首页
外语
计算机
考研
公务员
职业资格
财经
工程
司法
医学
专升本
自考
实用职业技能
登录
外语
Why Depression Needs a New Definition [A]Many psychiatrists believe that a new approach to diagnosing and treating depression—li
Why Depression Needs a New Definition [A]Many psychiatrists believe that a new approach to diagnosing and treating depression—li
admin
2017-01-21
32
问题
Why Depression Needs a New Definition
[A]Many psychiatrists believe that a new approach to diagnosing and treating depression—linking individual symptoms to their underlying mechanisms—is needed for research to move forward. In his Aphorisms, Hippocrates defined melancholia(忧郁症), an early understanding of depression, as a state of "fears and losing courage, if they last a long time. " It was caused, he believed, by an excess of bile(胆汁)in the body(the word "melancholia" is ancient Greek for "black bile").
[B]Ever since then, doctors have struggled to create a more precise and accurate definition of the illness that still isn’t well understood. In the 1920s, the German psychiatrist Kurt Schneider argued that depression could be divided into two separate conditions, each requiring a different form of treatment: depression that resulted from changes in mood, which he called "inner depression" , and depression resulting from reactions to outside events, or " reactive depression". His theory was challenged in 1926, when the British psychologist Edward Mapother argued in the British Medical Journal that there was no evidence for two distinct types of depression, and that the apparent differences between depression patients were just differences in the severity of the condition.
[C]Today, Schneider’s subtypes have largely fallen out of favor, but over the years, many more definitions were offered in their place. In 1969, the American psychologist Rollo May wrote in his book Love and Will that " depression is the inability to construct a future," while the cognitive psychologist Albert Ellis argued in 1987 that depression, unlike "appropriate sadness" , stemmed from "irrational beliefs" that left sufferers ill-equipped to deal with even mild setbacks.
[D]In 1952, the American Psychiatric Association tried to standardize the definitions of mental illnesses, including depression, by creating a taxonomy(分类法)of mental illnesses. In the first edition of the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual, depression was listed under the broad category of " disorders without clearly defined physical cause". The DSM-III, published in 1980, was the APA’s first attempt to clarify the definitions of specific disorders by listing their symptoms: the new edition included guidelines for differentiating depression from other disorders, and outlined eight symptoms of depression, included "poor appetite or significant weight loss" and "complaints or evidence of diminished ability to think or concentrate". If an adult met four of the eight symptoms, the manual counseled, he or she would meet the criteria for clinical depression. In the DSM-V, published in 2013, depressive disorders were finally allocated their own chapter. The diagnostic criteria were mostly unchanged, with the exception of one additional symptom: " Depressed mood most of the day, nearly every day, as indicated by either subjective report(e. g. , feels sad or empty)or observation made by others(e. g. , appears tearful). "
[E]Some scientists believe that the DSM-V definition is still too vague. As the psychiatrist Daniel Goldberg noted in the journal World Psychiatry in 2011, many of the DSM symptoms are opposites, which can make it difficult for researchers working to develop a more precise understanding of the condition. " A patient who has psychomotor retardation(精神运动性阻滞), hypersomnia(嗜睡), and gaining weight is scored as having identical symptoms as another who is agitated, sleeping badly, and has weight loss," Goldberg wrote.
