首页
外语
计算机
考研
公务员
职业资格
财经
工程
司法
医学
专升本
自考
实用职业技能
登录
外语
The FDA may rescind its approval of Avastin, a colon-cancer drug. If the summer of 2009 was the season of "death panels," as
The FDA may rescind its approval of Avastin, a colon-cancer drug. If the summer of 2009 was the season of "death panels," as
admin
2011-04-11
12
问题
The FDA may rescind its approval of Avastin, a colon-cancer drug.
If the summer of 2009 was the season of "death panels," as the debate over health-care reform exploded, this is the season of "17.5k dead women a year." That’s the body count scaremongers are predicting if the Food and Drug Administration rescinds its provisional approval of the drug Avastin for metastatic breast cancer, a decision expected by year’s end. Although the move has nothing to do with the new health-care law, uncertainty about "Obama-care" has given opponents an opening to terrify people about what’s coming—like bureaucrats rationing health care to save money.
The reality is far different and, for those who care more about helping cancer patients than about scoring political points, much sadder. That’s because in 2008, when the FDA gave "fast track" approval for Avastin in breast cancer that has metastasized—usually to the lungs, bones, liver, or brain—it was conditional on the manufacturer, Genentech, running additional clinical trials of the drug’s safety and efficacy. There was good reason for that. Avastin is an angiogenesis inhibitor, a class of cancer drugs that have not lived up to their hype: although they stop one mechanism by which malignant cells grow blood vessels to sustain them, the cells often activate a different mechanism and go on proliferating.
Although Avastin does extend the lives of patients with metastatic colorectal and kidney cancer, and remains FDA-approved for those uses, the new studies show it does not work the same miracle against metastatic breast cancer (MBC). Instead, Avastin increased what’s called progression-free survival (how long before cancer spreads or grows) by about one to three weeks, depending on which chemo agent it was paired with. But it did not keep women alive any longer than chemo alone. To some advocates, progression-free survival without an increase in overall survival is still welcome, since it suggests patients have a better quality of life during their last months.
But it’s hard to make that case for Avastin. Not only did it not keep women alive, but it also caused hypertension, hemorrhaging, bowel perforations, and other side effects. "It seems as if the drug’s toxicity cancels out any benefit," cancer surgeon David Gorski of the Karmanos Cancer Institute told me. Perforated bowels do not equal a better quality of life.
These dismal results are what led an FDA panel to vote 12—1 in July to rescind the conditional approval of Avastin for MBC. Critics of health-care reform, predictably, saw nefarious motives-—in particular, evidence that Obamacare will ration expensive drugs. (Avastin costs some $88,000 a year, though few patients live that long.) The Wall Street Journal editorialized about the "Avastin mugging," and Sen. David Vitter accused the FDA of "assigning a value to a day of a person’s life. "
If Avastin did extend lives for, let’s say, $ 10,000 a day, Vitter might have a case. But it doesn’t extend life at all. That makes allegations like the 17,500 dead women (from a right-wing blog) "utter demagoguery of the most vile and despicable sort," Gorski wrote on the blog Science-Based Medicine.
There are stories galore of women with metastatic breast cancer who are alive "because of Avastin. " Indeed, patients have been flooding the airwaves and blogosphere with claims that Avastin helped them. But the only way to tell whether Avastin deserves the credit for keeping patients alive is through large studies. "There are always patients who live longer than average," biostatistician Donald Berry of the MD? Anderson Cancer Center told me. "They attribute it to the treatment; people love to make attributions. " But when the proportion of patients alive at any given time in a study is the same whether they are receiving Avastin or not—as the two large trials found—then crediting Avastin is "very likely wrong. " That some women did live longer on Avastin, Berry explained, "may simply reflect the natural heterogeneity of the disease and say nothing about the therapy. "
Doctors can keep prescribing Avastin for metastatic breast cancer off-label, though insurers will not pay for it. Some activists welcome that. There is "no evidence of clinical benefit from Avastin, yet there is harm," says Fran Visco, president of the National Breast Cancer Coalition. "We need to demand more of treatment before we unleash it on the public. " Science-based medicine isn’t always pretty. But it’s better than politics-based medicine, which is what some critics of the Avastin decision are practicing—and much better than deluding ourselves into thinking something works when it doesn’t.
