首页
外语
计算机
考研
公务员
职业资格
财经
工程
司法
医学
专升本
自考
实用职业技能
登录
考研
【F1】When Paul Krugman, a Nobel prize-winning economist, clashed with Niall Ferguson, a famous historian, over how best to respon
【F1】When Paul Krugman, a Nobel prize-winning economist, clashed with Niall Ferguson, a famous historian, over how best to respon
admin
2013-09-16
44
问题
【F1】
When Paul Krugman, a Nobel prize-winning economist, clashed with Niall Ferguson, a famous historian, over how best to respond to the economic crisis,Prof Ferguson’s response was humorously humble.
"A cat may look at a king," he wrote, "and sometimes a historian can challenge an economist. "
There has been some self-examination and soul-searching within the economics profession since the onset of the financial crisis.【F2】
Joseph Stiglitz, another Nobel prize-winning economist, has suggested that: "If science is defined by its ability to forecast the future, the failure of much of the economics profession to see the crisis coming should be a cause of great concern. "
Yet Prof Stiglitz’s conclusion is disappointingly mild: economists must simply search for new "paradigms" and then presumably go back into the business of scientific prediction.
For somebody educated as a historian, there is an obvious alternative conclusion to draw from Prof Stiglitz’s opening observation. And that is to conclude that the entire attempt to treat economics as a "science .. . defined by its ability to forecast the future" is misconceived.【F3】
The late Geoffrey Elton, a professor of modern history at Cambridge, argued that the function of the historian was to concentrate on the particular and the specific and to puncture the pretensions of social scientists, with their constant and futile effort to derive general, predictive laws from the study of the past.
In the current intellectual climate, it seems that Elton was saying something important. He was defending the empirical method and setting boundaries for what can be expected from the study of the past. Historians know that their work cannot be used to predict the future. History can suggest lessons and parallels and provide wisdom—but what it cannot do is provide a sociological equivalent of the laws of physics. Yet this seems to be the aspiration of many economists, who notoriously suffer from "physics envy".
Yet economists seem unlikely to abandon the belief that theirs is a discipline that makes "progress" and settles issues, in a way that resembles a hard science such as physics or chemistry.【F4】
Ben Bernanke, the current head of the Federal Reserve, exemplified this belief in a famous speech in 2004 on the "Great Moderation", in which he argued that there had been a "substantial decline in macroeconomic volatility", largely because of improved monetary policy, based on advances in economic thinking.
The subsequent financial and economic crash may have dented the confidence of some economists in particular tenets of their discipline.【F5】
But the Great Recession seems unlikely to dissuade many economists from the more fundamental belief that there are, indeed, predictive "laws" out there, just waiting to be discovered.
Rather than seeking to ape physicists, however, perhaps it is time for economists to learn a few lessons from history, or more precisely from historians.
【F3】
选项
答案
剑桥大学现代史已故教授杰弗里?埃尔顿主张,历史学家的角色是专注于特殊和特定的事情,戳破社会科学家的自命不凡,凭借持续而无用的努力,从对过去的研究中得出普遍而预见性的规律。
解析
转载请注明原文地址:https://kaotiyun.com/show/VbO4777K
0
考研英语一
相关试题推荐
WhichofthefollowingisNOTtrueaccordingtothetext?OnJayaAgrawal’swebsite,whatarethecommonresponsestothedocto
The"dawnofthedemocratizationoftheTVandfilmbusiness"probablymeans______.Samberg’ssolutionwasunconventionalbeca
Thesecondparagraphismeanttodemonstratethat______.CharlesClarkeasdescribedinthepassagewouldprobablyagreethat
WelearnfromthepassagethatBy"thependulumisswingingtoofar",IanPerryprobablymeans
Politicalcontroversyaboutthepublic-landpolicyoftheUnitedStatesbeganwiththeAmericaRevolution.(1)_____,evenbefore
TedKennedyismentionedinthefirstparagraphtoTheword"stoned"(line1,paragraph3)mostprobablymeans
Illiteracymaybeconsideredmoreasanabstractconceptthanacondition.WhenafamousEnglishwriterusedthe(1)_____overt
Illiteracymaybeconsideredmoreasanabstractconceptthanacondition.WhenafamousEnglishwriterusedthe(1)_____overt
Thehistoryofmodernpollutionproblemsshowsthatmosthaveresultedfromnegligenceandignorance.Wehaveanappallingtende
Medicalresearchersarepainfullyawarethattherearemanyproblems______(他们至今还没有答案).
随机试题
心尖搏动向左下移位见于
我国国家秘密的密级分为()三级。
下列关于成本和费用的表述中正确的是( )。
现阶段我国仍要发展轻纺产品出口,是因为其()。
随着企业规模的扩大和生产经营品种的增多,许多企业开始实行分权管理,以下关于分权管理的说法,正确的是()。
教师要求学生列举砖的用途,某学生在单位时间内列举出很多例证,但都在建筑材料范围之内,这表明该学生的发散思维在流畅性和变通性方面的特点是()。(2014年)
一位纳粹集中营的幸存者当上了美国一所中学的校长。每当有新教师来校报到,他都会交给新教师一封信,信上写着:“亲爱的老师,我是集中营的生还者。我亲眼看到人类所不应当见到的情景:毒气室由学有专长的工程师建造;儿童被学识渊博的医生毒死;幼儿被训练有素的护士杀害;妇
1911年的武昌起义掀起了辛亥革命的高潮,打开了清王朝的缺口。在一个月内,就有13个省以及上海和许多州县宣布起义,脱离清政府的统治。腐朽的清王朝迅速土崩瓦解。武昌起义具体组织者和发动者是
A、 B、 C、 D、 B
某类决策复杂,决策过程中受动态社会环境的约束,决策者只有有限的能力,且带有偏见。那么这类决策属于()。
最新回复
(
0
)