首页
外语
计算机
考研
公务员
职业资格
财经
工程
司法
医学
专升本
自考
实用职业技能
登录
外语
Where does morality come from? Throughout the history of Western civilization thinkers have usually answered either that it come
Where does morality come from? Throughout the history of Western civilization thinkers have usually answered either that it come
admin
2015-01-09
79
问题
Where does morality come from? Throughout the history of Western civilization thinkers have usually answered either that it comes from God, or else through the application of reason.
But in The Bonobo and the Atheist, primatologist Frans de Waal argues that there’s another answer that fits the data better: morality comes from our evolutionary past as a social primate. Like our closest relatives, the apes, humans evolved in small, tightly knit, cooperative groups. As a result, again like the apes, we are exquisitely sensitive to one another’s moods, needs and intentions.
This well-developed empathy provided the trellis on which morality later flowered. De Waal, who is based at Emory University in Atlanta, Georgia, has been making this case eloquently for many years and over several books, notably in Good Natured back in 1997, and in Primates and Philosophers, 12 years later.
In his new work, he bolsters the argument by drawing on a lot of new research, carefully footnoted for those who want to dig deeper. De Waal distinguishes two degrees of morality. The first he calls "one-on-one morality", which governs how an individual can expect to be treated, and the second "community concern", a larger, more abstract concept that extends to the harmony of the group as a whole.
Chimps and bonobos certainly have the former—they respect ownership, for example, and expect to be treated according to their place in the hierarchy. But de Waal presents several examples—such as a chimp stepping in to stop a fight between two others—that suggest that they also have a rudimentary form of the latter.
The book’s title, incidentally, draws on bonobos because they are more likely than chimps to behave morally, to have concern for each other, to value harmony and so on. This, imagines, de Waal, is something morally inclined atheists would want to emulate. If humans inherited morality from our ancestors, though, what are we to make of religion? Here de Waal moves into the territory he has not explored before. Clearly, religion must do something important, since every human culture has it. But instead of religion giving us morality, de Waal turns the tables. Morality, he argues, probably gave us religion as a way of reinforcing the pre-existing community concern.
If he’s right, then there may be no absolute code of right and wrong out there to be discovered. Instead, each individual’s evolved sense of empathy and concern for the group may help shape the group’s consensus on what kind of behaviour is appropriate. In short, says de Waal, morality may be something we all have to work out together. It’s a persuasive argument, and de Waal’s cautious and evidence-based approach is one that many New Scientist readers are sure to find congenial.
That careful approach is less evident in another book covering some of the same ground. In How Animals Grieve, anthropologist Barbara King sets out to explore the question of whether non-human animals grieve for their dead. It’s an intriguing question, but unfortunately King’s book is largely a succession of anecdotes: the cat who roams the house, crying, in search of its dead litter mate; the dog who waits daily at the train station for its dead master; a dolphin trying to keep her dead calf afloat for days.
Some of these stories make a persuasive case for some animals—especially apes, elephants and cetaceans— sometimes grieving. No surprises there: I suspect most readers would have conceded that ground right from the start.
But King makes little effort to dig any deeper by exploring, for example, the neural machinery and cognitive skills an animal needs in order to be capable of grief. After all, solitary species such as cats have less need for empathy- and its corollary, grief—than social animals, and small-brained creatures such as turtles may simply lack the brainpower or not form lasting pair bonds.
To his credit, de Waal takes full note of such distinctions; King, not so much.
The author find Barbara King’s book
选项
A、persuasive.
B、surprising.
C、suspicious.
D、unconvincing.
答案
D
解析
推断题。由题干中的Barbara King’s book定位到第九、十段。第九段最后一句提到,Barbara King的书写的主要是一系列轶事,此外,第十段最后一句作者明确说他认为大多数读者会承认这本书从开始论述的就是一个既定的事实,总结这两处不难看出,作者认为Barbara King的书是没有说服力的,因此选择[D]。
转载请注明原文地址:https://kaotiyun.com/show/15dO777K
0
专业英语八级
相关试题推荐
AsmanyeducationreformsaretakingplacethroughoutChina,BeijingUniversitywentonestepfurtherandestablishedtheConfuc
LondonissteepedinDickensianhistory.Everyplacehevisited,everypersonhemet,wouldbedrawnintohisimaginationandre
LondonissteepedinDickensianhistory.Everyplacehevisited,everypersonhemet,wouldbedrawnintohisimaginationandre
LondonissteepedinDickensianhistory.Everyplacehevisited,everypersonhemet,wouldbedrawnintohisimaginationandre
IntroductoryLecturetoUniversityStudyInordertoadjustwelltouniversitylife,freshmenusuallyhavetounderstandthe
IntroductoryLecturetoUniversityStudyInordertoadjustwelltouniversitylife,freshmenusuallyhavetounderstandthe
IntroductoryLecturetoUniversityStudyInordertoadjustwelltouniversitylife,freshmenusuallyhavetounderstandthe
IntroductoryLecturetoUniversityStudyInordertoadjustwelltouniversitylife,freshmenusuallyhavetounderstandthe
随机试题
某产妇,26岁。临产17小时,阴道有少量淡绿色液体流出,宫缩25秒/6~8分,胎心音150次/分,肛查宫口开大2cm,宫颈轻度水肿,先露一2。根据产妇病情,不应进行哪项处理
政府增加购买性支出,对社会的生产和就业及国民收入分配的影响是()。【2008年真题】
2012年,黄山市全年接待海内外旅游者3641.3万人次,比上年增长19.2%。其中:接待国内旅游者3481.0万人次,增长19.1%;接待入境旅游者160.3万人次,增长22.0%。在入境旅游者中。外国人92.8万人次,增长21.6%;港澳台同胞67.5
()食物中毒可出现“肠源青紫症”。
实施幼儿德育最基本的途径是()。
材料1从2018年5月1日起,J市Z区进入为期6个月的汛期。为扎实做好防汛工作,保证抗洪抢险和救灾工作高效有序进行,最大限度地减少人员伤亡和财产损失,Z区成立了区防汛指挥部。区长任总指挥长,区各相关职能部门及各街道负责人为指挥部成员。办公室设在区
与2016年相比,2017年4个银行中,“利润总额”的增长率最大的银行是()。
道路交通事故是指车辆在道路上因过错或者意外造成的人身伤亡或者财产损失的事件。其中“道路”,是指公路、城市道路和虽在单位管辖范围但允许社会机动车通行的地方,包括广场、公共停车场等用于公众通行的场所。“车辆”,是指机动车和非机动车。“非机动车”,是指以人力或者
说明数组后,数组元素的初值是
Humanityusesalittlelessthanhalfthewateravailableworldwide.Yetoccurrencesofshortagesanddroughtsarecausingf
最新回复
(
0
)