首页
外语
计算机
考研
公务员
职业资格
财经
工程
司法
医学
专升本
自考
实用职业技能
登录
外语
Dr. Rablen and Dr. Oswald have just published a study which concludes that Nobel science laureates live significantly longer tha
Dr. Rablen and Dr. Oswald have just published a study which concludes that Nobel science laureates live significantly longer tha
admin
2015-07-27
41
问题
Dr. Rablen and Dr. Oswald have just published a study which concludes that Nobel science laureates live significantly longer than those of their colleagues who were nominated for a prize, but failed to receive one. They work with data from 1901 to 1950, and the search is restricted to men (to avoid differences in life span between the sexes), and those killed prematurely are eliminated. That gave them 135 prize winners and 389 also-rans.
The theory they were testing was that status itself, rather than the trappings of status, such as wealth, act to prolong life. This idea was first declared by Sir Michael Marmot, of University College, London. Sir Michael studied the health of British civil servants and discovered, contrary to his and everyone else’s expectations, that those at the top of the hierarchy — whom the stress of the job was expected to have affected adversely — were actually far healthier than the supposedly unstressed functionaries at the bottom of the heap. Subsequent research has confirmed this result, and suggested it is nothing to do with the larger salaries of those at the top. But Dr. Rablen and Dr. Oswald thought it would be interesting to refine the observation still further, by studying individuals who were all, in a sense, at the top. By comparing people good enough to be considered for a Nobel, they could measure what the status of having one was worth.
Comparing winners and also-rans from within the same countries, to avoid yet another source of bias, Dr. Rablen and Dr. Oswald found that the winners lived, on average, two years longer than those who had merely been nominated. Exactly what causes this increased longevity is unclear. It is not the cash, though. The inflation adjusted value of the prize has fluctuated over the years, so the two researchers were able to see if the purchasing power of the money was correlated with longevity. It was not.
With the hierarchically ordered individuals studied by Sir Michael and his successors, both medical records and experiments on animals suggest stress hormones are involved. It is, indeed, more stressful to be at the bottom than the top, even if being at the top involves making decisions on the fate of nations. The result Dr. Rablen and Dr. Oswald have come up with, though, suggests a positive effect associated with high status, rather than the absence of a negative effect, since unsuccessful nominees never know that they have been nominated.
A similar effect has been noted once before, in a different field. Research published a few years ago by Donald Redelmeier and Sheldon Singh showed that Oscar winning actors and actresses live 3.6 years longer than those who are nominated, but do not win. However, in that case the failed nominees do know that they have failed. And, curiously, Oscar winning scriptwriters live 3.6 years less than do nominees. Perhaps writers, unlike actors and scientists, live in a world of inverted snobbery.
What’s the difference between the two doctors’ study and that of Sir Michael’s?
选项
A、They demonstrate opposite findings.
B、They have different theoretical foundations.
C、They use different methods to select subjects.
D、They have different degrees of influence.
答案
C
解析
推理判断题。本题要求比较两位博士的研究与麦克爵士的研究的不同之处,因此可将信息定位于第二段。由该段第三句可知,麦可的研究对象既有位居高层的公务员,又有底层的公务员:而由该段倒数第二句可知,两位博士的研究对象只涉及“同样位居高层的人”。由此得出,[C]为两个研究的不同之处,为本题答案。同样从第二段可以得出,两个实验都验证了地位和长寿之间的关联,所以[A]错误;由第二段前两句可知,两位博士要验证的理论最初是由麦克爵士提出的,可见两者的理论基础相同,排除[B],文中并未比较两个实验的影响,故[D]属无中生有。
转载请注明原文地址:https://kaotiyun.com/show/0gOO777K
0
专业英语八级
相关试题推荐
Asthe20thcenturybegan,theimportanceofformaleducationintheUSincreasedThefrontierhadmostlydisappearedandin191
TheblackmanJimisacharacterinMarkTwain’s
Theexplorationofinternationalbusinessisanexciting,important,andnecessarytask.Internationalbusinessisexcitingbec
Educationalphilosophyhaschangedagreatdealinthe50yearssinceIwasinschool.Backthen,forexample,Ihadthehighe
1 Manypeopleseemtothinkthatsciencefictionistypifiedbythecoversofsomeoftheoldpulpmagazines;theBug-eyedMons
TheIELTSExamIELTS:InternationalEnglishLanguageTestingSystemI.Purposes:forimmigrationstatus,(1)______,applyingfor
Supposeyouaredrivingoffahighwaywiththreelanesgoinginyourdirectionandyoucomeuponatellplazawith.sixtollboo
Mostmenliveinharness.Richardwasoneofthem.Typicallyhehadnoawarenessofhowhismaleharnesswaschokinghimuntilh
Manytypically"American"characteristicsarearesultofvalue.【M1】______ThereisaremarkableethicdiversityintheUS.Amo
Manytypically"American"characteristicsarearesultofvalue.【M1】______ThereisaremarkableethicdiversityintheUS.Amo
随机试题
平和の尊さは誰もが________ほど語り継がれてきたはずなのに、まだまだ国際紛争の種は尽きない。
C语言中,唯一的三目运算符是_________。
在下面四条有关进程特征的叙述中,其中正确的一条是()。
灭火系统分为()系统。
砖砌沟墙时,应()。
以下不属于商用房贷款审查和审批中的风险的是()。
支持性心理治疗包括()。
现在人们日益关注“绿色增长”的概念。“绿色增长”的概念与“低碳经济”“循环经济”和“生态经济”等概念相比,它们的核心是一致的,倡导的都是一种经济社会与自然资源、生态环境全面协调和可持续发展的理念。差别只是视角和重点不同。低碳经济强调降低温室气体排放,循环经
数据字典包括______。①数据项②数据结构③数据流④数据存储⑤处理过程A)①②④⑤B)①②③⑤C)②③④⑤D)①②③④⑤
A、Cookmealsautomatically.B、Checkthestockautomatically.C、Goshoppinginsupermarket.D、Cleanroomautomatically.B本题问的是根据既
最新回复
(
0
)