[F]Many recent studies have verified Goldberg’s concerns. In 2000, for example, a group of researchers at Johns Hopkins University attempted to identify subtypes of depression by studying the symptoms of nearly 2,000 patients. However, the researchers were unable to find much of a pattern connecting gender, family history, symptoms, and the degree of the condition(mild to severe). "Depression is of different kind," they concluded, adding that "the severity of an episode appears to be more informative than the pattern of symptoms. " And in 2010, researchers in Germany testing the validity of the DSM-IV definition found that the criteria captured a huge population of patients with "widely varying associations with the pattern of co-morbidity(共病), personality traits, features of the depressive episode and demographic characteristics. " The results, they argued, "challenge our understanding of major depression as a similar categorical entity. "
[G]Part of the problem, said Scott Monroe, a professor of psychology at the University of Notre Dame, is that in medical term, depression is considered a syndrome rather than a disease. While a disease is a specific condition characterized by a common underlying cause and consistent physical traits, a syndrome is a collection of signs and symptoms known to frequently appear together, but without a single known cause. In a paper published in June in the journal Current Directions in Psychological Science, Monroe called for scientists to begin defining depression with more precision. " It is in this vague and imprecise realm that problems can arise," he wrote, " and vague insights based on imperfect similarities and differences eventually may prove to be clear oversights. "
[H]Part of the reason that scientists are still working in the "vague and imprecise realm" , as Monroe put it, is because they still don’t have a clear answer for what causes depression. In the 1960s, the dominant hypothesis was that it stemmed from a chemical imbalance in the brain, specifically from lower levels of the neurotransmitter serotonin(血清素). As a result, drug companies poured resources into developing "selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors"(SSRIs), drugs that increased the amount of serotonin in the brain. SSRIs are still the most commonly prescribed type of antidepressant—despite the fact that research has shown that lower levels of serotonin do not necessarily cause depression for all individuals. And in 2010, a review of three decades’ worth of studies on antidepressants found that while SSRIs can be helpful for severely depressed people, their effectiveness "may be minimal or nonexistent" in those with mild or moderate depression.
[I]Bruce Cuthbert, the director of adult translational(平动)research and treatment development at the National Institute of Mental Health(NIMH), thinks that part of the problem is that researchers have largely focused their attention on finding a one-size-fits-all treatment that doesn’t exist. "When you do a clinical trial, you’re getting a bunch of people who are ’ depressed’ , but they’re actually very different," he said. " It’s like comparing apples, pears, and oranges. You’re not going to see a significant effect. You’re not going to be able to say, ’ This treatment works for fruits. ’" Trying to create a singular treatment for depression, Cuthbert said, is like trying to create one for cancer: too unspecific to actually be helpful. "Our current diagnostic system is running out of steam for research. " "While DSM has been described as a ’Bible’ for the field, it is, at best, a dictionary, creating a set of labels and defining each," the NIMH director Tom Insel wrote in 2013.
[J]In 2010, Insel invited Cuthbert, who was then working as a psychology professor at the University of Minnesota, to help the NIMH develop a new framework for defining mental illness. The result, unveiled in 2013, was the Research Domain Criteria(RDoC), a system created to flip the way researchers think about mental disorders. Unlike the DSM, RDoC isn’t organized by disorder: instead, it’s organized around specific symptoms, like fear, anhedonia(the inability to feel pleasure), and willingness or unwillingness to work. The system also lists the genes, neural circuits, physical response, and self-reported behavior associated with each symptom.
[K]The theory behind this RDoC system is that treating a specific symptom will produce better results than treating a broad category of illness. Many depression patients exhibit anhedonia, for example, but many others don’t. But if researchers took a group of patients who all displayed anhedonia, regardless of their diagnosis(it’s also a common symptom of schizophrenia)and tested treatments for that very specific symptom, they would get better results for treating anhedonia.
[L]The current definition of depression, Cuthbert explains, has largely stemmed from scientists observing patients and then developing lists of symptoms based on what they saw. " The belief was that if you described the disorder well enough, you would be able to define it," he said. But it’s becoming increasingly clear, he said, that by relying on describing the disorder, scientists are only slamming the surface in terms of understanding it. Cuthbert hopes that the RDoC system will challenge researchers to look at the mechanics of each symptom more closely, and in the process, come up with more well-informed ideas around how to diagnose mental illness. " We’re starting over with how we think about mental disorders," Cuthbert said. "Our current diagnostic system is running out of steam for research. " "Our current concept of depression is left over from times when we didn’t really understand it very much," he added. "We know so much more about it now—physically, genetically, neurochemically— and we should be using that. "
Scientists only scratch the surface of the problem in understanding depression because relying on mere description of the illness is insufficient.
