首页
外语
计算机
考研
公务员
职业资格
财经
工程
司法
医学
专升本
自考
实用职业技能
登录
外语
Why do readers of New Scientist continue to get steamed up about race? After all, it can be used as an innocuous technical term
Why do readers of New Scientist continue to get steamed up about race? After all, it can be used as an innocuous technical term
admin
2019-09-17
78
问题
Why do readers of New Scientist continue to get
steamed up
about race? After all, it can be used as an innocuous technical term by anthropologists. But all too often discussions of "race" lead to "racism", and tempers begin to fray. Before the 18th century, race merely described a group of common cultural origin, not one defined by immutable characteristics. Unfortunately, this usage changed as the Western powers colonized Asia and Africa and needed a way to characterize the peoples they subjected as not only different, but inferior.
A long list of scientists helped to "classify" the races. Among them were some of the famous names of the 18th and 19th centuries: Linnaeus, Cuvier, Haeckel, Huxley and Buffon. Although their classifications rarely agreed, many accepted that the races were fundamentally different and could be arranged with Caucasians at the top.
Only after the Darwinian evolution and the emergence of genetics did the notion of a league table start to crumble. By the 1940s, UNESCO could emphatically state: "Racism falsely claims that there is a scientific basis for arranging groups hierarchically in terms of psychological and cultural characteristics that are immutable and innate."
That groups cannot be arranged hierarchically does not mean that anthropologists cannot set up classifications which divide people into different groups, or that such classifications will not be useful, as several of our latter writers point out. For example, they can provide vital tools (along with language distribution) to reconstruct the prehistoric movements of peoples. Where genetic data are available, these reconstructions can be greatly refined.
In other contexts, such classifications are misleading. Many of the differences they record (including facial features, skin and hair color) are most probably superficial adaptations to local climate. Although useful as indicators of the origin of different groups, they imply nothing fundamental about differences between them.
Attempts to assess more important differences between groups (of any number of cognitive abilities, for example) always come to the same very well-known conclusion — that the differences between individuals within one racial group are much larger than the differences between the average members of two such groups.
What this means is that it is impossible to say anything about a particular individual’s ability because of his or her race (however, defined) because the spread of variation within a race is larger than the average difference between races. Racism can thus receive no support from science, even though a classification of races can be scientifically useful.
Lay people sometimes put more faith in the concept of race than scientists do, perhaps because they believe they can quite easily identify a person’s race or even nationality. But it’s not that easy: our correspondent from Le Vesinet, for example, identified some of the people in our recent feature ("Genes in Black and White") as Australian, Sicilian, Sumatran and Brazilian. In fact, they came from Sweden, Greece, the Central African Republic and Russia.
The classification of races by famous 18th- and 19th-century scientists were______.
选项
A、useful
B、hierarchical
C、valuable
D、significant
答案
B
解析
语义推理。根据第二段“Although their classifications rarely agreed,many accepted that the races were fundamentally different and could be arranged with Caucasians at the top”可知,尽管对他们的分类很少达成一致意见,但许多人都接受的观点是:种族之间存在根本性区别,而白种人(高加索人)至上。根据at the top可判断,他们认为种族之间存在等级,有高下之分。故B为正确选项。【知识拓展】语义推理(semantic inference)指的是依据词项之间的语义关系进行的推理。例如,从“白种人在顶部”可推出“有的人在底部”和“种族有高下之分”等。这种推理依据的是词项“种族”“白人”与“其他种族人”之间的语义关系。语义推理主要有三类:①同义关系推理;②上下义关系推理;③反义关系推理。这种语义推理也是种必然性推理,其推理的有效性是以正确分析词项的语义结构为基础,以恰当把握词项间的语义关系为前提的。由于语义推理是脱离特定语境而独立进行的,因而它不同于依赖特定语境的语用推理。
转载请注明原文地址:https://kaotiyun.com/show/JvwO777K
本试题收录于:
CATTI三级笔译综合能力题库翻译专业资格(CATTI)分类
0
CATTI三级笔译综合能力
翻译专业资格(CATTI)
相关试题推荐
NarratorListentopartofatalkinanenvironmentalscienceclass.Nowgetreadytoanswerthequestions.Youmayuseyournot
Mostecologistsbelievethatancientpopulationsofchipmunksdivergedgeneticallywhenisolatedfromoneanotherbymountainsa
In1831whenSmithwasfinallyrecognizedbytheGeologicalSocietyofLondonasthe"fatherofEnglishgeology,"itwasnotonl
Manypartsoftheworldarelosingimportantnaturalresources,suchasforests,animals,orcleanwater.Chooseoneresourceth
Somehighschoolsrequireallstudentstowearschooluniforms.Otherhighschoolspermitstudentstodecidewhattoweartosch
Howmuchmoneywillthemanbeabletoreceiveforhisbook?
Genesarethebiologicalinstructions______ineverycell.
1EarlyinlifeMarthaGrahamlearnedthat"movementneverlies."Whenshewasalittlegirl,herfatherwarnedhernevertolie
Therehasbeenmuchspeculationabouttheoriginofbaseball.In1907aspecialcommissiondecidedthatthemodemgamewasinven
Therehasbeenmuchspeculationabouttheoriginofbaseball.In1907aspecialcommissiondecidedthatthemodemgamewasinven
随机试题
下列对鉴别轻症和重症胰腺炎,有帮助的是
建设工程施工项目的安全检查应由()组织,定期进行。
关于资金时间价值,下列说法错误的是()。
日常会计核算工作的起点是()。
完善的积极人格包括六种美德,下列不属于积极人格中的美德的是()。
党政机关公文应由文秘部门或者专人统一管理,设立党委(党组)的()级以上单位应当建立机要保密室和机要阅文室,并按照有关保密规定配备工作人员和必要的安全保密设施设备。
本题为选做题,请在Ⅰ、Ⅱ两道试题中选取其中一道作答,若两题都回答,只按第Ⅰ道试题的成绩计入总分。选做题Ⅰ:以下是关于发展中国特色社会主义的相关材料:材料1改革开放以来我们取得一切成绩和进步的根本原因:开辟了中国特色社会主义道路,形成了中国特色社会主
CigarettesmokingisahealthhazardofsufficientimportanceintheUnitedStatestowarrantappropriateremedialaction.Itwa
Youaresupposedtodeliveraspeechaboutsub-healthpreventionattheopeningceremonyofannualSportsMeeting.Writethespe
设计名为form_book的表单(控件名为form1,文件名为formbook)。表单的标题设为“图书情况统计”。表单中有一个组合框(名称为Combo1)、一个文本框(名称为Text1)和两个命令按钮“统计”(名称为Command1)和“退出”(名称为C
最新回复
(
0
)