首页
外语
计算机
考研
公务员
职业资格
财经
工程
司法
医学
专升本
自考
实用职业技能
登录
外语
We must Train People to Break the Rules [A]Lay out the entrails, read omens and auguries, study the heavens, shake your hoary lo
We must Train People to Break the Rules [A]Lay out the entrails, read omens and auguries, study the heavens, shake your hoary lo
admin
2013-11-12
11
问题
We must Train People to Break the Rules
[A]Lay out the entrails, read omens and auguries, study the heavens, shake your hoary locks like an ancient seer. Signs and portents bring us messages, and we should heed them ere civilization crumbles.
[B]Off Hope Cove, on the Devon coast, a crew of strong, experienced men has saved a girl’s life with minutes to spare, only to find itself "disciplined" because the only boat available was classified as an "additional facility awaiting inspection". Earlier and farther inland, see two more strong men standing helpless in their luminous Police Community Support uniforms, wittering into radios because they lacked the correct certificates to try to rescue a drowning boy.
[C]Elsewhere, a coastguard resigned after saving a 13-year-old dangling from a cliff. He failed to fetch and buckle on his own safety harness, and immediately found himself in trouble from bosses droning that they "don’t want dead heroes".
[D]Meanwhile a thousand small habitual practices — from cake stalls to carpentry classes — find themselves under heavy reproof and restraint. And in a hospital ward somewhere a dying, frail old man repeatedly falls out of bed because nurses reckon that they can’t put up the sides of the bed without a "risk assessment", in case they breach his "human rights" and "unlawfully imprison" him.
[E]A frantic family tries to get a telephone line reconnected to a remote Welsh hillside where a man has had a stroke, and meet only call-centre shrugs because they don’t have the account number off the bill; a neighbor phones the weekend "on-call" doctor service about an ailing nonagenarian neighbor, to be told by the doctor that nothing can be done until they give the victim’s correct postcode and date of birth.
[F]An amateur dramatic group has to find lock-up storage for two plastic toy swords; and in Huddersfield, citizens have to barricade the road before Binmen will take away rubbish bags that didn’t fit correctly into the wheelie bins, although the surplus is entirely due to the said Binmen having been on strike and omitting the last collection.
[G]From distant California, thanks to Times online message boards, comes the echo of a voice from the Ancient World. Jim from El Centro responded to the Hope Cove rescue story at the weekend with a quotation from Marcus Tullius Cicero: "A bureaucrat is the most despicable of men, though he is needed as vultures are needed, but one hardly admires vultures, which bureaucrats so strangely resemble. I have yet to meet a bureaucrat who was not petty, dull, almost witless, crafty or stupid, an oppressor or a thief, a holder of little authority in which he delights, as a boy delights in possessing a vicious dog. Who can trust such creatures?"
[H]Something is wrong. We read too many stories about this craven, inhuman, poltroonish cowering behind rules and routines, and about individuals who get into trouble for momentarily breaching them in the name of humanity or sense. I take issue with Cicero and Jim a little, though — it is too easy to rage at bureaucracy itself and join in thoughtless jeering at "suits". Even Cicero accepts that efficient administration is necessary: it gets things done and distributed, and is a bulwark against chaos. So I think we have to choose our targets more carefully, and unpick more precisely the evil threads that make us so uneasy and unhappy and desperate to stick to rules in defiance of common sense and kindness.
[I]I would diagnose it as insecurity, linked to a misunderstanding of the concept of "training"(which, incidentally, links straight back to the culture of unintelligent testing in schools). Depressed, anxious people always prefer to stick to rules rather than think for themselves; at the extreme they lapse into obsessive-compulsive disorder, forever washing their hands and touching wood. Depressed, anxious institutions such as the Maritime and Coastguard Authority, National Health Service management(and quite a few call centers)display this pathology on a corporate level. You get the "training", tick the right multiple-choice boxes and refuse to think that there might be another choice, not listed. You feel safer that way, like a troubled child determined not to color outside the lines.
[J]Yet this is the opposite of real training, as practised for years in real armies, navies, laboratories and institutions. Real training lays down a framework of expertise and safety not to prevent initiative, but to free it. If you really know the rules and understand their purpose, you can judge when to make an exception and break them.
[K]A nurse should be able to think(as some no doubt do): "Right, the patient is confused and rolling about, and might get hurt, I’ll put up the sides of the bed and keep an eye on things, and have a word with the relatives later to explain."
[L]The boat crew should feel free to think(as they did): "The big lifeboat isn’t going to be in time, we know our own boat’s safe even though it hasn’t got the certificate yet, and if we do get into trouble it’s worth a try to save a life — go for it!" The dustmen should say: "OK, so there are bags lying beside the wheelie bins in contravention of council regulations, but that’ll be because of the strike, isn’t it? Chuck them in."