选项
答案
L
解析
转载请注明原文地址:https://kaotiyun.com/show/4MF7777K
0
大学英语六级
相关试题推荐
Themostwell-knownportraitofawomanintheworldisoverthemoonliterally.RecentlyNASAmanagedto【B1】______animageoft
Amajoringredienttotakingthepainoutofastressfuldayatworkisasupportivepartnerathome,anewstudyhas【B1】_____.
A、Schoolsuseprivatedetectionservices.B、Teachersdiscussessaytopicswiththeirstudents.C、Teachersaskstudentstoturni
A、Explainmoretotheman.B、Payforthetrafficticket.C、Stopforshopping.D、Noticetheelectroniceye.B旅行交通类,行动计划题。女士解释说她只是
A、Shewillhaveadiscussionwiththosewhowanttobevolunteers.B、Shewillworkwithtrainingagenciestoimproveteachingsk
A、SheiseagertobeacceptedintotheUniversity.B、SheiswaitingtoseeifshecouldgetthejobfromIBM.C、Sheisexpecting
中国的农历(lunarcalendar),又称“夏历”,是中国传统历法之一,据说产生于夏代,迄今已有3000年的历史。农历实际上是一种阴阳合历(lunisolarcalendar),同时兼顾月亮和太阳的运行。农历的出现对中国农业和经济的发展产生了深远的
Forcenturiesmendreamedofachievingverticalflight.In400A.D.Chinesechildrenplayedwithafan-liketoythatspunupward
A、Helpherpreparethepresentation.B、Giveherextratimetofinishthereport.C、Givehersomeadviceondoingthereport.D、H
A、Tohaveathree-weekholiday.B、Tospendhisremainingyears.C、Topatenthisinventions.D、Toteachatauniversity.D对话结尾处提到
随机试题
在考生文件夹下的“samp1.accdb”数据库文件中已建立3个关联表对象(名为“职工表”、“物品表”和“销售业绩表”)、一个窗体对象(名为“fTest”)和一个宏对象(名为“mTest”)。请按以下要求,完成表和窗体的各种操作:将宏“mTest”重命
________分组级的主要功能是将链路层所提供的连接STE-DCE的一条或多条物理链路复用成数条逻辑信道,并且对每一条逻辑信道所建立的虚电路执行与链路层单链路协议类似的链路建立、数据传输、流量控制、顺序和差错检测、链路的拆除等操作。
陈力就列,不能者止。列:
36岁女性,孕4产2,2次剖宫产史,B型超声检查提示子宫畸形,双子宫。因有避孕需求来门诊咨询。患者服用去氧孕烯炔雌醇片的第一周出现恶心、呕吐和头晕等不适症状,前来门诊咨询。应采取下列哪些措施进行处理
女性,28岁,已婚。产前检查胎背位于母体腹部右侧,胎心位于右上腹,宫底可触及浮球物。诊断其胎位为
甲公司以库存商品A产品、B产品交换乙公司原材料,双方均将收到的存货作为库存商品核算,假定具有商业实质。甲公司另向乙公司支付补价45万元。甲公司和乙公司适用的增值税税率为17%,计税价值为公允价值,有关资料如下:甲公司换出:①库存商品—A产品:账面成本180
下列与会计估计审计相关的程序中,注册会计师应当在风险应对阶段实施的是()。
交易双方同意在将来的某一特定日期,按事先规定好的价格买入或售出既定数量的某种资产协议的金融工具,称之为(),它是一种场外交易。
简述学前儿童语言教育活动评价的原则。
服务人员提供服务于顾客时,也正是顾客消费服务的时刻,二者在时间上不可分离。这是指服务的()。
最新回复
(
0
)