首页
外语
计算机
考研
公务员
职业资格
财经
工程
司法
医学
专升本
自考
实用职业技能
登录
外语
Historian E. H Carr’s thesis that all debates concerning the explanation of historical phenomena revolve around “the question of
Historian E. H Carr’s thesis that all debates concerning the explanation of historical phenomena revolve around “the question of
admin
2020-03-28
78
问题
Historian E. H Carr’s thesis that all debates concerning the explanation of historical phenomena revolve around “the question of the priority of causes” is so familiar to historians as to constitute orthodoxy within their profession. The “true historian”, as Carr puts it, will feel a professional obligation to place the multiple causes of a historical event in a hierarchy by means of which the primary or ultimate cause of the event can be identified. In the Marxist mode of historical explanation (historical materialism), a universal hierarchy of causes is posited in which economic factors are always primary. In the classic, more widely accepted alternative ultimately derived from Weberian sociology, hierarchies of causes are treated as historically specific: explanatory primacy in any particular historical situation must be established by empirical investigation of that situation, not by applying a universal model of historical causation.
While the need to rank historical causes in some order of importance may seem obvious to most historians, such hierarchies raise serious philosophical difficulties. If any historical event is the product of a number of factors, then each of these factors is indispensable to the occurrence of the event. But how can one cause be “more indispensable” than another? And if it cannot, how can there be a hierarchy of indispensable causes? It was this problem that first led Weber himself to argue for the impossibility of any general formula specifying the relative importance of causes; we cannot, for example, conclude that in every capitalist society religious change has been more significant than economic change (or vice versa) in explaining the rise of capitalism.
Runciman offers a different argument leading to the same conclusion. He points out that it is possible to identify specific factors as the primary causes of a particular historical event only relative to an initial set of background conditions. For instance, if we accept English defeats after 1369 in the Hundred Years War as a given, then we may identify the high levels of taxation necessitated by these military reverses as the “main” cause of the Peasants Revolt of 1381. If instead we regard the financing of warfare by taxation in this period as a background condition, then we will see the English reverses themselves as the main cause of the revolt. However, neither ordinary life nor historical practice offer reliable criteria by which to distinguish causes from background conditions and thus to resolve historical debates about the relative importance of causes. And this difficulty casts doubt not only on the Marxist effort to identify a universal hierarchy of causes, but also on any attempt to identify an objective hierarchy of causes—even of the historically specific kind favored by non-Marxists.
Which of the following best describes the organization of the passage?
选项
A、An assumption is identified and called into question.
B、Opposing views are compared, contrasted, and shown to be compatible.
C、An argument is advanced, criticized, and then revised.
D、A theory is shown to be superior to its chief rival.
E、Similar arguments are shown to lead to different conclusions.
答案
A
解析
本题考查结构性主旨题,选择符合驳论文特征的选项即可,选项A正确。all assumption对应“可以排序”,后文全都是在反驳这一观点。B项opposing views可以认为是马克思和韦伯的观点,但是看不出可以融合。C项revised意味着有新观点,本文只是在批判老观点。D项不符,文章没提哪个观点优越于其他理论。
转载请注明原文地址:https://kaotiyun.com/show/4mVO777K
本试题收录于:
GRE VERBAL题库GRE分类
0
GRE VERBAL
GRE
相关试题推荐
Companiesthatadvertiseontelevisioncomplainthatdigitaltelevisionrecording(DTR)servicesmakeitpossibleforconsumers
Anagriculturalcooperativewantstosellmoreofitslesspopularvegetables,zucchiniinparticular.Aconsultanthassuggeste
WhenA.PhilipRandolphassumedtheleadershipoftheBrotherhoodofSleepingCarPorters,hebeganaten-yearbattletowinrec
Itwasonceassumedthatalllivingthingscouldbedividedintotwofundamentalandexhaustivecategories.Multicellularplants
Opponentsoflawsthatrequireautomobiledriversandpassengerstowearseatbeltsarguethatinafreesocietypeoplehavethe
Asociety’sinfantmortalityrateisanacceptedindicatorofthatsociety’sgeneralhealthstatus.Eventhoughinsomelocaliti
Someanthropologistsstudymodern-daysocietiesofforagersinanefforttolearnaboutourancientancestorswhowerealsofora
AneditorialintheGrandburyDailyHeraldclaimsthatGrandburg’svoterswouldgenerallywelcomethedefeatofthepoliticalp
Forsomebirdsthesenseofsmellappearstoplayaroleinnavigation,sincepigeonswithsurgicallyremovedolfactorynervesw
Toooldtobeararmshimself,FriederickDouglassservedasarecruitingagent,traveledthroughtheNorthtoexhortBlackment
随机试题
小儿每日补充生理需要,所需液量
法国戴高乐政府时期的广播电视事业属于()
A、腰骶段脊髓B、延髓C、大脑皮质D、下丘脑E、杏仁核排便反射的最高级中枢位于
某砖混结构二层住宅(平面图a、b、c),基础平面图见图a,基础剖面图见图b,首层平面图见图c,二层平面图见图4;外墙墙身高5.88m室外地坪标高为-0.2m;设混凝土基础与灰土垫层施工均不留工作面,人工挖沟槽从灰土垫层下表面开始放坡,土质为二类土,放坡系数
2016年10月,A公司(房地产开发企业)转让开发的办公楼项目,共取得收入30000万元。A公司按照国家税法的规定缴纳了相关税费1650万元。已知A公司为取得该项目土地使用权支付的地价款和按照国家规定缴纳的有关费用为5000万元;该项目房地产开发成本为70
关于我国反垄断法的适用范围,以下说法正确的是()。
【2016上】下列不属于发生在法国大革命时期的大事的是()。
粮食作物不包括()。
作为一个新老师,你会如何向老教师请教呢?
HowtoSolvetheRubbishProbleminCities?
最新回复
(
0
)