[M]The NHS or telecom call-centre staff should be alert not only to the list of correct procedures on the wall, but to the note of panic in the distant voice.
[N]Employees should be allowed to be people too; and a good bureaucrat should feel safe to judge which value scored highest at the critical moment. We all see examples of this gentle accommodation every day. But we also know that those who break small rules for human values run a real risk, because of that corporate anxiety and depression. It is brought on by soulless micromanagement from the top and a culture that assumes the citizen is a moron. Keeping the balance is not always easy: but hell, human life is a tightrope and always has been. Certainly the reckless rule-breakers should be curbed or sacked; but so should the stupidly rigid bureaucrats.
[O]Can’t leave you on that gloomy note. So rejoice: 125 miles out in the dark North Sea, in the excellent Tall Ships Race, 13 crew(mainly teenage)have just been rescued from the flooded cutter Clyde Challenger by the(mainly teenage)crew of a fellow-competitor, the Norwegian ketch Loyal. I am sure that they all obeyed the rules: perish the thought that they wouldn’t. But if they had to break a few, good luck to them.
Instead of thinking for themselves, the depressed, anxious people prefer to stick to rules.
选项
答案
I
解析
根据题目中的the depressed,anxious people将本题出处定位于[I]段第2句,该句中的prefer to…rather than…意为“宁可坚守原则,也不自己思考”表明,depressed,anxiouspeople更倾向于stick to rules。题目基本上是对该句的复现,只是将rather than…改为了instead of…。
转载请注明原文地址:https://kaotiyun.com/show/Ds17777K
0
大学英语六级
相关试题推荐
Bycontrast,Americanmothersweremorelikely______(把孩子的成功归因于)naturaltalent.
HumanNetworkingIknew,nocomputerortechnologyevergotanyofusaraise,landedusthatdreamjob,foundusthatmento
A、Buysomenewbooks.B、Changethelibrariansthere.C、Checkallthecardsandreprintthemwherenecessary.D、Changethelibrar
Asawisemanoncesaid,weareallultimatelyalone.ButanincreasingnumberofEuropeansarechoosingtobesoataneverear
OurculturehascausedmostAmericanstoassumenotonlythatourlanguageisuniversalbutthatthegestureweuseisunderstoo
Everyculturehasitsownbodylanguage,andchildrenabsorbitsnuancesalongwiththespokenlanguage.AFrenchmantalksandm
A、Pollutionproblem.B、Populationproblem.C、Unemploymentproblem.D、Nuclearweaponproblem.D细节题。谈话开始,男士说Areyougoingtothed
A、0.291667B、0.298611C、0.3125D、0.326389B推理判断题。选项表明对话内容与谈论时间有关。对话中女士开始说,如果现在出发的话,我们有没有足够的时间赶上7:30的火车,男士回答No,it’stoolate.It’s
A、Hisfirstapplicationwillnotbere-evaluated.B、Hewillhavetore-applythefollowingyear.C、Hisfamily’sfinancialcondit
随机试题
正确的刷手范围是
程序正当是行政法的基本原则。下列哪些选项是程序正当要求的体现?(2012年卷二第77题)
生产经营单位发生安全事故的时候,单位的主要负责人不应当做的是()。
某住宅小区委托甲物业公司进行物业管理,甲物业公司委托乙市政公司对小区内的污水区、化粪池、隔油池等进行定期清理。根据《有限空间安全作业五条规定》(国家安全生产监督管理总局令第69号),乙市政公司以下做法中,正确的是()。
汇款人签发汇兑凭证时,必须记载的事项有( )。
某企业拟购买一项新技术,两年前类似技术交易转让价格为50万元,经专家评估,该技术比两年前类似技术会更好,技术经济性能修正系数为1.3,时间修正系数为1.1,技术寿命修正系数为1.2,根据市场模拟模型,该企业购买该技术的评估价格为()万元
企业为达到预定的销售量,采用各种沟通手段或沟通工具的组合是()。
中国古代哲学家陆象山主张“宇宙是吾心,吾心便是世界”是()。
给定资料1.中国人讲究礼尚往来,逢年过节来往走动,互赠礼物,互祝安康,也是美好情谊的表达。特别是在结婚这样的喜事上更是讲究礼尚往来。操办婚礼无可厚非,但是动辄十几万甚至几十万的彩礼、几百几千的份子钱,亲朋好友连吃多天的婚宴酒席等大操大办、铺张浪费的不良风
Whatdoesitmeantobeintelligent?Mostpsychologistsagreethatabstractreasoning,problemsolving,andtheabilitytoacqui
最新回复
(
0
)