首页
外语
计算机
考研
公务员
职业资格
财经
工程
司法
医学
专升本
自考
实用职业技能
登录
外语
Every individual in a society has a responsibility to obey just laws and to disobey and resist unjust laws. Write a response in
Every individual in a society has a responsibility to obey just laws and to disobey and resist unjust laws. Write a response in
admin
2017-11-13
98
问题
Every individual in a society has a responsibility to obey just laws and to disobey and resist unjust laws.
Write a response in which you discuss the extent to which you agree or disagree with the claim. In developing and supporting your position, be sure to address the most compelling reasons and/or examples that could be used to challenge your position.
选项
答案
Throughout history the conflict between one’s own judgment and the judgment of the lawmakers has given rise to many conflicts, wars and revolutions. In that context, the claim that individuals should follow their own sense of righteousness by opposing laws that are in their opinion unfair and following laws that are fair is justified. Since individual judgment is subjective, however, I cannot completely agree with the claim. One of the negative consequences of blindly following a state’s laws becomes clear when one considers authoritarian, ideologically extreme and fundamentalist countries. It is highly likely that power-hungry and oppressive governments like Nazi Germany are not founded on and buttressed by the most ethical laws. For example, when my grandfather was stationed with the German army in the Czech Republic in 1945, he was tasked with executing five Czech partisans. As a soldier, he should have followed orders and could have been sent to prison or executed himself if he disobeyed. He managed to convince his superior that his pistol was rusty and would not fire and thereby saved the lives of the partisans by disobeying a direct order. When a state’s laws are in conflict with basic human codes of ethics, therefore, it becomes clear that one should disobey orders. Not all laws, however, violate human rights, so the decision to follow or oppose them is not black and white. In some cases a subjective sense of what is right might actually oppose a collective sense of what is right. For instance, I remember arguing with my parents while in 5th grade in school that, based on my antipathy towards school at the time, I had a right to freedom and should not be obliged to go to school. In fact, going to school is required by law in Germany, and I was arguing to break the law based on my own set of principles and rights. Since a sense of righteousness can be subjective, it is sometimes reasonable to accept laws that benefit the whole of society as well as the individual - even if the individual is not willing to accept that as a universal truth. I furthermore can’t completely agree with the claim with respect to the statement that society should obey "just" laws. There are certainly circumstances in which a whole society’s sense of right and wrong has been manipulated by years of propaganda. Consider the law passed in 1939 by Nazi Germany labeled the"Endloesung" i.e., the final solution. That law deprived Jewish people of any human rights and set the scene for the holocaust. Through years of brainwashing, a large proportion of German society accepted that law and actually believed that Jews were an inferior race. Therefore, depending on the circumstances and the manipulative powers of a regime, even laws that appear just to some are utterly appalling to humanity as a whole. Hence, the subjective nature of right or wrong does not only vary from person to person but is also subject to manipulation and deceit. For this reason I cannot agree with the claim completely. In conclusion, therefore, there are situations, such as when laws clearly oppose basic human rights, in which the claim is true and useful. However, an individual’s interpretation of what is right is often subjective and vulnerable to biased influences by powerful regimes. Therefore the truth of the claim is limited.
解析
This response presents a cogent, well-articulated analysis of the issue in accordance with the specific task directions. Each paragraph contributes significant analytical reasoning to support the nuanced position that while resistance to authority is obviously justified in the most clear-cut cases, a sense of justification can be too subjective to be reliable not only in a personal sense but also on a societal scale, as when entire populations become deluded. In presenting that analysis, the writer takes a position that one must disobey unjust laws(second paragraph)and obey those that are just(third paragraph). But, in accordance with the task direction to address any compelling reasons and/or examples that could be used to challenge one’s position, the writer also recognizes a counterargument to his/her position in instances when people neither resist nor disobey unjust laws(fourth paragraph), particularly when they are "subject to manipulation and deceit." Furthermore, the examples and reasons are both compelling and persuasive as in the dramatic case of the Nazi soldier finding a way to disobey orders even though he "should" have followed them to save his own life. The response conveys ideas fluently and precisely via effective vocabulary and syntax, as in this example: "Therefore, depending on the circumstances and the manipulative powers of a regime, even laws that appear just to some are utterly appalling to humanity as a whole. Hence, the subjective nature of right or wrong does not only vary from person to person but is also subject to manipulation and deceit." For its well-articulated, cogent analysis of the issue, this response earns a score of 6.
转载请注明原文地址:https://kaotiyun.com/show/6HkO777K
本试题收录于:
GRE ANALYTICAL WRITING题库GRE分类
0
GRE ANALYTICAL WRITING
GRE
相关试题推荐
IftheDakotaAccessPipeline(输油管道)iscompleted,itwillcarrynearlyhalfamillionbarrelsofoilacrossfourstateseveryd
TheCalifornialawmakersvotedThursdaytoraisethelegalagetobuytobaccoproductsfrom18to21.Themeasureispartofal
Increasingly,overthepasttenyears,people—especiallyyoungpeople—havebecomeawareoftheneedtochangetheireatinghabit
Directions:Forthispart,youareallowed30minutestowriteacompositiononthetopic"HowtoHandleStress?"Youshouldwr
Scientistsmeasuredtheimpactthatpeoplehaveontheenvironmentusingatermcalledcarbon"footprint."Thatfootprintrefle
Itcanbereallyfrustrating(使人沮丧的)foranoverweightpersontogotoagymandworkoutwithapositiveattitude.Allonehasto
Inanoldtownlivedamerchant.Heearnedhugeprofitsbyfairmeansandfoul(恶劣的).Withmoreprofitsflowingin,hebecamemor
Caraccidentskillmorethanonemillionpeopleandinjureapproximately50millioneachyear.【C1】______,millionsoffishcans
Visitorstothezoousuallypitytheanimalsowingtotheirparticularemotionalassociations(联想).Whichanimalsshouldbeindee
Ifxandyareoddintegers,whichofthefollowingmustalwaysbeanon-integer?
随机试题
首先提出目标管理的是()
男,30岁,上腹疼痛3小时。其于晚餐后突发上腹剧痛,迅速波及全腹,伴恶心、呕吐。查:腹稍胀,全腹有肌紧张、压痛和反跳痛,以上腹为重。叩诊肝浊音界消失,听诊肠鸣音弱。化验:白细胞15.2×109/L,中性粒细胞85%,淋巴细胞15%。最可能的诊断是
心理应激对健康影响的生理机制是
肾阳虚带下过多的治法是()
在项目管理组织体系中,不属于直接管理子系统的是()。
按照国外建安工程费用的构成,下列费用中,不属于单项工程开办费的是()。
下列关于项目融资的特点,说法错误的是()。
若2005年有其他因素不变,要实现目标利润总额,固定成本总额应降为( )若2005年经过努力使变动成本率比2004年降低20%,且其他因素不变,则2005年盈亏临界点销售量为( )件
《全国国土规划纲要(2016─2030年)》指出,我国国土面临的严峻挑战有()。①资源约束不断加剧②生态环境压力加大③国土空间开发格局亟需优化④国土开发质量有待提升
HowdoesSerkis’versiondifferfromtheoriginalone?
最新回复
(
0
)