首页
外语
计算机
考研
公务员
职业资格
财经
工程
司法
医学
专升本
自考
实用职业技能
登录
外语
Let’s Not Hide Health Costs We are awash in health-care proposals. President Bush has one. So does California Gov. Arnold Sc
Let’s Not Hide Health Costs We are awash in health-care proposals. President Bush has one. So does California Gov. Arnold Sc
admin
2013-01-24
18
问题
Let’s Not Hide Health Costs
We are awash in health-care proposals. President Bush has one. So does California Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger. Democratic Sen. Ron Wyden has a plan, as does a coalition led by Families USA (a liberal advocacy group) and America’s Health Insurance Plans (a trade group). To some extent, all these plans and others aim to provide insurance to the estimated 47 million Americans who lack it—a situation widely deplored as a national disgrace. But the real significance of all these proposals, I submit, lies elsewhere.
For decades, Americans have treated health care as if it exists in a separate economic and political world: when people need care, they should get it; costs should remain out of sight.
About 60 percent of Americans receive insurance through their employers; to most workers, the full costs are unknown. The 65-and-older population and many poor people receive government insurance. Except for modest Medicare premiums and payroll taxes, costs are largely buried in federal and state budgets.
It is this segregation of health care from everything else that is now crumbling—and the various health proposals are just one sign. We see others all the time. For example, even with employer-provided insurance, workers’ monthly premiums (which cover only part of the costs) have skyrocketed. From 1999 to 2006, they doubled from $129 to $248.
Look at Massachusetts. Last year the then Gov. Mitt Romney made headlines by signing legislation to cover all the state’s uninsured. The law required that everyone with incomes three times the federal poverty line buy "affordable" insurance (people with incomes below that threshold would be subsidized on a sliding scale). Romney suggested annual premiums for a single worker might total $2,400. But when insurance companies recently provided real estimates, the cost was much higher: $4,560. Is it a sensible policy to force workers with a $30,000 income— about triple the poverty line— to spend nearly a sixth of their budget on health insurance, as opposed to food, rent or transportation? Good question.
The hard questions won’t sit still, because health care (now a sixth of the economy, up from an 11th in 1980) is too big to be hidden. Myths abound. Contrary to conventional wisdom, the doubling of premiums for employer-provided coverage doesn’t mean companies shifted a greater share of costs to workers. In both 1999 and 2006, premiums covered 27 percent of costs, says Paul Fronstin of the Employee Benefit Research Institute. It’s simply the rapid rise in total health spending that’s depressed workers’ take-home pay.
One myth about the uninsured is that, because they’re heavy users of emergency-room services, providing them with insurance (and regular care) would actually lower their costs. This may be true for some—but not most. The trouble is that the uninsured don’t really use emergency rooms heavily. A study on the journal Health Affairs finds that their use is similar to that of people with private insurance—and half that of people with Medicaid. The upshot is that extending insurance to all the uninsured would be costly, because they would get more and (presumably) better care. John Sheils of the Lewin Group estimates the annual cost of their care would rise 75 percent to $145 billion.
Our health-care system will inevitably combine government regulation and private enterprise. But what should the mix be? Which patients, providers and technologies should be subsidized and why? How important is health care compared with other public and private goals? Will an expanding healthcare sector spur the economy—or, through high taxes and insurance premiums, retard it? We have refused to have this debate for obvious reasons. A friend of mine recently had a near-death experience; he survived only because he had superb medical care. Debating health care makes us queasy, because it pits moral imperatives (including the right to live) against coldhearted economics.
I don’t intend to examine—at least now—all the new proposals. Some would do better at some goals (say, protecting the poor) than at others (say, controlling costs). But the Bush proposal does have one huge virtue: it exposes health-care costs to the broad public. By not taxing employer-paid insurance, the government now provides a huge invisible subsidy to workers. Bush wouldn’t end the subsidy, but by modifying it with specific deductions for insurance ($15,000 for families, $7,500 for singles), he would force most workers to see the costs. By contrast, some other proposals disguise their costs. Schwarzenegger’s plan shifts costs to the federal government, doctors and hospitals. It’s clever, but it perpetuates the illusion that health care is cheap—or even free.
