首页
外语
计算机
考研
公务员
职业资格
财经
工程
司法
医学
专升本
自考
实用职业技能
登录
外语
One of the principal of Walzer’s critique of liberal capitalism is that it is insufficiently egalitarian. Walzer’s case against
One of the principal of Walzer’s critique of liberal capitalism is that it is insufficiently egalitarian. Walzer’s case against
admin
2015-10-21
55
问题
One of the principal of Walzer’s critique of liberal capitalism is that it is insufficiently egalitarian. Walzer’s case against the economic inequality generated by capitalism and in favor of "a radical redistribution of wealth" is presented in a widely cited essay entitled In Defense of Equality.
The most striking feature of Walzer’s critique is that, far from rejecting the principle of reward according to merit, Walzer insists on its validity. People who excel should receive the superior benefits appropriate to their excellence. But people exhibit a great variety of qualities— "intelligence, physical strength, agility and grace, artistic creativity, mechanical skill, leadership, endurance, memory, psychological insight, the capacity for hard work—even moral strength, sensitivity, the ability to express compassion. "Each deserves its proper recompense and hence a proper distribution of material goods should reflect human differences as measured on all these different scales. Yet, under capitalism, the ability to make money("the green thumb of bourgeois society")enables its possessor to acquire almost "every other sort of social goods" such as the respect and esteem of others.
The centerpiece of Walzer’s argument is the invocation of a quotation from Pascal’s Pensees, which concludes;"Tyranny is the wish to obtain by one means what can only be had by another. " Pascal believes that we owe different duties to different qualities. So we might say that infatuation is the proper response to charm, and awe the proper response to strength. In this light, Walzer characterizes capitalism as the tyranny of money(or of the ability to make it)and Walzer advocates as the means of eliminating this tyranny and of restoring genuine equality"the abolition of the power of money outside its sphere". What Walzer envisions is a society in which wealth is no longer convertible into social goods with which it has no intrinsic connection.
Walzer’s argument is a puzzling one. After all, why should those qualities unrelated to the production of material goods be rewarded with material goods? Is it not tyrannical, in Pascal’s sense, to insist that those who excel in "sensitivity" or "the ability to express compassion" merit equal wealth with those who excel in qualities(such as "the capacity for hard work")essential in producing wealth? Yes. Walzer’s argument, however deficient, does point to one of the most serious weaknesses of capitalism—namely, that it brings to predominant positions in a society people who, no matter how legitimately they have earned their material rewards, often lack those other qualities that evoke affection or admiration. Some even argue plausibly that this weakness may be irremediable: in any society that, like a capitalist society, seeks to become ever wealthier in material terms disproportionate rewards are bound to flow to the people who are instrumental in producing the increase in its wealth.
The author implies that sensitivity is a quality that______.
选项
A、is not essential in producing wealth
B、can be sensibly measured on a scale
C、characterizes tyrannical people
D、deserves much more wealth
答案
A
解析
推断题一末段第三句和第四句指出,如果按帕斯卡尔的意思坚持认为那些擅长于“敏感”和“善于表达怜悯之心”的人应获取与那些更具有在物质财富创造过程中所不可或缺的品质(诸如“勤奋工作的能力”)的人同等的物质财富,同样是专制暴政。可见,作者认为敏感不是创造物质财富不可或缺的品质.故[A]为答案。帕斯卡尔认为敏感的人应该获取同样的财富,这与作者的观点不符,故排除[D];文章没有提到或暗示敏感度是可以衡量的,或是残暴者的特征,故排除[B]和[C]。
转载请注明原文地址:https://kaotiyun.com/show/DXKO777K
0
专业英语八级
相关试题推荐
MoneyinAmericaMoneyisusedtobuygoodsorservicesand【1】______debts. 【1】_________InAmerica,moneysupplycon
Self-discipline:theFoundationofProductiveLivingI.Issuestobenoticedatthethoughtofself-disciplineATroublesforso
Self-discipline:theFoundationofProductiveLivingI.Issuestobenoticedatthethoughtofself-disciplineATroublesforso
Theliberalviewofdemocraticcitizenshipthatdevelopedinthe17thand18thcenturieswasfundamentallydifferentfromthato
Moderatedrinkingreducesstrokerisk,studyconfirms.Similartothewayadrinkortwoadayprotectsagainstheartattacks,m
LiteratureandLifeInareactionagainstatoo-rigid,over-refinedclassicalcurriculum,someeducationalphilosophershave
Humanbeingsinalltimesandplacesthinkabouttheirworldandwonderattheirplaceinit.Humansarethoughtfulandcreativ
Humanbeingsinalltimesandplacesthinkabouttheirworldandwonderattheirplaceinit.Humansarethoughtfulandcreativ
Humanbeingsinalltimesandplacesthinkabouttheirworldandwonderattheirplaceinit.Humansarethoughtfulandcreativ
随机试题
药品的每张处方不得超过
舌下神经【】
对第8对颅脑神经有损害作用,可引起不可逆耳聋的药物是
房屋租赁代理业务的特点有()。
ClearPlus公司生产和销售口袋保护器。5月份静态预算值和实际值如下所示:关于ClearPlus公司5月份的实际业绩,以下哪项陈述是正确的?
人力资源管理始终贯彻员工是组织的宝贵财富的主题,强调对人的关心爱护,把人真正作为资源加以保护利用,即采取()。
根据下面的表格。回答73-76题。根据上表,可以判断2005年区域城市人均可支配收入最高的是()。
有人问吴孟超,你拿了那么多第一,拥有那么多头衔,获得那么多荣誉,你这一生值了。老人家回答说,是啊,就我的人生来讲,这些东西确实够多了。但是要说“值”,它究竟值在哪里?我想最重要的是,它凝聚着祖国和人民的需要。作为一个知识分子,只有把个人的发展与祖国和人民的
计算机网络的功能有很多,以下不属于其主要功能的是()。
InEngland,afternoontea,takenbetweenfourandfive,isthemost(11)mealoftheday.Ifyouareafriendofthefamily,you
最新回复
(
0
)