首页
外语
计算机
考研
公务员
职业资格
财经
工程
司法
医学
专升本
自考
实用职业技能
登录
考研
When is it permissible to tell a lie? Never, according to Augustine and Kant. Machiavelli approved lying for princes, Nietzsche
When is it permissible to tell a lie? Never, according to Augustine and Kant. Machiavelli approved lying for princes, Nietzsche
admin
2019-09-15
31
问题
When is it permissible to tell a lie? Never, according to Augustine and Kant. Machiavelli approved lying for princes, Nietzsche for the exceptional hero—the Superman. Most other philosophers, and ordinary folk, are less certain, allowing some lies, but not others. After some 2,500 years of moral speculation, says Philosopher Sissela Bok, mankind is still trying to work out ground rules for acceptable lying.
1. Mental reservation as a type of lying.
In her new book, Lying, Bok traces the history of convoluted arguments on the subject. For instance, casuists invented the "mental reservation."
2. Casual lying frequently used in America.
Most norms on lying, Bok writes, grow out of elaborate moral systems of thought that "are often elegant in operation, noble in design. But when we have to make difficult concrete moral choices, they give us little help." In the absence of clear social guidelines, casual lying has become entrenched in America.
3. Lying accepted in academic circle.
Bok also argues that lying is now an accepted part of many professions, including law and the behavioral sciences.
4. Lying in journalism.
Bok sees problems in journalism too. Those lies reported on TV or newspapers, she maintains, were not clearly necessary and may encourage other reporters to use such tactics routinely. Reporters Bernstein and Woodward, however, seemed untroubled by "the whole fabric of deception".
5. Should political lies be approved?
By this standard, she argues, political lies are rarely justifiable. "If government duplicity is to be allowed in exceptional cases," Bok concludes, "the criteria for these exceptions should themselves be openly debated and publicly chosen. Otherwise government leaders will have free rein to manipulate and distort the facts." Then what kinds of lies should be permitted? Bok’s answer, only those approved in advance by the general public.
Bok feels that doctors should stop virtually all lying to patients, universities should root out fraudulent and deceptive research, and government officials should be expected to stick to the truth. Her point: the public is now so cynical about being lied to that only extraordinary efforts to avoid lying will restore a feeling of trust. Or, as Mark Twain once observed, "Always do right. This will gratify some people, and astonish the rest."
[A] For instance, they used to uncover the Watergate scandal.
[B] Social Psychologist Jerald Jellison estimates that the average American outstrips Pinocchio by telling 200 lies a day, including white lies and false excuses ("Sorry I’m late. I was tied up at the office").
[C] The use of unmarked police cars is one example of socially approved deception.
[D] For instance, Grotius said that speaking falsely to an intruder is not a lie. This, Bok suggests, would be something like knocking a man to the ground, then explaining that you did not hit him because he had no right to be there.
[E] In a typical experiment in social psychology, for example, a subject is misled about the aims of the study to see how he reacts under pressure.
[F] The phrase can be best interpreted by this example: "Mr. Smith is not in today"—a lie that is magically transformed into a truth by adding the unspoken thought "to you."
选项
答案
B
解析
小标题点明了本段主旨:美国人经常撒谎。各选项中,只有B提及美国人说谎的相关信息,其中的average American...telling 200 lies a day表明美国人说谎频繁,解释了文中说的“随口扯谎的行为已深深扎根于美国人的日常生活当中”(castral lying...entrenched...)。故选B。
转载请注明原文地址:https://kaotiyun.com/show/1j2Z777K
0
考研英语一
相关试题推荐
Theideaisasaudaciousasitaltruistic:provideapersonallaptopcomputertoeveryschoolchild—particularlyinthepoorestp
Researchonanimalintelligencealwaysmakesmewonderjusthowsmarthumansare.【B1】______thefruit-flyexperimentsdescribed
Thehumannoseisanunderratedtool.Humansareoftenthoughttobeinsensitivesmellerscomparedwithanimals,【B1】______this
Thehumannoseisanunderratedtool.Humansareoftenthoughttobeinsensitivesmellerscomparedwithanimals,【B1】______this
Thehumannoseisanunderratedtool.Humansareoftenthoughttobeinsensitivesmellerscomparedwithanimals,【B1】______this
Peopleare,onthewhole,pooratconsideringbackgroundinformationwhenmakingindividualdecisions.Atfirstglancethismigh
Peopleare,onthewhole,pooratconsideringbackgroundinformationwhenmakingindividualdecisions.Atfirstglancethismigh
Ifyouareamaleandyouarereadingthis,congratulations;youareasurvivor.Accordingtostatistics,youaremorethantwic
DespiteincreasedairportsecuritysinceSeptember11th,2001,thetechnologytoscanbothpassengersandbaggageforweaponsan
Restrictionsonthesmokinginpublicplaceshavenotbeensosuccessfulinsomeregions."Second-handsmoking"isgettingserio
随机试题
CO2气体保护横焊时,由于熔融金属受重力作用,焊缝的下侧易产生()缺陷。
心脏骤停早期诊断的最佳指标是
实心圆轴受扭,若将轴的直径减小一半时,则圆轴的扭转角是原来的()倍。
一个路段的监控系统是根据道路的特点、桥梁与隧道等大型构造物的分布、交通量以及()等因素来构架本路段的监控系统。
邮寄申报的实际申报日期应当为()。
下列关于货币政策的目标说法正确的是()。①货币政策作为总需求管理工具,在维护金融稳定方面具有一定局限性②货币中介目标选取的标准不同于操作目标③货币政策中介目标在是选取利率还是货币供应量上存在争议④操作目标的选择在很大程度上取决于
产权是对特定物的()并排除他人干涉的权利。
一战期间,陈独秀等人在上海出版的一份以青年为对象的刊物,发刊词中有这样的两句话:“笃古不变之族,日久衰亡;日新求进之旅,方兴未已。”作者“求变”主要针对:
Inanew【C1】________publishedinthejournalHeart,researchersfoundthatSwissadultswhotookoneortwodaytimenapsperwee
中国是世界上公认发明指南针的国家。早在2400多年前,中国人就创造出世界上最早的指南针。后来经过不断改进,到宋朝(theSongDynasty)人们制造出铁针指南针并应用于航海。中国是第一个在海船上使用指南针的国家。指南针为明代(theMingDy
最新回复
(
0
)