Why may the FDA rescind its approval of Avastin?
选项
A、Because it may cause breast cancer to metastasize to other organs
B、Because it did not keep women alive.
C、Because it may cause side effects.
D、Because its toxicity outweighs its benefits.
答案
D
解析
美国食品与药品管理局为什么可能会撤销批准使用阿瓦斯丁?文章第三段提到晚期乳腺癌是指肿瘤细胞已经扩散到身体其他部位,并不是阿瓦斯丁造成的。文章第四段提到阿瓦斯丁并不能延长晚期乳腺癌病人的生命。第五段中提到阿瓦斯丁会带来一些副作用,但归根结底,撤销使用阿瓦斯丁的原因是使用阿瓦斯丁弊大于利。
转载请注明原文地址:https://kaotiyun.com/show/HAYO777K
0
专业英语八级
相关试题推荐
Whyshouldanyonebuythelatestvolumeintheever-expandingDictionaryofNationalBiography?Idonotmeanthatitisbad,as
Inthesummerof999,LeifEriksonvoyagedtoNorwayandspentthefollowingwinterwithKingOlafTryggvason.Substantiallythe
外来移民难道真的是欧洲社会难以摆脱的失业和高犯罪率的罪魁祸首吗?今天的欧洲或许算是一方乐土,吸引着非洲、亚洲、南美洲的许多年轻人背井离乡到这里来谋生求发展。更重要的是,西欧今天已经离不开移民。移民的到来对欧洲的经济社会发展,甚至改善欧洲人口年龄结构,起着不
TheexpandingInternationalSpaceStationhaslivingspace,alaboratory,storagemodulesandsolarpowerpanels.Nowitwillge
TheidealseasonforplantingthecropinthemainfieldisJuly-AugustorNovember-December.Plantingisdoneonraisedbedsof
TheidealseasonforplantingthecropinthemainfieldisJuly-AugustorNovember-December.Plantingisdoneonraisedbedsof
ThoughnottheidealshapeforaChristmasstocking,thisslimlittlevolumecouldneverthelessmakeawelcomeseasonalgift.La
ThoughnottheidealshapeforaChristmasstocking,thisslimlittlevolumecouldneverthelessmakeawelcomeseasonalgift.La
随机试题
血液中缓冲挥发酸最强的缓冲系统是
脊柱旁正中矢状层面的结构特点。
女孩,5岁,患有原发性肺结核,其病理转归最常见的是
关于氧疗,哪一项是错的?
A.砂仁B.豆蔻C.小茴香D.栀子E.蛇床子类球形,黄白色,有3条纵向槽纹,气芳香,味辛凉略似樟脑的药材是()。
杭州甲童装生产厂以“小太阳”为商标,生产童装,因为质量好,样式新,在当地有很大销量,甲童装生产厂于2005年12月1日向商标局寄出注册“小太阳”商标的申请文件,2005年12月5日到达商标局。乙童装生产厂见“小太阳”服装销量好,于是也于2005年12月3日
某公司为增值税一般纳税人,主要生产各种电动工具,适用的增值税税率为17%。增值税以1个月为一个纳税期,自期满之日起15日内申报纳税,增值税专用发票通过防伪税控系统开具。2012年7月10日该公司申报缴纳6月份增值税税款100万元。7月底,税务机关对该公司6
根据《国家赔偿法》的规定。下列各项中不能构成公安刑事赔偿的情形的是()。
在公元之初,牧师们将基督教在整个罗马帝国中传播开来,基督教的普及首先涉及的是各大城市的平民阶层。基督徒们反对皇权意识,因此君主们都把他们视为威胁,并组织起对他们的暴力摧残。然而这并没有中断新信仰的扩展,它一点点赢得了贵族阶级和最有影响力的人士,而且很快触及
燕子去了,有再来的时候;杨柳枯了,有再青的时候;桃花谢了,有再开的时候。但是,聪明的,你告诉我,【C6】______?——是有人偷了他们罢:那是谁?又藏在何处呢?是他们自己逃走了罢,现在又到了哪里呢?我不知道他们给了我多少日子;但我的手确乎是渐
最新回复
(
0
)