首页
外语
计算机
考研
公务员
职业资格
财经
工程
司法
医学
专升本
自考
实用职业技能
登录
考研
A supposed pillar of the US capitalist vigour has been revealed in all its degeneration. That pillar is the US patent system, wh
A supposed pillar of the US capitalist vigour has been revealed in all its degeneration. That pillar is the US patent system, wh
admin
2014-06-25
53
问题
A supposed pillar of the US capitalist vigour has been revealed in all its degeneration. That pillar is the US patent system, which has allowed Apple to extract $lbn from Samsung in compensation for alleged theft of intellectual property. Americans reasonably worship property rights and unreasonably extend this attitude to intellectual property rights, conflating "rival" goods like homes and hamburgers, which cannot be shared costlessly, with "non-rival" intellectual products that can be enjoyed simultaneously by all. Likewise, Americans worship innovation and presume that intellectual property rights always promote it. But this presumption is wrong.
The poster child for patents is the pharmaceuticals industry. But, as Richard Posner, a federal appeals court judge, has argued, what works in this sector is not necessarily appropriate in communications, software or elsewhere. Bringing a new drug to market is extremely expensive, mainly because of the need for large clinical trials. Monopoly rights over new drugs provide a needed spur to invention. And because trials take as long as a decade, the 20-year exclusivity typically granted can mean only 10 years of monopoly profits.
The technology industry is different. No clinical trials are needed, so costs of development are lower and the case for monopoly weaker. Certainly, 20-year exclusivity cannot be justified. But as Michele lioldrin and David Levine observe in a new paper, the right policy for Silicon Valley might be to grant no patents whatsoever. Technology innovators are amply rewarded by the first-mover advantage.
If the need for monopoly incentives in the tech industry is doubtful, the cost of granting them is clear. Whereas a drug patent covers one independent product, a technology patent typically covers a building block of a product, such as the look of the icons on a touch screen, to cite one of Apple’s complaints against Samsung. By patenting such building blocks, tech groups prevent rivals from using yesterday’s inventions to create tomorrow’s improved ones. Rather than spurring progress, patents can trip it up.
Some patents are kept deliberately low-profile in hopes that deep-pocketed companies will violate them unknowingly, at which point patent holders pounce. Last year US companies spent about $29bn fending off raids from "non-practising entities", also known as patent trolls, litigators who own bundles of patents with no intention of using them to build products.
In a better world, the US Patent and Trademark Office would take care not to approve frivolous and overlapping applications. But its examiners are swamped. The US has made modest efforts to rein in this excess. But the US has a long way to go before attaining sanity. Some observers believe that the patent system should be abolished outright. But you don’t have to go that far to see that there are grounds for worry. Americans labour under an illusion that their lawyers’ paradise is good for innovation. They could hardly be more wrong.
Apple’s extraction $ lbn from Samsung is mentioned here to show______.
选项
A、the harsh punishment for theft of intellectual property
B、the vitality of US patent system in American capitalism
C、the illusion of the US patent system as a spur to invention
D、the commercial exploitation of property rights
答案
C
解析
首段首先指出:美国专利制度衰落了;继而列举苹果VS三星案例;随后进行分析:美国人对产权的崇拜延伸到知识产权领域,认为知识产权有助创新;而作者最后明确指出:这种观念是错误的。可见,首段作者意在引出知识产权不一定利于创新,美国专利制度激励创新是个假象,而根据例子服务中心论点原则,[C]选项最符合作者例证目的。
转载请注明原文地址:https://kaotiyun.com/show/EFK4777K
0
考研英语一
相关试题推荐
Self-esteemiswhatpeoplethinkaboutthemselves—whetherornottheyfeelvalued—andwhenfamilymembershaveself-respect,
Untilthelate1940swhentelevisionbeganfindingitswayintoAmericanhomes,companiesreliedmainlyonprintandradiotopr
Computershavebecomeanextensionofus:thatisacommonplacenow.Butinanimportantwaywemaybebecominganextensionof
(46)In1798ThomasRobertMalthusfamouslypredictedthatshort-termgainsinlivingstandardswouldinevitablybeunderminedas
Antibiotics,beforetheybecameusedasdrugs,werenaturalproducts.Anewfindingprovidesthefirstdirect【C1】______thatanti
Somepeoplethinkpeopleshouldlearntocompete,butothersthinkthatpeopleshouldbetaughttocooperate.Whatisyouropini
Credibilityaboutmessagesishigh,becausetheyarereportedinindependentmedia.Anewspaperreviewofamoviehasmorebeli
AMGEN,theworld’sbiggestbiotechnologycompany,madeitsfortunefromadrugthatfortifiesthebloodofpatientswhoareunde
Recentlyscientistshavebeen【C1】______andperfectingothersourcesofenergy:nuclearoratomicpower,solar(sun)power,ands
Weblasttheupbeattunesforpartiesandworkoutsatthegym,andwesavethelow-keyballadsforromanticorpensivemoments.
随机试题
A.4~5天B.6~7天C.7~9天D.10~12天E.14天上腹部手术拆线时间()
Pickouttheappropriateexpressionsfromtheeightchoicesbelowandcompletethefollowingdialoguesbyblackeningthecorresp
关于高血压治疗原则,正确的是
A.火性炎上B.火易伤津耗气C.火易生风D.火易动血E.火易发肿疡临床表现为疮疡局部红肿热痛,体现火邪的性质特点是()。
A公司应邀参加氮制造厂合成压缩工段技改工程投标,招标书说明,以工期安排最短、最合理为中标主要条件。A公司技术部门依据招标书指出的工程内容编制了网络计划图。网络计划附加说明:1.配管包括机泵本体配管25d,塔器本体配管20d,塔机间连接配管15d
消费者认识需要是由()引起的。
关于绩效面谈方式的表述,正确的是()。
一个对2500名6~13岁儿童的调查表明()。
(2009年真题)下列行为中,可以构成附条件民事法律行为的是
若干年前鲑鱼无法在这条污染严重的缺氧河中生存,许多其他种类生物同样无法生存。而如今,经过这些年的人工治理,鲑鱼已经重现。这是该条河不再受污染的可靠指标。下列各项都表明上述推理中可能存在缺陷,除了:
最新回复
(
0
)