However our health system evolves—with more government control or more market influence—Americans need to come to a more realistic understanding of its limits. Underestimating its costs and exaggerating its benefits guarantees disappointment. If the present outpouring of proposals signals a start of our needed debate, then it is long overdue.
According to the author, the real significance of health proposals is_____.
选项
A、to solve health problems
B、to show that health care is cheap
C、to provide insurance to the uninsured
D、to treat health care in a realistic way
答案
D
解析
作者在第一段结尾说,健康提议的真正意义在于别处,并不是给未投保的人提供保险(B)。在最后一段,作者指出,应对卫生体制有一个现实的认识(D)。故D为正确答案。
转载请注明原文地址:https://kaotiyun.com/show/KMaO777K
0
专业英语八级
相关试题推荐
TheEnglishVocabularyVocabularyisacompleteinventoryofthewordsinalanguage.Itcanbedividedintoactivevocabulary
TheEnglishVocabularyVocabularyisacompleteinventoryofthewordsinalanguage.Itcanbedividedintoactivevocabulary
TheEnglisharemainlydescendantsof______,whowereagroupofpeoplethatoccupiedlandsstretchingfromtheBritishIslest
WhichofthefollowingisnotthenativepeopleinCanada?
NonverbalCommunicationNonverbalcommunicationisusuallyreferredtoasthe"hiddendimension"ofcommunication,whichisa
Theterm"formallearning"isusedinthispapertorefertoalllearningwhichtakesplaceintheclassroom,withoutregardto
A、FormerPresidentofRussiaYeltsindiedofaheartattackat76.B、BillClintonandhiswifeareexpectedtoattendonbehalf
洋教师说:“这文章写得当然好,而且绝妙无比,你们听——”他拿起作文念起来,“我们学校最美的地方,不是教室,不是操场,也不是校门口那个带喷水的小花坛,而是食堂。瞧,玻璃干净得几”乎叫你看不到它的存在——”洋教师念到这儿,眼睛调皮地一亮,眉毛一挑,“听听,多么
现代化的交通、电信与大众传媒手段使世界越来越小,国际社会如同一个地球村,居住在地球村里的各国人民在文化交流和冲撞中和睦相处、彼此尊重、共求发展。我赞同这样的看法:当代社会的民族文化不可能在自我封闭的状态下得到发展。在我看来,不同的文化应该相互学习
随机试题
用滚刀精铣蜗轮是一种啮合对滚过程,因此应使工件绕其轴线自由转动。()
甲向乙发生要约:购买黄豆5000吨,价格为1200元/吨,15日内承诺有效。在乙承诺前,甲又于发出要约后第10日发来传真,提出取消该要约。下列表述中正确的是()
A.右下腹痛伴腹腔内出血B.转移性右下腹痛伴板状腹C.触痛性腹部包块D.右下腹痛向会阴部放射E.右下腹压痛,其部位可随体位改变胃、十二指肠溃疡穿孔可表现为
孕妇28岁,孕1产0,孕29周,骨盆测量:髂嵴间径26cm,髂前上棘间径25cm,骶耻外径18.5cm,坐骨结节间径9cm,骶岬不突,骶骨弧度中等,坐骨棘内突,坐骨切迹宽,耻骨弓角度100°。该孕妇骨盆属于下列哪种类型
A.糖皮质激素B.阿托品C.柳氮磺吡啶栓D.布桂嗪(强痛定)E.洛哌丁胺(易蒙停)克罗恩病患者排便次数过多时应选用
以下有关皮瓣的叙述中,哪项是错误的
A、膈下游离气体B、鹰嘴样阴影C、杯口状阴影D、肿瘤状阴影E、大小肠均胀气乙状结肠扭转的X线表现
库伯等人的“心理旋转”实验说明表象具有()。
聚类的典型应用不包括_______(1),______(2)是一个典型的聚类算法。(2)
BodyLanguageinBusinessI.ImportanceofBodyLanguage—Giveothersa(n)【T1】_____【T1】______—Showour【T2】_____【T2】______—F
最新回复
(
0
)