首页
外语
计算机
考研
公务员
职业资格
财经
工程
司法
医学
专升本
自考
实用职业技能
登录
考研
Are human genes patentable? It would seem a simple question. But it has been the subject of years of litigation, academic head-s
Are human genes patentable? It would seem a simple question. But it has been the subject of years of litigation, academic head-s
admin
2013-09-16
32
问题
Are human genes patentable? It would seem a simple question. But it has been the subject of years of litigation, academic head-scratching and thunderous debates between some executives who say such patents propel innovation and others who say they curb it. All this culminated today with a decision from the United States Supreme Court. In a unanimous decision, its answer is "no".
At issue are the patents held by Myriad Genetics, a company based in Utah, on two genes, BRCA1 and BRCA2. Mutations in these genes are linked to an inherited form of breast cancer. Myriad found the precise location of the genes on two chromosomes and sequenced them. The company’s patents have given Myriad the exclusive right to extract and isolate the two genes, administer tests for the mutations and create synthetic BRCA DNA.
Critics, led by the American Civil Liberties Union(ACLU), have argued that the patents are unconstitutional. America’s courts have long held that "laws of nature, natural phenomena and abstract ideas are not patentable", but are the "basic tools of scientific and technological work". Myriad and its allies countered that, in an era propelled by genomics, patents are necessary to drive future discovery.
The Supreme Court waded into this difficult debate in April, when it heard oral arguments from both sides. The justices searched for analogies to make the biological debate simpler, settling on two: a baseball bat and medicinal sap from an Amazonian leaf. The court ruled that Myriad’s patents are invalid. The ruling reads a bit like an elementary science lesson, explaining the structure of DNA. Its conclusion is similarly straightforward. The justices conceded that Myriad had "found an important and useful gene, but groundbreaking, innovative, or even brilliant discovery does not by itself satisfy" the patent law’s requirements for "new and useful. .. composition of matter". In sum, a "naturally occurring DNA segment is a product of nature and is not eligible for patenting merely because it has been isolated".
The court limited its ruling. It held that synthetic DNA may be patented, as urged by the federal government in an amicus brief. Furthermore, it explained; "Had Myriad created an innovative method of manipulating genes while searching for the BRCA1 and BRCA2 genes, it could possibly have sought a method patent. " The court also said that the ruling does not limit patents on new applications of knowledge about BRCA1 and BRCA2, nor does it stop the "patentability of DNA in which the order of the naturally occurring nucleotides has been altered. "
Myriad has yet to issue a statement. Lawyers at the ACLU were excited. "Today, the court struck down a major barrier to patient care and medical innovation," said the ACLUs Sandra Park. "Because of this ruling, patients will have greater access to genetic testing and scientists can engage in research on these genes without fear of being sued. "
It can be inferred from Paragraph 5 that the Supreme Court______.
选项
A、suggests Myriad to seek a method patent
B、determines to stop the patentability of genes
C、supports the patentability of isolated DNA segment
D、approves the patentability of genetic manipulation methods
答案
D
解析
第五段首句指出,法庭裁决留有余地。随后具体说明首句,指出法庭所规定的四种与基因相关的可专利主体:①合成DNA(synthetic DNA);②处理基因的新方法(an innovative method ofmanipulating genes);③对基因知识的新应用(new application…);④改变核甘酸基自然序列的DNA(the order of the naturally occurring…has been altered)。[D]选项符合法庭对②的肯定,故正确。
转载请注明原文地址:https://kaotiyun.com/show/s6O4777K
0
考研英语一
相关试题推荐
LoggingisnotbannedchieflybecauseWhichofthefollowingisareasonforthelegalizationofthehempplant?
Thegirlsinthenovel______.ThisnovelisattentivetoeachofthefollowingEXCEPT______.
Title:ShouldThereBeCompulsoryRetirementAge?TimeLimit:40minutesWordlimit:about200wordsYourcompositio
Ifyoususpectthattheillnessmightbeserious,youshouldnot______goingtothedoctor.
Theincreaseinglobaltrademeansthatinternationalcompaniescannotaffordtomakecostlyadvertisingmistakesiftheywantt
Customhasnotcommonlybeenregardedasasubjectofanygreatmoment.Itistheinnerworkingofownbrainsthatwefeelt
Afather’srelationshiptohischild’scurrentandfutureacademicsuccessandthelevelofhisorherdevelopmentinacademicp
Toavoidthevariousfoolishopinionstowhichmanisliable,nosuperhumangeniusisrequired.Afewsimpleruleswillkeepyou
Stopworryingaboutrecession.ThatisthemessagefromAmerica’sR-wordindex.Foreachquarter,we(1)_____howmanystonesin
InAugust,environmentalistsinthePhilippinesvandalizedafieldofGoldenRice,anexperimentalgrainwhosegeneshadbeenmo
随机试题
闭孔神经的前、后支走行于()
下列说法不正确的是()。
下列关于企业境外投资项目行政管理的表述,错误的是()。
当兴趣不是指向对某种对象的认识,而是指向某种活动时便成了()。
坚持党对公安工作绝对领导的途径之一是组织领导,其实现途径是()。
现行《宪法》规定,处理全国人大常委会的重要日常工作的机关是()。
处于现代化社会转型的中国,全社会的文化精神也在经历着跨世纪整合与提升。我们在目睹了大众文化所裹挟而来的媚俗、泛娱乐、煽情、快餐化等种种现象之后,应该深刻地反省大众文化的实践误区。人们如果一味沉湎于个体的声色之娱,就很容易导致人们对现实世界、公共领域一些重大
社会主义初级阶段的基本特征有()。
在进行子系统结构设计时,需要确定划分后的子系统模块结构,并画出模块结构图。该过程不需要考虑__________。
Whathappensifyoureleasetheodoroflavenderintoarestaurant?Incaseof【M1】______asmallshopinFrance,atleast
最新回复
(
0
)