the two systems parted company. On the Continent, church-trained legal officials took over the function of both prosecuting and judging, while in England these were largely left to lay people, the Justice of the Peace and the jury. The jurymen were often illiterate and this meant that all the evidence had to be put to them orally. This historical accident dominates procedure even today, with all evidence being given in open court by word of mouth on the crucial day.
On the other hand, in France for instance, all the evidence is written before the trial under supervision by an investigating judge. This exhaustive pretrial looks very undramatic; much of it is just a public checking of the written records already gathered.
The Americans adopted the British system lock, stock and barrel and enshrined it in their Constitution. But, while the basic features of our systems are common, there are now significant differences in the way serious cases are handled. First, because the U. S. A. has virtually no contempt of court laws to prevent pretrial publicity in the newspaper and on television, American lawyers are allowed to question jurors about knowledge and beliefs.
In Britain this is virtually never allowed, and a random selection of jurors who are presumed not to be prejudiced are empanelled. Secondly, there is no separate profession of barrister in the United States, and both prosecution and defense lawyers who are to present cases in court prepare them themselves. They go out and visit the scene, track down and interview witnesses, and familiarize themselves personally with the background. In Britain it is the solicitor who prepares the case; the barrister who appears in court is not even allowed lo meet witness beforehand. British barristers also alternate doing both prosecution and defense work. By being kept distant from the preparation and regularly appearing for both sides, barristers are said to avoid becoming too personally involved, and can approach cases more dispassionately. American lawyers, however, often know their cases better.
Reformers rightly want to learn from other countries’ mistakes and successes. But what is clear is that justice systems, largely because they are the result of long historical growth, are peculiarly difficult to adapt piecemeal.
In Britain, newspapers ______.
选项
A、do the same as American newspapers do
B、are not interested in publishing details about the trial before it takes place
C、are not allowed to publish details about the trial before it takes place
D、are allowed to publish details about the trial before it takes place
答案
C
解析
文中作者在第四段第二句和第三句谈到,英美两国在受理重刑案件时一个最显著的区别是:美国法律并不阻止报纸和电视在庭审前对这类案件的大肆渲染。由此可见,在审理重刑案件之前,英国法律是不允许报纸报道任何细节的。因此这道题的正确答案应当为C。
转载请注明原文地址:https://kaotiyun.com/show/xC6O777K
0
考博英语
相关试题推荐
Readthenewreportbelow.ChoosethecorrectwordtofilleachgapfromA,BorC.Foreachquestion(29-40),markoneletter(A,
Readthearticlebelowaboutrelationshipwithcustomers.Foreachquestion(23-28)ontheoppositepage,choosethecorrectanswe
VP50PROJECTORDetailsofretailersavailableonwww.viewpoint.projectors.com
Lookatthechartbelow.Itshowstheproduction,salesandrejectionofproductsineightcompanies(A-H)ofagivenmonth.Whi
TheDevelopmentProgrammeManagementProcessAEstablishingareviewboardfordevelopmentsBEstablishingreviewcriteriaandm
FeaturesofWarehouseManagementSystemWarehouseManagementSystemsaregainingimportancesimilartothatofothersoftwar
TheAleuts(阿留申人)werenamedsobyRussians,buttheycallthemselvesUnanganwhichmeans"thepeople."Theyarenativeinhabit
TheAleuts(阿留申人)werenamedsobyRussians,buttheycallthemselvesUnanganwhichmeans"thepeople."Theyarenativeinhabit
随机试题
“炒鱿鱼”是()。
网络中防止病毒入侵的措施有()
A.硝酸酯类B.钙通道拮抗剂C.血管紧张素转换酶抑制剂D.β受体阻滞剂E.抗血小板制剂(2003年)对提高急性心肌梗死生存率无影响的是
A.渗湿止泻B.缓急止痛C.消食止泻D.活血消肿E.清热利湿小儿化毒散除清热解毒外,还可()。
深化投资体制改革的过程中,()在投资活动中占主体地位。
采用企业施工定额通过施工预算的编制而形成的成本计划属于()。
甲公司同意乙公司以其持有的某项长期股权投资偿还所欠的300万元货款,该长期股权投资中包括已宣告发放但尚未领取的现金股利5万元,市价280万元;甲公司应收乙公司账款的账面余额为300万元,已计提的坏账准备为10万元。甲公司取得该项股权投资时,额外从乙公司收取
下列关于品种法核算程序的会计表述中正确的有()。
如果党政机关多个单位联合开通一条服务热线,如群众打电话咨询一般性问题,要一次性解决。如咨询的是专业性问题。要在规定时间内解决。你认为在这个工作过程中的重点是什么?
在考生文件夹下打开WORDl.docx,按照要求完成下列操作并以该文件名(WORD1.docx)保存文档。【文档开始】硬盘的发展突破了多次容量限制;容量恐怕是最能体现硬盘发展速度的了,从当初IBM发布世界上第一款5MB容量的硬盘到现在,硬盘的容量已经达
最新回复
(
0
)