首页
外语
计算机
考研
公务员
职业资格
财经
工程
司法
医学
专升本
自考
实用职业技能
登录
外语
At Harvard College in September, a controversy erupted over the adoption of a "freshman pledge, " which for the first time asked
At Harvard College in September, a controversy erupted over the adoption of a "freshman pledge, " which for the first time asked
admin
2012-12-01
26
问题
At Harvard College in September, a controversy erupted over the adoption of a "freshman pledge, " which for the first time asked incoming students to sign a commitment to act with respect, integrity, and kindness in order to "promote understanding." Libertarian commentator Virginia Postrel, wrote that "treating ’kindness’ as the way to civil discourse doesn’t show students how to argue with accuracy and respect." Harry R. Lewis, a former dean of Harvard College and someone with an excellent perspective on undergraduate education, warned that it impinged on freedom of thought and that "a student would be breaking the pledge if she woke up one morning and decided it was more important to achieve intellectually than to be kind."
Has empathy become the new scapegoat in the long-standing concern about academic attainment in American schools? Books like Academically Adrift chart the decline in academic rigor on American college campuses, citing the plummeting hours that students spend on studying and critical thinking skills. But there’s also been a troubling, and concurrent decrease in empathy over the past thirty years. A study of 14, 000 college students published in Personality and Social Psychology Review in 2011 showed that the majority of college students today are less empathetic than their predecessors of prior decades. And other research even shows that education (like medical school!) can actually wring the empathy out of students.
Many people are squeamish about calls to increase empathy in young people because they wrongly assume that the ability to empathize is incompatible with traits like logic, reason, and impartiality. We’ve now entered a debate about how nice we should be or, rather, how nice we can afford to be and still stay competitive as a society, clinging to the pernicious belief that anything beneficial to young people must be painful and that we are in a rat race that is a zero-sum game.
In fact, there need be no tradeoff, at Harvard or anywhere else, between intellectual rigor and kindness. This is a false dichotomy, like the belief that a sick person must choose between a competent doctor and a humane one. Indeed, empathetic behavior—listening well, for example—actually makes a doctor better able to diagnose and treat illness, and studies show that when doctors are empathetic, their patients need less medication to relieve pain and less time to heal wounds.
People often equate empathy with gentleness and passivity. But empathy is really just a cognitive walk in another person’s shoes. An empathetic person is, fundamentally, a curious and imaginative person. Empathy involves a search for understanding. And we need today’s students to understand the world better in order to respond to its seemingly intractable problems.
Many educators agree that the intellectual skills required for the 21st century depend on not only a mastery of facts and figures, but also on complex communication, flexibility, collaboration, adaptability, and innovation. We live in a more open society than ever, with greater mixing of people and ideas.
The ability to master a new language, to translate scientific findings into policy, or to weave the concerns of one field into the terms of another (the way a Macintosh computer melds engineering and design), requires students to step outside of their own life experience and habits of mind. Steve Jobs had empathy for his customers.
Of course, we can always find examples of world-class thinkers who are oblivious to people’s feelings. But that doesn’t negate the fact that the vast majority of students will need to assume the perspective of others in order to get ahead in life. We can call this empathy. Or we can call it 21st century learning. It’s both. Empathy doesn’t always lead to more moral behavior, but it can lead to more intelligent behavior.
The author wants to argue in the passage that
选项
A、being kind and being smart are not mutually exclusive.
B、whether Harvard’s "freshman pledge" should be adopted or not.
C、empathy has become the new scapegoat of academic decline.
D、when the debate over Harvard’s "freshman pledge" will be ended.
答案
A
解析
主旨题。本文开篇提到引发作者讨论的事件“a controversy erupted over the adoption of a‘freshman pledge,’which for the first time asked incoming students to sign a commitment to act with respect,integrity,and kindness”。之后第二段提出问题“Has empathy become the new scape-goat in the long-standing concern about academic attainment in American schools?”,接着分析美国大学学术方面有所下降的现状。第三段和第四段作者给出自己的观点:人们认为移情和学术技能二者不可兼得的观点是错误的。第五至八段就自己的观点进一步展开分析和说明。因此可以看出,作者观点明确,认为做好人和聪明智慧并不矛盾,故[A]为答案。
转载请注明原文地址:https://kaotiyun.com/show/JFaO777K
0
专业英语八级
相关试题推荐
Asacontemporaryartist,JimDinehasoftenincorporatedotherpeople’sphotographyintohisabstractworks.But,the68-year-o
HowtoPlanYourFutureCareerForafewmonthsbeforegraduation,universitystudentsarebusywithjobhunting.Severalpoin
Asmoreandmorecollegestudentsprefertorentaroomoutsidethecampusandenjoytheirprivatelifethere,problemscomealo
ComingHome:LifeAfterStudyingAbroadManyreturneeswhohavestudiedabroadmaysufferre-entrycultureshockwhentheygo
LearningalanguageLinguistsareinterestedintheabilitiesthatpeoplehavetolearnlanguageandaretryingtosolvethepr
DemographyisthestatisticalstudyofhumanpopulationItcanbea-generalsciencethatcanbeappliedtoanykindofdynamicp
Threeweeksago,astorywepublishedputusinthemiddleofacontroversy.Itwashardlythefirsttimethathashappened,but
Threeweeksago,astorywepublishedputusinthemiddleofacontroversy.Itwashardlythefirsttimethathashappened,but
Shelly’ssnackshopwasthenamethatBrianEgemoofBadger,Iowa,appliedtohiswife’ssideofthebed.In1994Shelly,whoha
随机试题
参与细胞易化扩散的蛋白质是
依法为病人提供安全、有效、经济的优质药品和药学服务体现了( )。对病人的高度责任心和对药学事业的献身精神是( )。
房地产经纪服务费的管理主要从是否符合收费标准和()两个方面进行管理。
解决工程合同争议,应由( )起诉。
投标文件有下列()情形之一的由评标委员会初审后可按废标处理。
阅读下面材料,回答124~126题。材料一:党的作风问题,也是党的形象问题,作风不正,形象好不了,必然脱离群众、脱离实际。切不可小看了作风问题。领导干部作风好坏,做得如何,表现怎样,在有些人眼里都是“小事”、“小节”、“小问题”,看来无妨,似乎无害
32头牛和若干匹马韵价钱相等,如果把牛的头数和马的头数互换,马的头数再减少14头,此时二者的价钱又相等了。请问,每头牛和马的价格比为多少?
ln3原式
Mylittlebrotheristooyoung______gotoschool.
Juicemaybetasty,butit’snotreallythatnourishing.Whileorangejuiceisan【B1】_____sourceofvitaminC,itdoesn’tconta
最新回复
(
0
)